14 ms·
Is Nuclear Power Vital to Hitting CO2 Emissions Targets?
- wiz21c 10y agoSaying it's vital is not going to help. the question is : how much time and money do we have to be carbon free. Is nuclear power helping to reach that target or not ? Saying it's vital is equivalent to saying "do we really really really want it ?" And of course, a lot of uniformed opinions will come up... let me remind you that 1/ nuclear is bad when it breaks 2/ solar/wind is hyper expensive to build in quantities large enough to cover our needs So which evil will we choose ?
- toyg 10y agoEasy: money is immaterial in the long run, the planet does not care whether it exists or not. Whereas nuclear waste, or the result of nuclear accidents, is a real threat to life.
- travelbyphone 10y agoI'd bet its best to pay more money now for huge benefits later, than save money now with huge risks later.
- adrianN 10y agoHow much time do we have left? About twenty years. http://trillionthtonne.org/ http://trillionthtonne.org/
- spenrose 10y agoMaintaining existing nuclear power is very important and politically difficult: http://www.utilitydive.com/news/atoms-for-green-energy-what-role-should-nuclear-power-play-in-decarbonizat/422985/ http://www.utilitydive.com/news/atoms-for-green-energy-what-... New nuclear would be great in the long term. It's not the heart of what we need, but a useful part of the portfolio. The heart of what we need is integrated transmission supporting rapid rollout of all clean sources: https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/does-denmark-hold-the-key-to-integrating-large-amounts-of-intermittent-rene https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/does-denmark-ho... In the US, the new administration is vociferously opposed to any progress. Do NOT let them use nuclear as a wedge issue. They oppose targets in principle: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/trump-picks-top-climate-skeptic-to-lead-epa-transition/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/trump-picks-top-c... Nuclear AND wind AND solar and especially long term planning are all good. Keep your eyes on the prize.
- tombert 10y agoI don't fully know why people are so anti-nuclear in general. I'll be the first to admit that wind and solar are what society should aim for, but I don't full that, with our current implementations of them, that they're quite ready for a 7-billion-people level of energy needs. I feel like nuclear could be a good way to get us using (relatively) clean energy and get people using electric vehicles in the relatively short-term.
- dbingham 10y agoThere's a degree to which it is a zero sum system. If wind and solar is where we should be eventually, then resources put into nuclear now aren't going into wind/solar research and infrastructure building. And nuclear's not cheap. Plus, while nuclear can be done safely, it often isn't, and when it fails, it fails catastrophically. So it's scary for a lot of people. People have to trust not just that nuclear _can_ be done safely, but that it _will_ be done safely. That second one, especially, is a big leap for lots of folks.
- wbl 10y agoThere have only been three accidents at level 5 at commercial nuclear power plants, ever. Only one (Chernobyl) resulted in any casualties. The exclusion zones around Fukushima are as radioactive as Denver.
- tekmate 10y agoand 30 years later the wild hogs in germany are still radioactive thanks to all the caesium in the ground, trying to downplay the effects of these catastrophic events, no matter how rare they are, isn't very helpful
- htns 10y agoThey are still perfectly safe to eat. There isn't even an effect to downplay.
- Retric 10y agoNuclear power is extremely expensive and does not allow for peaking power. In the US company's are shutting them down early because operation costs are to high, let alone construction. So, on the surface it seems relatively useless for meeting our long term energy needs. The only 'advantage' seems to be making money for companies that build or operate nuclear power plants. Thus, there are going to be plenty of experts backing them. PS: While the carbon in natural gas produces CO2, the hydrogen atoms in it combine with Oxygen to form water making it a lower carbon source than Coal. If the goal is a rather arbitrary 32% lower emissions then natural gas can help reach that goal.
- robohamburger 10y agoI didn't know they were bad at peaking but that makes sense. The way I understood nuclear plants is they are enormous capital expenses and thus a utility is going to shy away from them because of that. I wonder how much they compare to a new coal fire plant though.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- AstralStorm 10y agoNot badly even considering the political issues and expense up front. Maintenance is not that expensive. Utilities mostly shy away because of politics, not cost.
- ohyes 10y agoIt actually depends entirely on the design of the reactor whether or not the plant can be used for peaking power. France used nuclear plants as load followers (their entire fleet). It stands to reason that one could be designed as a 'peaking' power plant if one had the desire. Nuclear aircraft carrier and submarine design are good at load following and may be suitable for "peaking" with some modification. Nuclear is expensive when compared to coal/oil/gas, but it's a bit of a catch-22. It's expensive to build a nuclear plant because we don't build very many, so you never get a real economy of scale in the production. Also they're expensive to insure/decommission, so they kind of need to be a state sponsored capital expense.
