5 ms·
I don't fully know why people are so anti-nuclear in general. I'll be the first to admit that wind and solar are what society should aim for, but I don't full
by tombert 10y ago
I don't fully know why people are so anti-nuclear in general.
I'll be the first to admit that wind and solar are what society should aim for, but I don't full that, with our current implementations of them, that they're quite ready for a 7-billion-people level of energy needs.
I feel like nuclear could be a good way to get us using (relatively) clean energy and get people using electric vehicles in the relatively short-term.
- dbingham 10y agoThere's a degree to which it is a zero sum system. If wind and solar is where we should be eventually, then resources put into nuclear now aren't going into wind/solar research and infrastructure building. And nuclear's not cheap. Plus, while nuclear can be done safely, it often isn't, and when it fails, it fails catastrophically. So it's scary for a lot of people. People have to trust not just that nuclear _can_ be done safely, but that it _will_ be done safely. That second one, especially, is a big leap for lots of folks.
- wbl 10y agoThere have only been three accidents at level 5 at commercial nuclear power plants, ever. Only one (Chernobyl) resulted in any casualties. The exclusion zones around Fukushima are as radioactive as Denver.
- tekmate 10y agoand 30 years later the wild hogs in germany are still radioactive thanks to all the caesium in the ground, trying to downplay the effects of these catastrophic events, no matter how rare they are, isn't very helpful
- htns 10y agoThey are still perfectly safe to eat. There isn't even an effect to downplay.
- tekmate 10y agojust because it's a rationale for people to be vocally against nuclear doesn't mean it's rational
- ComputerGuru 10y ago> and 30 years later the wild hogs in germany are still radioactive So is the 300 million year old chunk of coal being burned in a factory and that banana you ate yesterday... This is how FUD spreads. What does it even mean for something to "be radioactive?" How much "radioactive" is bad?
- Pokepokalypse 10y agoYou're conflating ideas. Yes, Potassium and even radioactive Caesium are flushed out of the body. (whether Caesium is, is controversial). Iodine accumulates in the body (but has a short half-life). Strontium, and several other elements build-up. They bio-accumulate. So yes, you can eat a radioactive wild hog, and be safe. If you eat them for dinner once a week, you will very likely, eventually, suffer ill health effects, possibly even cancer. This is not a problem for hog hunters in Germany. It is a problem for Rice farmers in Japan. Because those guys eat a lot of rice, all day, every day. Plus, the rice is often processed into other products, and combined into other foods as starch or protein supplements, so even people who don't eat rice are getting some exposure. After Fukushima, the strategy was not to dump all the radioactive rice. They dumped everything with high levels; and then the rice with medium levels, they mixed it in with uncontaminated rice, to make the overall level low enough to be below regulatory thresholds (which they raised after Fukushima). Now, it's going to be found in your rice-chex cereal in America. Your protein-bar in France. Your chewing gum in Africa. Is any of that going to kill you? It probably raises anyone's chance of eventually getting cancer by .001%. Yes, there's no way to prove it, no way to sue anybody, or collect damages. If you survive the cancer, you're still the person who has to pay for it. If you don't get cancer, you still pay for it, because your insurance premium covers the increased risk to your pool. You - the person affected - pay for this. The people who made profit; the shareholders, don't care.
- ComputerGuru 10y ago> Plus, while nuclear can be done safely, it often isn't Huh? Citation certainly needed since by ANY metric you are 100% incorrect. Count the number of nuclear subs, nuclear power plants, plutonium power sources, controlled fusion reactions in testing, fission reactions being carried out across the globe by nations at different stages of development, etc and tell me it is "often" not done safely. The fact that nuclear is so scary to get wrong is precisely why we (by and large) get it right.
