4 ms·
That's not an equivalent analogy. Disabling JS displays nothing at all, while changing text and background color is a progressive enhancement. Content should
by tambourine_man 10y ago
That's not an equivalent analogy.
Disabling JS displays nothing at all, while changing text and background color is a progressive enhancement.
Content should still be accessible without JavaScript, even if, perhaps, in a less convenient way, i.e., every click reloads the entire page
- Blahah 10y agoWhy? Every browser has JS, and it's a core web technology.
- efaref 10y agoI quite often use Lynx[1], which does not support JS. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynx_(web_browser) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynx_(web_browser)
- adrianN 10y agoDoes every screen reader have Javascript?
- vertex-four 10y agoScreen readers integrate with browsers, they don't implement an entire browser on their own, so yes.
- __derek__ 10y agoYou and GP are missing the point: the site uses an ocean-liner's worth of JavaScript in order to do anything at all. HTML is also a core web technology and is arguably more "core" than JavaScript.
- adim86 10y agoBut why? Who made the rule that websites should work without JS? Content being accessible without JS is best practice. I get it and it was very valuable a long time ago. It comes in handy sometimes today but for most of the internet accessing world, working without JS is not a requirement. I do not get why people ding products for not working when JS is not enabled.
- tambourine_man 10y ago> Who made the rule that websites should work without JS? It's not an arbitrary rule, it's just that they always have. That's the hole point of progressive enhancement, you don't start requiring some technology as soon as it reaches x% market share and ignore the remaining minority. You build on top and offer a better experience to those that can or want. In the apps world, it's usual to draw a line on a set of minimum system requirements and expect that line to move forward as the years go by. But this is the Web, being accessible should be a priority.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoIt's still valuable unless your time is worthless.
- aplummer 10y agoI disagree with this assumption "Content should still be accessible without JavaScript" in 2016.
- icebraining 10y agoIt's not specifically against JS, it's a matter of parsimony. One shouldn't require more than what's needed for the job. KISS. Of course, most of us fail to perfectly abide by that, but the principle is solid.
- silversmith 10y agoIt's like saying a company should be present in each and every market. It might or might not make business sense to do that. Same with JS - it might or might not make sense to support non-js browsers, based on your target audience.
- tambourine_man 10y agoThe Web was not meant to run on specific markets, platforms or browsers. It's the World Wide Web. Being accessible to everyone is the whole point. We have other platforms that target specific markets. That's fine. But we only have one Web.