- lmm 10y ago> Finally, there’s one big falsehood at the core of arguments for nuclear: that it’s “clean.” The full life cycle of nuclear power—from mining, milling, the separation of the uranium from the ore, to ultimate plant decommissioning—collectively generates vast amounts of carbon dioxide. This is of course even more true for wind and especially solar.
- AcerbicZero 10y agoI also did a bit of a double take upon reading that. It seemed like a questionable position to try and take up in an otherwise reasonable-ish debate.
- mnw21cam 10y agoWow. Very light grey text, on a white background. Almost unreadable.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 7Z7 10y agoOT: the irony.
- swehner 10y agoThe short answer is, no, it's not vital. (That was easy)
- swehner 10y agoYou (down-voter) guys really are the hoot!
- EGreg 10y agoLook, no matter what we do, eventually ALL the oil will be extracted fro the ground. Alternative energy just isn't going to replace the oil fast enough. Carbon credits or not, it doesn't matter. And under President Trump, the US will be developing all the fossil fuels it has. Great for economic independence and paying back sovereign debt. Bad for the environment. The best thing to do at this point is to invest in ways to capture the carbon once it is released into the atmosphere. Then of course there is this: http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist/ http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2012/04/economist-meets-...
- shuntress 10y agoHopefully by the time all the natural oil is gone we will be able to efficiently produce synthetic oil that is compatible with out current infrastructure. Also we will, hopefully, have worked out the best way to capture and contain/re-use the CO2 emissions. Though obviously we would need nuclear/wind/solar power for that backbone that facilitates oil synthesis.
- leereeves 10y agoNuclear would have been a great option 30 years ago when the public debate about CO2 began.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- acidburnNSA 10y agoNuclear Engineer here. I like to point out a few things that this article kind of gleans over about nuclear energy. In particular it bothers me that the Sierra Club made that Bugs Bunny quip. The fact is, nuclear fuel has ~2 million times more energy in it per mass than fossil fuel, and while splitting atoms intrinsically requires no carbon emissions, combusting fossil fuels do Carbon+Oxygen = CO2 + energy. When your fuel is 2 million times denser, you need 2 million times less mining, less transportation, etc. And if you run your enrichment plants off of nuclear reactors (like France does), then that process is low-carbon too. Nuclear is extremely clean and very low carbon. Anyway, the nuclear scorecard is: * Nuclear is currently producing 60% of the USA's carbon-free electricity (the article nailed that one) * Nuclear worldwide has saved 1.8 million lives net by displacing air pollution * Nuclear worldwide has prevented the emission of 65 billion tonnes CO2-eq * If you got all your energy for 80 years from nuclear you'd make 1.3 soda cans of waste * Advanced nuclear makes additional advances in already-fantastic safety and can improve cost * Nuclear scales well (demonstrated in France) * Nuclear is great for regions that get winter storms, lots of darkness, hurricanes, hail, very little wind, etc. while wind and solar are good in places that do not have those. Also recall that wind and solar are collecting a very non-dense (but free) energy so they need lots of material and land footprint.
- makmanalp 10y agoHey, while we've caught you here as someone knowledgeable, I've always worried about one thing re: nuclear power: What do you think the risks are in terms of nuclear facilities being easy targets for malicious people? Both in terms of the power network being less distributed because of the much higher energy production per plant, but also much more about the potential consequences of leaks and meltdowns. The Fukushima incident gave me serious doubts about whether containment buildings were truly sufficient to withstand a targeted attack in a war scenario. Sabotage is even more scary, but I'm guessing there are safeguards against that too. Sounds a bit paranoid, but seems worth thinking about before putting more and more civilians near these things :)
- sambe 10y agoLast time I checked (maybe a year ago) there was not a single person who had died from Fukushima (the reactor problems - obviously the quake/tsunami had many fatalities). There was one worker who died but the last official stance was that it was from exposure. I think also some elderly or frail people died as part of the evacuation. Estimates in the abstracts of papers I skimmed were low hundreds of potential future deaths, but quite some uncertainty there obviously. I think the models nearly always estimate on the high side due to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model being used but I'm not an expert. Obviously you can continue to argue about environmental damage and cost of the land being unusable for many years as well. I actually felt a bit better about nuclear safety though - if old reactor designs that are poorly managed can be hit by tsunamis, melt down and still not result in many deaths, the safety looks better than expected. Possibly the risk model changes for a determined attacker? EDIT: current state of Wikipedia is pretty much in agreement with the above, but it's an article with a lot of edits and some points have no references. The number of deaths "due to evacuation conditions" is much higher than I remembered (~1500).
- sonium 10y agoTLDR: No, it is not. Once again Betteridge's law of headlines holds.
- piotrjurkiewicz 10y agoIt is totally mind-boggling for me that the same people who are the strongest advocates of CO2 emission cuts are usually, the same time, the strongest opponents of nuclear power. Nuclear power, which is the only one economically viable way to achieve serious CO2 emission cuts they advocate.
