9 ms·
Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThis is the proverbial "other shoe" and its not at all clear who actually is getting hurt. So the back story is that it is trivial to set up a "fake news" site and slant the crap out of the news and outright lie about what is going on to attract that segment of the population that is more interested in having their views validated than they are in learning anything new. And if you do that and fill it with aggressive ads you can make enough money per month to buy beer easily and sometimes even fund a comfortable lifestyle in a country which has a low cost of living. So Google is going to stop selling ads to those sites. (good move on their part although it does impact their bottom line slightly) and they are going to stop taking money from those sites which try to buy adwords and make their site appear in the search results for a popular keyword. Also good but somewhat problematic. This is the problem. Google sells ads on bids, highest bidder gets the best ad spot. Search ads are their cash cow and lifeblood. Hackers and fake news sites compete with each other trying to buy the ads on searches that hapless people do trying to find information about current events. So Google profits both by selling adwords and by the competition all these bad actors are engaged in trying to buy that top slot. Stop selling them adwords or stop allowing them to bid, and Google takes a big hit in topline revenue. How much remains to be seen, but if its a problem I expect fake news to be a hot topic at Searchengineland.
- GabrielF00 10y agoI think Google risks taking a huge hit to its credibility if the most prominent result for a topic is an outright lie. I'd guess that the loss of credibility/constant PR problems would more than offset the revenue.
- kevingadd 10y agoI think another factor here is likely that when traffic on a fake news site is high enough, it can actually get pushed to the top of Google's organic search results (as happened with completely false popular vote results recently). In that scenario, they've manipulated Google into feeding them massive ad revenue with false information. Given Google's (now dead, I suppose) original intent to classify the world's information and make it easy to find, it's a pretty sad outcome. Glad they're taking action.
- JacobJans 10y agoYou have to respect Google for taking the long view on this –– their revenue may decrease in the short term, but in the long term they will keep the trust of their users. And that is worth a lot more than a relatively few fake news sites.
- sparkzilla 10y agoAre they going to stop ads on the New York Times, The Washington Post, and the other mainstream media sites that suppressed bad news about Clinton, while pushing fake and manipulated news about Trump?
- sigmar 10y ago>while pushing fake and manipulated news about Trump? Link please.
- joshmn 10y agoInserts infowars, anonnews, yournewswire references. Because remember folks, not even your President-elect factchecks. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9IEIP3k_8c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9IEIP3k_8c
- sparkzilla 10y agoSince you asked..The New York Times completely made up the story about Trump mocking a disabled reporter, to distract from their reporting of his comments about seeing Muslims celebrating in New Jersey [1]. Freeze framed his arms and completely made up the story to match. That's just one of many, many deliberate misdirections and bogus factchecking fails by the MSM in this election. The New York Times even apologised to its readers for its biased coverage. [1]https://medium.com/@sparkzilla/trump-and-the-battle-of-the-truths-a13450ecbbc8#.kc7t2kiby https://medium.com/@sparkzilla/trump-and-the-battle-of-the-t...
- fullshark 10y agoThere's video of him mocking said reporter. That's really what you went with?
- sparkzilla 10y agoTrump mocked the reporter, but he didn't mock him for his disability. Trump uses the same mocking motions all the time [1], but The New York Times, decided to freeze the image and write a story to say he was specifically mocking the reporter's disability. Big difference. And it worked, because so many people believe it. But it was a lie plain and simple. That's why so few people trust the media any more. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uiUizn19p7o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uiUizn19p7o
- vinhboy 10y agoThank god we are finally focusing on this issue. I can not believe we allowed right wing propaganda sites to publish so much false information for so long. Anyone who denies the existence of this is being dishonest. There is no way you can defend the journalist integrity of the 'breitbart' of the web. It takes 'yellow journalism' to a whole new level. It has also become obvious to us that the average internet user, has no idea how to vet anything on the web. They lack the simplest ability to recognize the deceiving nature of the URL they are visiting. And we're not just talking about uneducated folks. I've seen plenty of college-educated people share fake news. This is rotting our democracy. I am at the point where I feel like technologists and journalists have to work together to establish some sort of browser based credentialing system that we give to content creators to signal that they are a legitimate news source. Like how we SSL validate sites. It maybe as useless as a "certified organic" sticker, but at least it'll be better than nothing.