- CapitalistCartr 10y agoThat's the problem: by and large isn't good enough. No one wants a meltdown in their country. Its why the US military stopped carrying nuclear weapons in airplane bomb bays; they lost a bunch. With nukes, any is horrifying. A cite? Kyshtym, Chernobyl, Fukushima, . . . https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_civilian_nuclear_accidents https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_civilian_nuclear_acc... P.S. I'm still a proponent of nuclear power. It beats coal all to hell. I don't think denying the risks helps; a rational discussion of the benefits and risks of each method better serves us all.
- ceejayoz 10y agoThe US military stopped carrying nukes in planes because of ICBMs.
- CapitalistCartr 10y agoWe had ICBM's before 1970. It was dropping too many that killed it. Like 4 on Spain. Solid-fueled missiles didn't help ease the fear over a first strike much; they're still vulnerable.
- ceejayoz 10y agoThe Minuteman entered service in 1962, and the long-lived Minuteman III entered service in 1968 - same exact year Operation Chrome Dome ended. It became pretty clear that ICBMs were a lot more effective than trying to get a B-52 through Soviet air defense.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 0xfeba 10y ago> Plus, while nuclear can be done safely, it often isn't, and when it fails, it fails catastrophically. And thus is the problem with the court of public opinion on this. Nuclear is the safest per Kw/h, period. But yes, there are accidents and they are plastered over the news for weeks. Whereas coal mining disasters? Well it's just coal mining, not related to the coal power plant that coal was all headed too.
- Roritharr 10y agoI remember writing a similar HN comment shortly before Fukushima, feeling very smart at the time. Well Fukushima happened and left me wondering if we as humans are able to maintain something that can generate so much potentially irreversible damage, with our tendencies to cut-corners, wing-it and just being less than perfect. I hang my hat in shame over that comment everytime I read of more irradiated water leaking into the Pacific.
- adrianN 10y agoYou have to weigh the alternatives. Continuing to use coal for base load is much worse for almost everyone compared to nuclear.
- Roritharr 10y agoAlmost everyone living right now. And yes you are right, coal is horrible. But atleast i can imagine some piece of technology sucking co2 and other toxic gasses out of the atmosphere. Less so with irradiated Elements. How to get radioactive saltwater out of the Pacific? Can't imagine how one would go about cleaning that mess up. Think of the near SciFi Solutions Tepco tries to Contain the irradiated groundwater. If you have to spend the Energy equivalent of another nuclear powerplant trying to create artificial Frozen earth barriers just to POTENTIALLY contain the mess you've made... Things get surreal.
- adrianN 10y agoBurning coal releases plenty of radioactive ash right into the atmosphere.
- stale2002 10y agoOK, but nuclear waste existed before we took it out of the ground. That stuff was still radioactive BEFORE. Also, putting it in a safe place is easy. Just pick your favorite mountain in a desert. No ground water there.
- Pokepokalypse 10y ago
- etaty 10y agoLet's think like internet. Nuclear is the mainframe. Big, powerful, ... but when it goes down everything goes with it. (centralized) Solar/Wind are small unit of production, they don't do much individually, cheap and in a network they improve their reliability. (decentralized)
- TeMPOraL 10y agoLet's think like industry. Factories are extremely efficient, able to produce lots of stuff for very cheap by means of economies of scale, which leads to lots of goods available for consumers. Home manufacturing is very inefficient, wasting energy and material. Which is why nobody does it to produce goods for mass consumption. Seriously. I'm fascinated by the Internet too, but it's like people are forgetting that centralization == efficiency, distribution == waste. There are ways to achieve reliability without totally decentralizing the grid, and what we need now is not adding few more nines after decimal point of the already 99.999something% reliable grid. We need efficiency all across the board to reduce waste.
- vmarsy 10y agoWith electricity generation, thinking like a regular industry would also be very inefficient. It's well known that there's a lot of wasted energy in the electrical lines to transport the electricity from the centralized plant to the end users, even with crazy high voltage aiming at reducing losses. An optimal setup would probably be a not-too-fine-grain decentralized setup
- AstralStorm 10y agoNot much loss in high voltage lines and required transformers. (Use Ohm's law.) Much less than inefficiencies inherent in tiny power plants, which can rob you of more than half power in the fuel of it were burnt in an efficient plant. (Cooling on a small scale is especially hard.) Similarly with wind turbines, less with solar. These losses are accounted for and are a reason (other than problems building really massive plants) why there are more than one in every country.
