7 ms·
They should start building hardware switches on mics, cameras, WiFi, Bluetooth etc. And we should be able to check that they really work.
by pmontra 10y ago
They should start building hardware switches on mics, cameras, WiFi, Bluetooth etc. And we should be able to check that they really work.
- zlatan_todoric 10y agoWe do this with our products https://puri.sm/learn/hardware-kill-switches/ https://puri.sm/learn/hardware-kill-switches/ although it would be really good to get more players into same field.
- randall 10y agoCan you guys add a real GPU? I'd buy in a second if it was available.
- zlatan_todoric 10y agoAdding nVidia and AMD GPUs would require us to have nonfree drivers or firmwares so that would be against our philosophy. Also adding proprietary stuff is against our goal of creating secure yet convenient OS (we try to free or create things that people need, not close them down even more).
- Joof 10y agoI also like the idea of building the notification LED for cameras directly into the circuit so that it can't turn on the camera without the LED.
- TheGorramBatman 10y agoRelevant: https://www.usenix.org/node/184422 https://www.usenix.org/node/184422 "iSeeYou: Disabling the MacBook Webcam Indicator LED"
- SG- 10y agoThis doesn't work with recent MacBooks, only the older models.
- gcr 10y agoApple's is in the firmware, but legend has it that it's possible to bypass. It would be great to have the light show for both microphone and webcam access.
- WalterBright 10y agoIf it's in the firmware, it is possible to bypass. It must be a hardware switch to be credible.
- shostack 10y agoBut honestly, most people won't audit the wiring of their device. I wonder if a more low tech solution is the answer...a cover for cameras and some sort of sound blocking cover/plug for microphone holes.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThat's the same argument that's been applied against open source software for decades now. The reality is you don't need everyone to audit their devices, you only need there to be credible auditors. Better: standards mandates that require isolation of any ambient capture devices. In the alternative, the ability to flood and overload such circuits might be of interest.
- pmontra 10y agoAn ok from ifixit would be good enough.
- rabidonrails 10y agoI think that Jeff Bezos said this is how Alexa/Echo is built. I can't verify by watching the clip now, but I believe it's in this interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yq0ecBGg5Q0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yq0ecBGg5Q0
- mdda 10y agoIt's just after 5m45s : https://youtu.be/yq0ecBGg5Q0?t=5m45s https://youtu.be/yq0ecBGg5Q0?t=5m45s
- JadeNB 10y ago> And we should be able to check that they really work. How? Seriously, if you don't trust a hardware switch to work as advertised, then you probably don't trust software correctly to report the state of the hardware; so what would you trust? (I wish that I could say that I think you're being paranoid, but I don't; I just wonder what a zero- or minimal-trust proof of disconnected hardware would look like—short, presumably, of something like a visible air gap that could only be implemented at considerable expense to the portability of modern electronics.)
- gizmo686 10y ago>so what would you trust? Physics. Their not being an unnoticed second camera/microphones/etc. If you main concern is that your computer will be used to spy on your physical life, then having verified switches can give you confidence from first principles that it it has no way of observing you (modulo secondary sensors that you did not notice.)
- tree_of_item 10y agoPhysics? Can you go in to some detail as to what you mean by this? You can't see physics with your eyes.
- JadeNB 10y ago> having verified switches can give you confidence from first principles that it it has no way of observing you Right, but this is what I meant to ask: how does one verify a switch that has been manufactured by someone else? I suppose that an electrical engineer could check the schematics, but how do you verify that the actual hardware in your device matches the schematics?
- gizmo686 10y agoSwitches are very simple devices. If the switch mechanism is not enclosed, it is easy to look one and see that the input leads are separated by the output leads by an air gap. Of course, a sufficiently motivated attacker could still work around this (by eg, by finding a side channel, or having the plastic of the switch be somewhat conductive). However, these attacks are far more difficult, and far less plausibly deniable.
- pkaeding 10y agoNope [1] is one pretty slick after-maket hardware 'switch' you can add to your webcam. Of course, some gaffer's tape works just as well, and costs a lot less (but doesn't look as slick). I don't have any such solution for the microphone, though. [1] https://www.bungajungle.com/products/nope https://www.bungajungle.com/products/nope
- icanhackit 10y ago[...] some gaffer's tape works just as well, and costs a lot less (but doesn't look as slick). I don't have any such solution for the microphone, though. The microphone is a hard one. Even if you cover the holes in the casing where the mic is located the sound still travels just fine via the keyboard. IIRC when a photo came out of Mark Zuckerberg covering his webcam I noticed he covered his mic port with tape as well. He should have checked the volume levels from his mic - it would still pick up everything just fine. In fact I think the tiny mic holes are mostly vestigial.
- r00fus 10y agoIs there ever a need for a laptop microphone? I always have a headset or BT if I'm doing FaceTime or a confirm call... Why not just disable the hardware or at the OS level?
- icanhackit 10y ago> Why not just disable the hardware Depends on the make/model of computer - current MacBooks use a lot of glue to hold components together, making minor hardware tweaks a bit of a gamble. It's not impossible, just not as hassle-free as it used to be. > or at the OS level If your computer has a rootkit then doing it in software is no good.
- scotu 10y agoI once was videocalling with my macbook on my lap, suddenly I couldn't be heard by the other party: I moved and my leg was covering the microphone hole. Problem is that the mic is still picking up sounds, just very attenuated. Maybe a solution would be no integrated microphone, a small low profile microphone in the laptop box to be connected through the laptop mic jack.
- awqrre 10y agoApple would have an heart attack if they would be required to do this...
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoWe also need hardware write-protect in storage media such as USB flash drives. Otherwise any system the USB is inserted into can compromise the USB. You usually think of USB compromising a computer, e.g. Stuxnet, but it can also work in the other direction. Back in the old days of 1/2" mag tape reels, the rule was "no ring, no write". There was a physical ring that needed to be present before a tape drive would write to a mag tape. This was also relatively failsafe. If the ring fell out or was removed, for any reason at all, the data was guaranteed to be safe. This same mentality carried over to floppy disks. It was possible to protect media in hardware. But in the interests of saving money, hardware write protect circuitry is quite passe these days. As are hardware switches of all sorts.
- koolba 10y agoFun fact about old floppy drives, the write lock didn't actually prevent writes from happening. It was just an indicator. Write prevention was handled by the disk drive which could choose to ignore the write lock.
- hobarrera 10y agoActually, we need more modern OSs that allow isolation of priviledges from apps and alike (similar to what iOS does, but desktop), and manually activating things like cameras/mics per-app. POSIX (and the upper, newer, layers of API) is really starting to show it's age, since it's from a time when "untrusted software" was not that much of a thing.
- pjmlp 10y agoThat is the direction of macOS and Windows are going, but apparently many wish things to stay the same old POSIX way.
- pmontra 10y agoIn part yes, but there are people (me included) who are past the point of trusting the companies that are making most of the software and the hardware we use, OS included. That's why verifiable hardware switches are important.