- Kenji 10y agoThank goodness we can hide away and silence dissenting and right wing voices. It's not like that was a big part of what caused Trump to be elected. I really am glad that google, facebook & co curate what political things we get shown, that fixes democracy once and for all by making us better informed citizens. /s EDIT: To those who do not get free speech at all: By silencing people who spread conspiracy theories, you provide them with the first fact that they might be on to something. Because if they weren't on to something, why couldn't you just provide simple facts to contradict and embarrass the conspiracy theorist?
- matt4077 10y agoYou're being sarcastic, but I'm not sure if people weren't better informed in times where just a few organizations were gatekeepers to information. It's undemocratic, I know. They still did a better job. Now, people support parties as if they were sports teams. Politics has become mass entertainment and the relationship between quality and success is so low, I'm unsure if we wouldn't be better of selecting congress in a lottery.
- allemagne 10y ago
- piotrjurkiewicz 10y agoWhat about fake opinion polls?
- DominikR 10y agoWell that's a hard one to answer for defenders of the politburo.
- dandare 10y agoI think this is one of the good ideas that pave the way to hell. What is fake and what is truth? How is Google going to decide? Couple examples: 1/ Is global warming a huge conspiracy? The president of USA certainly says so. 2/ News: CIA plotted with terrorist to traffic drugs to US - that must be a hoax, right? 3/ News: The US govt secretly spread syphilis among black population - this infowars shit must be surely hoax. 4/ How about US pretending being attacked to start a war? I am talking about Gulf of Tonkin, not 9/11. 5/ The government is reading all your emails and listening to all your phonecalls - bat shit crazy, right? What I am trying to say is that once such mechanism is in place it can go on a slippery slope from there on. Next thing they will decide to filter fake news search results and that very minute they will be subpoenaed to hide something in the name of state security.
- matt4077 10y agoI know there are people who will dismiss it as bias, but you can actually assign a quality score to publications quite easily. NYT/Wall Street Journal/The Atlantic/Guardian/Washington Post/The New Yorker vs. breitbart/HuffPost/.... Note that all those stories you're referencing were all broken by the papers I listed. The breitbarts of the world usually just repackage what actual news organizations publish with ideological slant.
- pdeuchler 10y agoThat's not bias, it's just over fitting the model
- tomsaffell 10y ago>repackage what actual news organizations publish with ideological slant. Which is what The Economist does - it's been doing so since 1843. Current circulation is over one million, and it's widely respected, though not by all...
- matt4077 10y agoThere's a bit of a difference in that the actual facts in the Economist are probably trustworthy, but I agree that they argue from a certain (free-market worshipping) point-of-view. It's obviously a scale, and opinions will vary widely. It's not even a problem for journalism to have an opinion (I'd actually argue it's impossible). What readers should demand is a good-faith effort to argue the best version of the opposition's case. At this point, the problem with the US right isn't actually ideology. You can believe that coal is the future, and I'll vote against you, but I'm not looking at CDC statistics to find out when I can expect you to die. It's the complete disregard for the system that's alarming. All over the country, there are polling places, often staffed by the older generation, people from both parties and independents, and the ones I've met always gave me the feeling that they'd defend the integrity of the vote no matter what. I wish I could say the same about the people being elected.
- Mao_Zedang 10y agoI am sure this will be cheered at here, but this is a troubling trend.
- forrestthewoods 10y agoDoes Vox count as fake news? Their manipulative misuse of statistics is so bad it should qualify as fake.
- mr_spothawk 10y agocare to expound on that?
