4 ms·
The greater the marketing hype before a film arrives in my town, the greater the inevitable disappointment. Perhaps Arrival is great, but imho the truly great
by sandworm101 10y ago
The greater the marketing hype before a film arrives in my town, the greater the inevitable disappointment. Perhaps Arrival is great, but imho the truly great ones don't invest in such a hype machine.
The "100% at rotten tomatoes" line in the commercials give me pause. I checked. It's at 95, not 100. I can see why. Scores do change, but it's just more evidence of heavy marketing. The best scifi, the really good stuff, doesn't hit a home run with reviewers immediately. I'm suspicious and so will probably go see this movie myself first rather than suggest a group of us go.
- macintux 10y agoIt's flawed, certainly, but I found it compelling. Took me quite a while through the credits before I could compose myself to leave. Probably the best $5 I've spent in a long time (morning showing).
- chroma 10y ago> The best scifi, the really good stuff, doesn't hit a home run with reviewers immediately. Wait, so your expectations for the movie would be higher if the Rotten Tomatoes score was lower?
- BatFastard 10y agoI pay more attention to the user rating than the critics rating, critics are either paid off, or what they like in a movie is different than most movie goers.
- Jtsummers 10y agoHard to avoid spoilers this way, but the best way to consider critic reviews is to focus on the negative ones. If a movie gets 95% on Rotten Tomatoes, and the negative reviews are all rather inane, you can be reasonably confident that it's actually a good movie. But when they start making valid points, you can be confident it's merely overhyped.
- sandworm101 10y ago>> Wait, so your expectations for the movie would be higher if the Rotten Tomatoes score was lower? Yes. A good movie should be hated by certain reviewers. There are a great many reviewers with radically different tastes than mine. The chances of us all agreeing about a movie are slim. So when I see "100%" I am suspicious.
- DGAP 10y agoIt's very good, I'd recommend seeing it. Avoid spoilers if you can. The cinematography is gorgeous and the whole movie just feels extremely tight and well put together with nothing extraneous. Its small flaws are overshadowed by just how good it is. HN commenters just like to shit on things as soon as they're popular to feel smart.
- sandworm101 10y ago>> Avoid spoilers if you can. That's another red flag for me. The great scifi remains watchable over and over. Knowing the plot, not being surprised, should not take much away from a properly good movie. When people tell me not to read spoilers they are suggesting to me that the film is considerably less watchable without the surprises. True be told, pretty much every "giant ships" scifi follows the predictable path. We see the ships, we get scared. Some government types then want to nuke them while a band of heros (a couple government types + an emotionally-damaged scientist + the human interest character) tries to convince everyone to calm down and see the good in the aliens (Godzilla 2015). Or the opposite, where the scientist is the one screaming danger (Independence Day). The only surprise is whether or not the world actually ends ... but knowing that fact in advance doesn't take much from a good movie. We knew that the aliens would eventually die (it was a War of the Worlds remake) and we knew that Godzilla would win. They remain as watchable the second or tenth time you see them.
- schoen 10y agoWhile the Hollywood-added differences from Chiang's story are pretty much just as you described, there is also a plot arc retained from the original that's different from this.
- macintux 10y agoI'd gladly rewatch it, but is it really so hard to imagine that a surprising plot is worth being unspoiled? You're trying awfully hard to dislike a movie you haven't seen.
- sandworm101 10y ago
- betageek 10y agoYou're wrong about this one but I guess that's your loss. It's a fantastic adaptation and takes what is already a great story and uses the full arsenal of film making to turn it into something truly moving. I think the marketing/hype is just a studio decision - they got an amazing film with known stars for a cut price $47 million so it's worth a punt on marketing to make it a big release.
- gohrt 10y agoSurely there's a difference between "hyped by many reviewers and related journalism" and "hyped by McDonald's and 7-11 tie-ins"
- geden 10y agoI'm very curious about what you consider to be "the best scifi, the really good stuff". Could you name some examples? Very few decent SF scripts go into production, even fewer with such amazing talent on board (Villeneuve, Johannsson, Adams) etc. Arrival is not just one of the best SF films this year, it's one of the best films this year. Villeneuve and Johannsson weren't handed Bladerunner 2 for no good reason :)
- sandworm101 10y agoI'd draw a line between the good scifi and the good theatre movies. There is some great scifi out there that isn't for general consumption in theatres. I'd call Akira (1988) one of the greats, but not the sort of thing I would see in a theater with a mixed group of friends. On the other hand, I didn;t like the Matrix movies much but would have to agree that were fun in theatres. Some people found them great, but they haven't aged well imho. I saw the original Jurassic Park probably 10 times in theatres. That was a great scifi theatre movie. If it came out today I would recommend it to my friends.