6 ms·
I still don't understand why anyone would buy a Bolt (or a Tesla) over a Volt. Since I heard about the Volt initially back in 2006, it was the most logical and
by brightball 10y ago
I still don't understand why anyone would buy a Bolt (or a Tesla) over a Volt.
Since I heard about the Volt initially back in 2006, it was the most logical and practical approach to powering a vehicle that I'd ever heard. Eliminate gas usage on 95% of your driving, but have gas available for long range and fast refueling against the entire infrastructure of the US.
Pure EV's are nothing more than "around town" cars in a lot of the country, which I'm sure is great if you can afford it or fun for early adopters but otherwise just an impractical luxury.
That first 40 miles approach turned the MPG formula on it's head by making clear that miles-per-day is the real metric that people need to worry about.
Going forward, the approach of the Volt could easily be modified to replace the gas generator and tank with fuel cells, bio-diesel, ethanol or any other power source that comes along.
The perk of the approach is that you have 2 options and you aren't purely SOL after a long power outage from a hurricane or other unexpected event. That happens with an EV and you don't have another way to charge it via wind/solar you're left with a very expensive brick.
- coredog64 10y agoI already have 2 cars, so I'm not concerned about range. One of those cars is a Prius. While it has been very reliable, as we come up on 200,000 miles my wife is getting anxious about failure modes that are hybrid only. I mostly don't want to ever have to get another oil change again.
- camiller 10y agoWife has the minivan for when we all are going somewhere, daughter has a beater ('95 Buick) after she wrecked(totaled) my Impala(and two other peoples cars), All I need is an around the town car. I drive 3.6 miles to work, home for lunch then back to work and home again in the evening, sometime a few errands. The only practical drawback is how low slung these small cars are. As a backup if my wife's van is in the shop, we need something higher off the ground as the wife has had six back surgeries and getting in/out of something low is hard for her. If Chevy would do an all electric equinox...
- Vik1ng 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5lOV6PdVQbk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5lOV6PdVQbk Consumer Reports touches a bit on that. One advantage is for example that you don't have to worry about the maintenance and reliability of the combustion engine.
- ams6110 10y agoFTA: The battery is expected to last the life of the Bolt EV, and it’s covered by an eight-year/100,000-mile warranty. 100,000 miles is not remarkable for cars made in the last decade at least. Most will go 100,000 miles easily with only routine fluid changes. Granted that may be more than what an EV needs but it's not something most people really "worry" about. None of my current cars are less than 10 years old and none have less than 100,000 miles; my main family car for long trips is a Honda minivan w/210,000 on the clock and it runs like new and is very reliable. And I only paid 8,000 for it when I bought it with 80,000 miles.
- sliken 10y agoSo it's warrantied for 100k miles, not that it's going to die at 100,001. Are any of your cars warrantied for more than $100k? Not like the battery is expoxied in and you can't replace it.
- brightball 10y agoI leased a Volt for 3 years to try it out without having to commit to the early adopter risk. Oil changes were every 20,000 miles. Occasionally the engine would turn on and run automatically because I hadn't used it at all in a few weeks just for maintenance sake. For a gas first approach like most hybrids I think it's a bigger concern. In the Volt since it's just a generator I don't know if the maintenance burden is quite as much of a concern.
- hx87 10y agoThe first gen Volt had a parallel-hybrid mode, which increases wear compared to a pure series-hybrid, so maintenance isn't as low as it could be.
- maxsilver 10y ago> I still don't understand why anyone would buy a Bolt (or a Tesla) over a Volt. It's a great second car. For families, you buy one PHEV (like your Volt) to handle commutes or road trips, and one Pure EV second car that only gets used for commutes and such. Pure EV's also have significantly lower maintenance. > Pure EV's are nothing more than "around town" cars in a lot of the country, This isn't like a LEAF with low 80ish mile limits. At 220+ miles, this new Bolt could drive from Chicago to Milwaukee and back without ever stopping to charge -- quite a bit further than just "around town".
- gordon_freeman 10y agoOr Prius Prime? The new version of prius plug in would give epa estimated 133 mpge which is the highest number for any car sold in USA. So if you really consider efficiency and even carbon emissions then that is the car one should get. A good amount of electricity is generated in America by coal based power plants so in a way, comparing mpge numbers make more sense while thinking about reducing the carbon emissions. Also found this tool really useful to see carbon footprint of a car. Www.carboncounter.com
- brightball 10y agoDefinitely the right approach. The more options out there like that the better IMHO.