- bcoates 10y agoI'm mostly on the buy side so I'm not sure how much of the dogwhistle comes through, but here's a random article about how Vox is basically a platform for brands to sell products as news: http://digiday.com/publishers/flush-cash-vox-media-seeks-tech-advantage-native-ads/ http://digiday.com/publishers/flush-cash-vox-media-seeks-tec... Obviously they can't be too blatant about it but Vox promoting any position you pay them to is literally their business model. I assume they don't tell their writers this but the softball neoliberalism that they pitch by default is brand-safe enough that nobody'd notice.
- yahyaheee 10y agoWonder what spawned this?
- jwtadvice 10y agoNational Security folk calling in favors.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoThis is good but I think there's an elephant in the room Google isn't addressing...and I don't know why. Content origin/ownership. Say I devote three weeks to researching a topic and then publish a detailed article on my website. A website with more traffic can swipe the entire thing, word for word, even the images, post it on their site and generate traffic on stolen content. Google desperately needs a way for content authors to be able to register their work and penalize content thieves. This is probably impossible to make work retroactively but that's not a problem. When it comes to news websites, the same applies. Why do we have the same story from 1,000 different sites? Whoever originates the story should "own it" and get the search traffic. Other sites are just copying. So, if CNN and FOX are just regurgitating stories from Associated Press, why are they even relevant? I think sensible content ownership controls could clean-up a bunch of the internet and direct traffic to deserving sites. There's almost no incentive to create original content unless you already have so much traffic that you are going to capitalize on it. I have hundreds of original articles I would like to publish on our sites and don't because I know what will happen. So, we publish articles with much less depth, because it costs money to sit down and devote hours to writing a well-researched piece.
- Pxtl 10y agoSometimes the big news sites add much-needed context to an AP wire articles that reads like too much inside baseball.
- narrowrail 10y ago>I have hundreds of original articles I would like to publish on our sites and don't Wait, you have already sunk the costs to produce this content, but will not because others might profit from it? This doesn't make much sense at all unless I'm missing something here. You might have generated some revenue, but now it's $0?
- rebootthesystem 10y agoThe content was written and delivered to our customers directly through email. It was not inexpensive to develop and that's why I hesitate to put it online for it to be stolen. We have healthy email lists of our customers and are happy to deliver good content directly into their mailboxes.
- DominikR 10y agoStrange to see how Google, a company that once refused to do business in China in order to not have to engage in censorship, now openly seeks to implement censorship in the West. And a bunch of "liberals" on a hacker news who in all other cases would rail against censorship on the Internet happily supporting censorship on the Internet. I'm astonished that someone like Sergey Brin would even allow this to happen, considering that his family immigrated from a country that censored information it did not like for the exact same reasons in order to impoverish and control its population. This is it for me, I'm moving away from all Google services.
- Pxtl 10y agoCensorship is about silencing uncomfortable truths. This is about declining to fund uncomfortable falsehoods.
- DominikR 10y agoThis is _exactly_ how the Sowjets justified their own censorship. It's all falsehoods by ideological degenerates or by Western saboteurs and other collaborators with the enemy and therefore must be censored in order to protect society.
- mr_spothawk 10y agoImagine the difference if it had been titled: "Google has agreed that it will stop serving ads to Chinese sites which are unfriendly to President Li's conception of Chinese culture and values."
- DominikR 10y agoI'm pretty sure now that this mass psychosis in the West will most definitely lead to civil war. There are just too many people who can't seem to accept democracy or liberty if it doesn't go their way.
- ern 10y agoGoogle is a private company that can choose how to make money. If it chooses to not show advertising on any particular category of site, that's a commercial decision. If its shareholders or customers are upset they can unseat the board or find another provider respectively (as you wish to do). A competitor may even see a commercial opportunity and make a business model based off carrying ads on fake news sites-Google doesn't do ads on porn sites, and yet those sites seem to be doing OK on ad revenue.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jwtadvice 10y agoThis is going to bring the New York Times down.
- mr_spothawk 10y ago>"Moving forward, we will restrict ad serving on pages that misrepresent, misstate, or conceal information about the publisher, the publisher's content, or the primary purpose of the web property," That sounds terrible. Does that mean if I'm ICANN registered with my host's "don't spam me bro" protections, that my blogs can be ad supported?