- mason240 10y agoAnd hyrdo power. I've seen zero discussion on building new dams. The PNW is bragging now about their clean energy, but they spent decades trying to get all those dams removed.
- hangsi 10y agoI imagine there are a couple of points that play into this: 1) The good dam spots are occupied, to put it lightly. 2) Hydroelectric dams aren't exactly built to be replaced 3) The technical side of hydroelectric power generation hasn't changed much in recent years; the old dams hold up pretty well for efficiency in taking energy from the water flow. Hydroelectric dams were great before global warming became an issue. The effect of all the above points is that a modern dam would be situated in a place either too small or too risky or too troublesome to put one before. With the effects that dams have on the surrounding environment, it's unfeasible to imagine a scenario without government on board. Given that they must be involved anyway, the state's scarce resources might be better placed in other energy investments than the remaining high growing fruit left on the hydroelectric branch.
- bildung 10y ago> Nuclear power, which is the only one economically viable way to achieve serious CO2 emission cuts they advocate. Without massive subsidies (both direct and through waste disposal etc.) nuclear is actually one of the most expensive power sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_nuclear_power_plants#Cost_per_kWh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_nuclear_power_pla...
- piotrjurkiewicz 10y ago
- jbandela1 10y agoOne way to look at it is from a risk balance perspective. Let's say that with increased nuclear use we would have a Chernobyl every 10 years. So between now and 2200 we would have 20 such disasters. Reading about the Chernobyl disaster and multiplying by 20 still results in orders of magnitude less damage both to humans and the environment than the projections of what will happen if we continue on our present course. In addition, taking a realistic view, we will not be able to control climate change at this point just from a reduction in emissions. We will likely need to remove atmospheric carbon which will likely be very energy intensive. Having the extra power that nuclear brings to the table would be useful in this scenario.
- snuxoll 10y agoWhile I agree with you, saying "If Chernobyl happens every 10 years..." probably isn't going to be a good way to sell nuclear energy :)
- AstralStorm 10y agoBut it should be. We get Chernobyl every year from coal plants.
- jerven 10y agoSometimes it is worth looking at what if we go all in on a technology, what happens and how will that play out. So lets assume we are going nuc crazy and are ordering a 10 GW of plants. Can any nuclear power plant builder actually build this within 5 years? 10 years? Areva can't, Westinghouse seems to take 8. Who is going to man them, where is the training capacity for that many engineers. Consider that if a grid is full nuclear, capacity factors drop to 50%. Unless, you have lots of storage i.e. same as wind and solar. If I order 30gw of solar today, who can build that out in 10 years? lots of companies can. First Solar, Panasonic, LG and many more If I order 30gw of wind today, who can build that out in 10 years? lots of companies can. e.g. Vesta, Enercon, GE and more Nuclear construction capacity has dropped over the years and will take significant time to rebuild and re-equip. That takes significant financial resources. Can anyone afford that at this time considering the competition of solar and wind? Basically, isn't wind+solar+storage a lot cheaper and easier to finance than nuclear? So why go for the big central plants with lots of project risks.
- tristor 10y agoThis is the long-tail effect of society being irrationally anti-nuclear for so long, despite all the favorable evidence. I think being able to be 100% wind/solar is a pipe dream with the continued growth in power usage especially by data-centers. It makes sense to start making decisions now that will continue the positive impact, even if those plants aren't able to come online for 20 years. The additional capacity will still be useful.
- sanxiyn 10y ago> So lets assume we are going nuc crazy and are ordering a 10 GW of plants. Can any nuclear power plant builder actually build this within 5 years? 10 years? China can. As a matter of fact, China connected 20 GW (20863 MW to be exact) capacity to grid within 5 years, from 2012 to 2016. Check for yourself using IAEA PRIS(Power Reactor Information System): https://www.iaea.org/PRIS/CountryStatistics/CountryDetails.aspx?current=CN https://www.iaea.org/PRIS/CountryStatistics/CountryDetails.a...
- Twisell 10y agoMy two favorites vulgarization approach about nuclear radiation: - The XKCD radiation dose chart http://xkcd.com/radiation/ http://xkcd.com/radiation/ - The pretty bad-ass documentary "Uranium: Twisting the Dragon's Tail" where there presenter start by taking an radon bath in a Swiss SPA then travel around to the most radioactive places on earth (and flip out when under Pripiat hospital where he almost took too much risk)...
- iaskwhy 10y agoOne thing I almost never see discussed is how expensive it gets when you have to keep building nuclear power plants due to decommissioning. Most nuclear power plants in use nowadays seem to have a 30 years life expectancy, new ones get up to 60. It just seems hugely expensive.
