8 ms·
I'm all for this kind of citizen action. They're volunteering their own time to improve public safety. Kind of like how neighborhood watch groups can supplement
by TulliusCicero 10y ago
I'm all for this kind of citizen action. They're volunteering their own time to improve public safety. Kind of like how neighborhood watch groups can supplement police, these volunteers are supplementing departments of transportation. Of course it'd be even better if they could do it without breaking the law, but I doubt there are rules in place to permit citizens to do their own DIY infrastructure improvements.
Also, unlike what some commenters think, this doesn't really go against democracy. The cities where these groups work have embraced Vision Zero at least on paper, so they're generally for these sorts of improvements. Government just tends to move slowly, and they often have to deal with NIMBY groups that are more concerned with keeping as many parking spaces as possible in their neighborhood than public safety.
- edblarney 10y ago"Also, unlike what some commenters think, this doesn't really go against democracy. " It definitely goes against democracy and civility. Maybe it's for the better, maybe it's for the worse - but a small group of people taking it upon themselves to decide for everyone else how a city should operate is a very tricky place for any society to be. Maybe most people don't want something. Maybe it makes rescue workers jobs difficult by blocking traffic in a certain hot spot. Maybe the situation is more complex than one would imagine (i.e. some lanes radically affect the flow of traffic, screw up incoming/outgoing traffic/lane changes). I can think of quite a few things that 'civic vigilantes' could do that would be way, way out of bounds. It would be nice if SF could elect a mayor that could improve efficiency as opposed to simply encouraging people to make up their own policies.
- mmanfrin 10y agotaking it upon themselves to decide for everyone else how a city should operate How so? They aren't dictating traffic flow, they are adding visibility markers to existing bike lanes.
- lubujackson 10y agoMaybe the markers are too high and will hit some car mirrors. Maybe they impede lane access for turning vehicles. Maybe they are too close together, too far apart or too distracting to drivers or too close to bicyclists. Maybe they are not well grounded and if hit one will fly into traffic causing an accident. That being said, these are probably completely fine. But there's lot of reasons why having a process for infrastructure changes makes sense. At the same time, I applaud SF for being pragmatic about it and accepting of these people while working toward a long term solution.
- moyta 10y agoIf your door mirror is getting hit, you are driving way too close to the markers and they are doing their job. Hug the shoulder less, unless you like no mirrors & damage to the side of your car.
- stanleydrew 10y agoThat's the most generous possible interpretation of the situation. It may be correct, I'm just noting. I ride my bike to and from work pretty much every day in SF, and I readily admit that adding these markers most definitely does interrupt and disrupt traffic flow. The fact of the matter is, sometimes delivery vehicles and service vehicles need to stop and block traffic. They tend to pull over as far as possible to the right, so as not to impede auto traffic. Often this means pulling over into the bike lane. (Note that when there is no bike lane, these vehicles block the right-most lane of auto traffic and cars just go around without getting too hot and bothered. But I digress.) Erecting the markers prevents this behavior in many instances. You can decide to be in favor of the new bike lane markers, but you can't pretend that the added markers aren't a unilateral alteration to traffic flow that does have an effect.
- alwaysdoit 10y agoYou mean, sometimes delivery vehicles and service vehicles illegally choose to stop and block traffic.
- tdfischer 10y ago> but a small group of people taking it upon themselves to decide for everyone else how a city should operate is a very tricky place for any society to be. good thing we don't have small groups of organized opposition showing up to these things and blocking progress while calling themselves "concerned neighbors" or "neighborhood coalitions" oops no wait thats whats happening now.
- myowncrapulence 10y agoa small group of people taking it upon themselves to decide for everyone else how a city should operate is a very tricky place for any society to be You realize, you just described the government right?
- edblarney 10y agoThe government is elected and acts for and in the behest of the plebes, they're not just an arbitrary group doing as they think best. Well, unless you're very cynical :)
- megablast 10y ago> Maybe it's for the better, maybe it's for the worse - but a small group of people taking it upon themselves to decide for everyone else how a city should operate is a very tricky place for any society to be. This already happens, unless you imagine that we are voting on every single issue such as new stop signs or changed traffic flows?
- qq66 10y agoAt least in SF, there is a public hearing for any new permanent stop sign.
- TulliusCicero 10y ago> Maybe it's for the better, maybe it's for the worse - but a small group of people taking it upon themselves to decide for everyone else how a city should operate is a very tricky place for any society to be. The actions these groups are taking line up with city goals. Not only that, most of the time they're upgrading infrastructure that already exists, not creating something entirely new.
- tn13 10y agoIt all looks good until someday another car loving group might erect something else that harms others.
- hiou 10y agoWell you'll be happy to know that my comment about democracy was forcibly removed by the mods. I won't repost it since it was made quite clear the opinion contrasted with the mod's opinion and not welcome here.
- aninhumer 10y agoYour comment was clearly removed because it was unnecessarily hostile. Many other people have made the same point more civilly, and their comments were left alone.
- gohrt 10y ago> how neighborhood watch groups can supplement police, neighborhood watch groups DO NOT supplement police. Police supplement neighborhood watch groups. Police are only necessary when civilian management fails.
- vidoc 10y ago> Kind of like how neighborhood watch groups can supplement police Is this a Sarcasm? :)
- qq66 10y agoWould it go against democracy for a billionaire to install bollards around his Bentley, merely drawing attention to a parking spot that the city has embraced on paper?