3 ms·
Ah, you're talking about the philosophical concept of whether random even exists. As far as we (humanity) know, true randomness is still a thing. Quantum effec
by dahart 10y ago
Ah, you're talking about the philosophical concept of whether random even exists.
As far as we (humanity) know, true randomness is still a thing. Quantum effects have no known predictors. From the article I linked: "Quantum mechanics predicts that certain physical phenomena, such as the nuclear decay of atoms, are fundamentally random and cannot, in principle, be predicted"
So Quantum science believes that true random does exist. Until someone demonstrates otherwise, or I start working on the problem, I'm good accepting that for now. The tests to demonstrate these ideas are fascinating: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_test_experiments https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_test_experiments
In the mean time, there's the very real concept of whether something is practically predictable, and a Geiger counter is currently not practically predictable. (And worth noting, it lands into the category of currently not theoretically predictable too.)
Personally, I feel like the definition "unpredictable" is quite good, especially for regular people. Going deeper than that requires all kinds of baggage and explanation. But the point the author made is very good -- people tend to start expecting things when "randomness" is involved, and that expectation is a problem, because randomness is unpredictable.
- UhUhUhUh 10y agoAgreed. I tend to cringe at essentialism, which can be applied to any concept. At the same time, I cringe at its opposite. If the idea of an unknown entity is not entertained, held in suspension as it were, in one's mind, I think that theory suffers. As you point out, "practically predictable" is where I would stand. Or "random enough". When I was little, in France, I was explained that the Meter was defined according to the length of a platinum alloy standard sitting in an institute in Paris... Bottom line: Randomness, is a philosophical concept, predictability is a scientific concept, asymptotic to 0, another needed absolute...