3 ms·
The Ship of Theseus was gaining and losing mass at a molecular level constantly. So from a scientific analysis, it is the concept that remains, and the materia
by r00fus 10y ago
The Ship of Theseus was gaining and losing mass at a molecular level constantly.
So from a scientific analysis, it is the concept that remains, and the materials/constituency of the whole are details that must be abstracted (unless you have a way to diff at the molecular and/or subatomic level).
From an philosophical view of identity, I don't see much in past works that recognize how a person changes through their life path - I would most certainly make some different decisions than the 20y ago self - does that mean I am a different person? If not, then how do you determine identity? For every moment could it possibly be that you are a different person, and there are infinite instances of "you"?
- Retric 10y agoFrom a physics standpoint every single electron is the same electron they have the same identity and that's not a problem. Which is why I think this argument is ridiculous. People approach philosophy trying to get their mutually contradictory assumptions to work out rather than accept some assumptions are wrong. Human identity is a social construct not a physical one, so it only needs to work in human terms. PS: Yes, that means I and You have no well defined meaning, they also don't need a well defined meaning to be useful.
- r00fus 10y ago> From a physics standpoint every single electron is the same electron they have the same identity and that's not a problem. Cite? This is an unproven hypothesis.
- Retric 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identical_particles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identical_particles I don't mean there is only one electron ever or something like that, just you can't actually distinguish them. There is also math which works better if Electrons have no identity. "The fact that particles can be identical has important consequences in statistical mechanics. Calculations in statistical mechanics rely on probabilistic arguments, which are sensitive to whether or not the objects being studied are identical."