4 ms·
>> I wonder where the top Speed Limit comes from... Gear ratio. It says the motor spins to 8800rpm which is high but not crazy high. Given a top speed of the m
by phkahler 10y ago
>> I wonder where the top Speed Limit comes from...
Gear ratio. It says the motor spins to 8800rpm which is high but not crazy high. Given a top speed of the motor the gear ratio will determine the top speed of the car. They may have optimized it for better acceleration at the expense of top speed. Many people in the US never drive that fast so it's not a bad tradeoff.
If you're wondering about having multiple gear ratios, it doesn't make much sense in EVs. These motors already behave in a similar way. For a given (maximum rated) current they will produce constant torque from zero to what is called "base speed" which is the point where the back-emf matches the bus voltage. Beyond that speed it enters an operating region called "field weakening" where some of the current is used to oppose the magnets which is equivalent to reducing the back-emf so it can go faster. In this region it operates much like a constant power device so the torque drops with the inverse of rpm much like a CVT. There's another metric called the constant-power-speed-ratio (CPSR) which is the top speed divided by the base speed. In my experience, CPSR for an EV is likely to be somewhere between 3 and 5 though it can be much higher.
Source: one of my specialties happens to be algorithms for very high CPSR. It's an odd place I never meant to go, but I would enjoy taking a stab at tuning the Bolt.
- mikeash 10y agoI believe that multiple gear ratios could make sense for high-end EVs. For example, the Model S P100D's top speed of 155MPH is pretty low for a car of such power and low-end acceleration. And its acceleration tends to fall off at higher speeds (if you watch drag races against high-end ICE cars, the Tesla tends to stomp them initially, then the ICE car starts to catch up after a few seconds) and I have heard that being able to change gear ratios would help with that, although I certainly could be misinformed.
- phkahler 10y agoMy colleagues looked into a 2-speed gearbox for EVs and they just couldn't make the case for it. Tesla was also going to use one early on and seems to have abandoned that idea. For the Model S (or any EV), increasing top speed would mean either increasing the motor RPM, or increasing the gear ratio which would reduce acceleration. I don't know what limits their top speed to 155 and don't want to guess.