5 ms·
I agree with all of these points and am rather a pro-nuclear myself. But the Chernobyl / Fukushima risk cannot be dismissed. What would be great is a form of nu
by cm2187 10y ago
I agree with all of these points and am rather a pro-nuclear myself. But the Chernobyl / Fukushima risk cannot be dismissed. What would be great is a form of nuclear energy that doesn't run this meltdown risk. I hear contradictory opinion on Thorium. Does Thorium eliminate this risk?
- maverick_iceman 10y ago28 people died in Chernobyl, 0 in Fukushima. How many have died due to coal related air pollution? And this is completely ignoring global warming effects of coal fired plants.
- Retric 10y agoNot an expert, but 28 is very much a low estimate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_di... A United Nations study estimates the final total of premature deaths associated with the disaster will be around 4000 However, the rather large exclusion zones are another large risk. The cost of insurance to pay for such events is very significant.
- cm2187 10y agoThe cost to Ukraine's economy is not small too. There is still a large part of Ukraine where you cannot grow anything.
- acidburnNSA 10y agoCorrect. I usually include the up-to 4000 early cancer deaths in my comparisons. Still pales compared to air-pollution deaths from coal.
- tremon 10y agoIf we don't factor in the number of premature deaths from air pollution in coal fuel figures, why should we factor in the number of premature deaths from radiation in nuclear fuel figures?
- hyperbovine 10y agoIt's not just the deaths. The Chernobyl exclusion zone is 1000 sq. mi., i.e. 1/6500th of the entire country of Russia (the largest on earth). That's pretty amazing when you think about it.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> But the Chernobyl / Fukushima risk cannot be dismissed. Chernobyl was a massive fuck-up that IIRC wasn't even possible in Western plants of the time, let alone afterwards. Fukushima demonstrates the risks of building a power plant in a tsunami zone, but its death toll is zero, and even the worst estimates of cancer deaths are only in the hundreds. A single coal mining disaster kills more than that, and we have them fairly regularly. In short, the risk can be dismissed, especially if you factor in the risks of things like coal mining and emissions.
- cm2187 10y agoThe thing is you could argue in the same way about anything dangerous. CDO only blew up during the financial crisis because of investors overleveraging. If investors had not fucked up, the financial crisis wouldn't have been that bad. Bophal only happened because industrials fucked up, improperly storing chemicals close to a populated area. The problem is rather that overleveraged financial products and chemical products are dangerous. They are safe if handled with care by responsible people who understand what they are doing. But they are inherently a danger because sooner or later someone who doesn't know or doesn't care ends up handling them.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> The thing is you could argue in the same way about anything dangerous. You can and you should. You need to work the numbers, and the numbers will tell you that indeed chemical plants are a problem and financial industry is a problem. But nuclear energy? Not really.
- hyperbovine 10y agoIf you had told me in 2010 that the most conservative and competent engineering culture on the planet could suffer a preventable nuclear disaster I'd never have believed you. If the Japanese can't get it right...
- snuxoll 10y agoMolten-salt reactors like LFTR's are extremely safe against catastrophic meltdown and are probably the best path forward, but we still need to actually put theory into practice with them. Gen IV traditional reactor designs are much improved over what was used in Fukushima as well, but with that said there has probably been fewer casualties from nuclear energy disasters than people that have contracted illnesses or died from our use of coal in particular.
- cm2187 10y agoCasualty count is one thing, but transforming entire regions into no man's land is not a small price to pay. Can Molten-salt reactors be used with uranium too or do we need to develop a Thorium based industry from scratch?
- snuxoll 10y agoThorium is just one choice for a molten-salt reactor, U-235 is a feasible fuel source as well. Also, as far as the "no-mans land" comment, there's only been two incidents in our entire history of using Nuclear energy that did this: Chernobyl and Three-Mile Island. Both of which are horrible losses, but Fukushima is not anywhere near as disastrous. The region will be essentially uninhabitable for 30 years, but after that the half-life of the longest-lived element from the disaster will have decayed naturally. Not great, but considering the much longer impact global warming will have a 20Km radius of land being unusuable for 1/3 of a century doesn't seem so bad in comparison - of course, with modern reactor designs (Fukushima was built in '67!) this whole thing could have been avoided entirely even though it was in a Tsunami zone (although a MSR could have had negative consequences, there would have been no issue just pumping seawater in immediately to cool the reactor and stop the reaction - it would have contaminated the water and possible corroded the containment, all of your critical reactor would be dead stopped and the rest of the radioactive material sealed in a giant chunk of salt instead of blown/washed away ending up in the soil).
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoWhat? Three-Mile Island transformed an entire region into no-mans land? I don't think that's accurate. I have relatives living just a few miles away.
- saulrh 10y agoIf you want to only consider nuclear by looking at its worst-case, you have to do the same with its competitors for the comparison to be fair, which turns out to be even more favorable to nuclear than the naive examination - banqiao dam, global climate change, people falling off roofs and turbines, etc. Even if nuclear power plants continue to fail at the same rate as they have historically, or five or ten times the historical rate, I'd take them over existing power sources in a heartbeat.
- cm2187 10y agoBut the problem is precisely this worst case, and dismissing it will not help its cause. If you look at it through any other lens than this worst case, it is a no brainer, go 90% nuclear. But this worst case is what will drive public opinion and political support.
- 08-15 10y ago> Does Thorium eliminate this risk? sigh (I hear this too often.) No, it doesn't. Thorium in conventional, solid fuel reactors is useless. Also, conventional, solid fuel reactors are a relatively dumb idea. We need better reactors. We have known that since around 1954. One particular design of a more efficient, safer, and likely cheaper reactor would benefit from being fuelled with Thorium. But it's about the reactor, not the Thorium! By the way, Chernobyl and Fukushima were very different events. Different reactors, different physics, different ourcome. Don't get hung up on Thorium, learn something about reactor physics instead.