- deleted 10y ago
- akamaka 10y agoI'm anti-nuclear because we don't really know how much it costs. The cost of cleaning up after very rare disasters has to be worked into the price, but the Fukushima incident is still ongoing. We're not even sure if the current efforts will prevent more radiation leaks, and perhaps the cost will continue to climb.
- revscat 10y agoWe know quite well what it costs. I believe you are making a mistake by using "we" for "I" in your first sentence.
- Pokepokalypse 10y agoWhen the US originally decided to build out plants in the 1960's, the plan was for 1000 plants. We ended up with just over 100. Each construction was filled with delays and cost-overruns. Then, we ran those plants, based on out-dated designs, long after they were intended to be torn down and replaced. Even some plants that were upgraded, had flaws that prevented them from being used, (SONGS is a good example), so they had to be shut down. The industry won't pay for R&D for new designs. They won't invest in proper maintenance and training. They barely keep their word on decomissioning schedules. Waste storage is a huge, huge problem, that nobody has addressed yet. (except the French). And even fuel reprocessing doesn't fully solve the problem. I think it's a great technology, and there are awesome new designs that could be researched, tested, and put into production. But the industry has to actually pay for this shit and do it. And that's just not happening. The finance side of the industry is still stuck in 1960's models. Operators are finding that these plants aren't even profitable to operate, compared to natural gas plants. (so nuclear is very vulnerable to short-term energy market fluctuations after you've invested billions of dollars into construction). Also: insurance is not insignificant, when there is a risk of accident that will contaminate land around the plant for hundreds of square miles. That's all "someone else's property" - and those people need to be compensated. What if it's a farmer, who would have generated revenue with that land for the next 100 years (while we wait for the cesium and strontium to decay or wash out of the soil)? Insurance funds do not cover that kind of loss.
- melling 10y agoMuch of the HN crowd is against nuclear. We had the debate 3 weeks ago when I posted this TED talk: https://www.ted.com/talks/michael_shellenberger_how_fear_of_nuclear_power_is_hurting_the_environment?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/michael_shellenberger_how_fear_of_... You can read past arguments here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12777901 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12777901
- dv_dt 10y agoI used to be pro Nuclear, nowadays I feel that all the people looking at the benefits of Nuclear miss a few big things. They overestimate the maturity of the tech (x1000 for the maturity of the materials development in the designs as opposed to the Nuclear reaction itself), far understate the risks and pretty much ignore the economics. And by economics I include operating costs, but also rarely discussed: the ability of private markets to finance, build, and start pulling profits from a power project in a reasonable time-frame. If that second part isn't possible, then building lots of anything isn't going to happen easily. There is a big difference in 40 x1 billion projects and one 40 billion project - and one way that plays out is in the likelihood of any project getting spun up and succeeding even if all other things are equal. But all other thing are not equal, in operating costs, Nuclear is less economically productive than wind energy by far, and soon solar (or perhaps already more-expensive when one figures in overruns, gov't support, etc..). There is a point in that Nuclear can provide "baseload", but it's fairly incompatible with varying renewable supply as it doesn't seem to cycle up or down fast enough to be really be paired with a renewable supply. Energy storage, while also being immature, is likely to improve much more rapidly than the relative slow design development of Nuclear tech. I don't want to be unnecessarily negative regarding Nuclear (and am excited about potential future fusion developments - esp the small scale designs), but I think there's a lot more holding Nuclear back than simply anti-nuclear activism.
- 7952 10y agoI dont think the public are particularly against nuclear. Most major developments have opposition. And any project as costly will have concerns simply from a project managment perspective. I don't think you can blame protestors for massive financial risk that investors are scared of. Lucrative projects that are much more environmentally damaging go ahead all the time afterall.