- rdtsc 10y ago> Meanwhile, the price of solar took just five years to drop almost 70%, and it continues to fall at record rates. Wow that is a surprising number. That looks encouraging. What is the expectation there? Is there a currently known limit that we expect to hit. (say the scarcity of some rare metal). Or it is easily possible to see another 70% drop next 5 years. To my uninformed mind, advanced nuclear seems like a good way forward. Is there a way to make reactors smaller, "burn" the waste, Thorium seems popular and there were many articles on it. I grew up not far from Chernobyl when it happened. So it would seem I should be vehemently opposed, but I believe with each accident we'd learn from the past what not to do.
- philipkglass 10y agoThere is no near/medium term limit to PV manufacturing volume from materials scarcity. The rarest material used in a typical crystalline silicon solar panel is silver, part of the conductive pastes used to make electrical contacts on cells. Limits on silver availability could limit annual production rates with present mainstream designs. But manufacturers have found many ways to economize on silver use so that total PV silver consumption rose only slightly from 2011-2015 even as annual production volume rose 80%. SunPower uses plated copper for electrical contacts instead of silver pastes. Their modules are also the most efficient on the market. But the high efficiency and avoidance of silver come at the price of higher process complexity during cell manufacturing which leads to higher costs per watt of capacity. SunPower is at least an existence proof that you can produce modules at large scale, at high efficiency, from abundant elements. I expect other manufacturers to substitute away from silver too if increasing demand pushes silver prices up too high. Sometimes you'll see people claim that solar can't attain really large volumes because of dependencies on "rare elements." Those claims are probably referring to the tellurium in cadmium-telluride PV modules and/or the indium and gallium in copper-indium-gallium-diselenide modules. But you can safely ignore those worries because CdTe and CIGS together account for a very small share of the market; crystalline silicon dominates PV at over 90% share.
- rdtsc 10y agoThank you for explaining. The future sounds exciting. I especially like the "Solar Roof" from Tesla that is probably what was needed to make it mainstream. When building a house customer has a checkbox to a regular roof or solar roof, but otherwise it looks about the same. One day the solar roof might be the default choice in many areas of the country probably.
- niftich 10y agoThe case of Slovakia and Hungary is interesting: they are two of the top 4 countries where the share of nuclear generation is highest (and above 50%) [1]. Slovakia is largely devoid of fossil fuels, while Hungary produces lignite, oil, and natural gas, but both are reliant on gas imports (mostly from Russia). As such, they generally can't afford to not consider nuclear, despite being small countries where an accident would damage a sizeable chunk of the countryside. Despite their Russian-made reactors, and usually Russian-sourced fuel, the domestic production of more than half the countries' energy needs is simply a national security issue with the useful side-effect of reducing carbon emissions than if imported natural gas was used for a much higher share of production. [1] https://www.iaea.org/PRIS/WorldStatistics/NuclearShareofElectricityGeneration.aspx https://www.iaea.org/PRIS/WorldStatistics/NuclearShareofElec...
- Fej 10y agoKeep fighting for LFTR. We need to beat the CO2 targets, not miss them. Unfortunately, even hitting the targets seems like a pipe dream at this point.
- darawk 10y agoIf Trump could somehow channel his disdain for environmental groups away from coal and towards nuclear, he could actually end up doing a really great thing. The fact that environmentalists have resisted nuclear power for so long is one of the stupidest most self-defeating things in modern history. If Trump took all his rhetoric and bullheadedness and focused it on making nuclear great again, that would make me supremely happy.
- 234dd57d2c8db 10y agoNo one seems to be even considering fusion. I understand the tech isn't there, but that's because of the "fusion-never" levels of funding. Can someone please fund this!?
- 08-15 10y agoThis article asks the wrong question. And answers an unrelated one. First off, the question subtly implies that nuclear power should be the last resort. That's already setting the stage for a slanted discussion. The correct question is to ask whether we want nuclear power in preference to coal, oil, natural gas, and a little bit of solar and wind. As far as I can tell, the answer should be an emphatic YES---but the point isn't the answer, it's the loaded question. Second, the WSJ asks what's necessary to hit emissions targets. That's dumb. We ought to ask what's necessary to stop global warming. I don't know what are the current targets, probably something like cutting emissions in half by 2050. I think we can do that by switching more industrial processes from coal or oil to natural gas. But if the dire predictions of the IPCC are true, we're still going to die, only a little bit slower. To stop global warming, we need to get CO2 emissions to practically zero, and natural gas doesn't get us there. Neither do unreliables (sun, wind) combined with natural gas backup, nor the vain hope for a magic storage solution nobody knows yet. And finally, the stupid environmentalist hack proceeds to answer a different question. He tells us that nuclear power is expensive (still cheaper than wind and sun, though), but if indeed it was "Vital to Hitting CO2 Emissions Targets", we wouldn't care. We'd do it anyway, wouldn't we? But naturally, the ecotard doesn't even listen to the question and just rattles off his canned talking points...