- audunw 10y agoI'd just like to add that mpge does not really make sense for EVs. There simply aren't enough EVs to make any significant impact on short-term carbon emission. All the EVs produced by the end of this decade won't make even a tiny dent. You can't really think of EV as relevant at all in the short term. You have to think of it as part of a two-decade long strategic plan. The same is partly true for PHEV with sufficient battery capacity. So the question is really, how is electricity generated in 20 years? I think there's reason to be optimistic about that question. In general, when it comes to the environment: don't mistake the forest for the trees. But I see that, ironically, both environmentalists and deniers like to focus on carbon emissions on EVs (equivalent or not). Environmentalists like to say that they're "zero-emission" to boost their ego, while deniers like to show worst-case scenarios to try to make EVs no better than gasoline cars. But if you're calculating the carbon emission of an EV today, you've already missed the point.
- mikeash 10y agoI can't speak for the Bolt, but I bought a Tesla over a Volt for several reasons. For one, it's a much more practical car. The Volt has only four seats. The latest generation has a fifth sort-of seat you can squeeze someone into if you really need it. My Tesla seats five adults and two children. It also has about three times the cargo space in a five-seat configuration. Long range travel is not an issue. Visit https://supercharge.info https://supercharge.info and see just where you can reach on Tesla's network alone. OK, places like North Dakota and Arkansas won't work too well, but certainly the places I'd like to visit are covered. I find myself planning a lot more road trips with the Tesla than with previous cars. I didn't like burning all that gas before, but now it's just fun. In the past year, I've driven from my home near DC to south Florida, to Ohio, to Montreal, and I'm planning a trip to Wisconsin next month. As far as long power outages go, I'm less worried with the Tesla than with previous cars. Every morning, the car has 237 miles of range left. With my gas cars, that figure fluctuated anywhere from 500 miles to 40 miles. Gas pumps require electricity to work, so you have to wait for power to come back (or go somewhere that has it) either way. But I know that I'll always have the canonical "half a tank of gas" that they say you should ensure you have for emergency. EVs are highly practical these days. What they aren't (yet) is both practical and affordable. The Bolt is helping to change that, although the lack of fast charging infrastructure means it doesn't quite get there. I totally understand why people would want to stick with gas cars or hybrids, whether it's because you live in or visit places like North Dakota, or can't stand the extra charging time needed for long trips, or can't charge at home, or whatever. But I hope this helps you understand the other side.
- brightball 10y agoGood explanation. Checking the map in the southeast is pretty sparse though.
- mikeash 10y agoWhich part of the southeast are you looking at? If "the southeast" comprises NC, SC, GA, FL, AL, MS, and TN, then the only sparse areas are northern AL and MS and western TN, and northern AL and western TN have sites under construction which will probably be done in a month or two.
- andygates 10y agoIt hits every trip need of mine except for that ill-advised 1000 mile road trip. Looking forward to the UK variant.
- aembleton 10y agoThey're not bringing the first gen model to the UK: http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/vauxhall/94351/opel-ampera-e-electric-car-wont-come-to-uk-in-current-form http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/vauxhall/94351/opel-ampera-e-el...
- sebnukem2 10y agoI totally agree with you. The Volt seems like the perfect car, but I ultimately picked the Prius over the Volt for 2 reasons: the Prius looks a lot better and, more importantly, has a lot more interior space that I need. The Volt felt both heavy and cramped, like a flawed first generation product. The 2nd gen Volt is a big improvement.
- vinhboy 10y agoI also picked a Prius EV. It think that was a mistake. A Volt would have made my EV driving percentage way higher.
- projektfu 10y agoAfter test driving both, as well as the C-Max, the Volt felt much snappier and suits our lifestyle better. We don't need 5 seats but we like the layout of the cargo space. The overall ride of the Volt is very smooth. In 2.5 years we haven't needed an oil change. My one complaint is that it doesn't corner as well as my 1999 Corolla did.
- sliken 10y agoMaybe because you don't want the cost, complexity, and weight of having two completely different drive trains? As chevy shows with the CotY you can make a hell of a car if you design a car for electric and invest the weight/savings in the better electric car. Why carry around a complete drive train for the 5% case when that you could invest in the electric side for the 100% case.