2 ms·
The main difference is the verification/design method. seL4 does the abstract machine in Haskell, model in HOL, and final code in C. Both Haskell and C are show
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
The main difference is the verification/design method. seL4 does the abstract machine in Haskell, model in HOL, and final code in C. Both Haskell and C are shown equivalent. It took a ton of work. They also have to use these two tools for expressing all kinds of solutions they're not ideal for.
CertiKOS is using a DSL approach if it's same as paper I'm remembering. They design languages or proving techniques ideal to the type of thing they're working on: memory management, I/O, etc. They prove each individual component as easily as they can. Then they have some way of modeling the system as a whole and/or integrating those. Too early to judge but they seem more productive than L4 project was due to tooling benefits.
- indolering 10y agoAccording to one of the talks I watched, they are moving towards using more domain-specific languages.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThat's ambiguous. Are you talking about seL4 or CertiKOS people?
- indolering 10y agoThe seL4 team, they have taken this approach with their drivers and ext2 implementation. Apparently it is part of a more general strategy [0]. [0] https://archive.fosdem.org/2015/schedule/event/sel4/ https://archive.fosdem.org/2015/schedule/event/sel4/
- nickpsecurity 10y agoOk. Good they're doubling down on it.