3 ms·
If you define the value of an infinite operation as its limit, as mathematicians normally do, then you can make a limit argument for an infinite product of many
by schoen 10y ago
If you define the value of an infinite operation as its limit, as mathematicians normally do, then you can make a limit argument for an infinite product of many numbers 0<n<1 being zero because each additional number that you multiply makes the product smaller, and you can find a point at which they will go smaller than any chosen positive number. In the epsilon-delta concept of limits (you challenge me to show where the value becomes closer than an epsilon of your choice to the purported limit; I show you where that happens) this then suffices to show that the limit is 0.
For example, suppose we multiply 0.9 by itself an infinite number of times. If we want it to be smaller than epsilon, we have to multiply it ceil(log_0.9(epsilon))+1 times. For instance, if you want it to get smaller than 0.01, the formula shows you should multiply it 45 times (actually 44 times suffices; the +1 is just for the case where it equals epsilon exactly). Here 0.9⁴⁵=0.00872796356808771242 which is indeed smaller than 0.01.
- schoen 10y agoA question that came to mind for me from this: is there any sequence k such that all 0<kₓ<1 and the product of all kₓ converges to something greater than 0? While each partial product must be smaller than the preceding one, is it possible to make k grow fast enough toward 1 that the rate of diminution of the partial products slows enough that they converge to a positive limit? I'm pretty sure that the answer is yes, but not certain!
- schoen 10y agoAs a clarification for anyone reading this later, "where the value becomes closer" means "where the value becomes (and thereafter remains) closer".