3 ms·
How people prioritize issues based on facts is different from whether the facts are true. I agree that you or I can disagree on prioritization of issues. People
by grzm 10y ago
How people prioritize issues based on facts is different from whether the facts are true. I agree that you or I can disagree on prioritization of issues. People can also be wrong about which facts they believe. For example, if someone believes that New York City is the capital of the state of New York, they're factually wrong. They're misinformed.
For a more political fact, Barack Obama either was or was not born in the US. People made political decisions based on whether or not this is true. For the argument I'm making, it doesn't matter whether or not it's true. It's that a fact is politically important.
If you're arguing that which facts are true is ultimately relative, I'm not going to chase you down that particular rabbit hole.
Perhaps what I'm saying is obvious and trivial to you, and we're speaking past each other.
- ThomPete 10y agoOf course there are facts not disagreeing there. What I disagree with is whether they impact the voters as has been claimed (not necessarily by you) and which I believe is the base of this whole thread here. The critical thinking only help you based on your premise it doesn't give you the "right" premise IMO.
- grzm 10y agoGreat! We agree that there are facts! :) (That's sincere, by the way. Sometimes it seems even that common ground is frustratingly hard to find.) As for impact on voters: Do you think there were any voters that cast their vote in part on their belief whether or not Obama was born in the US?
- ThomPete 10y agoNot enough for it to be a meaningful factor. Keep in mind many of the people who voted in Trump also voted in Obama.
- grzm 10y agoCool. I think it's fair to say that we agree 1) There are facts. 2) Facts have an impact on voters. The open question then is 3) The weight voters give these facts varies from voter to voter and fact to fact. Is that fair? I can certainly agree to that. What do you think?
- ThomPete 10y agoI am not sure how to interpret what you mean with 2) I agree that facts impact voters, but thats not really important. Whats important is which facts impact them. I.e. the facts that a Trump voter cares about vs. the ones that a Hillary voter cares about. I don't believe people voted based non-facts. They voted on the facts they know to be true and important to them. I.e. I don't subscribe to some idea of a false consciousness.
- grzm 10y agoI don't have some super secret agenda. 2) is just as it says. And by the rest, "Whats important is which facts impact them. I.e. the facts that a Trump voter cares about vs. the ones that a Hillary voter cares about.", I think you agree with 3). My reaction is solely on the idea that people can't believe facts that aren't true, that they can't be misinformed, and that the news plays no role in misinforming them. This goes back to "Everyone in a democracy is informed, there is no such thing as uninformed voters per se... News fake or not isn't what drive most peoples decisions " The news is a source of information/facts for people. Some of those facts may be false, and people may believe facts that aren't true. People who believe facts that aren't true are uninformed/misinformed. Perhaps a source of misunderstanding is I'm making little distinction between uninformed and misinformed, equating for these purposes misinformed and uninformed of the truth regarding a fact they accept. I do agree that people are subject to confirmation bias, fitting facts to what they believe more often than not. Jonathan Haidt's elephant/rider metaphor seems apt as well. This seems in line with your statements on how facts influence views. I had to look up false consciousness. While I do think there are misinformation and disinformation campaigns (which is what some campaigning seems to be reduced to, nowadays), I don't subscribe to some purposeful, widespread, institutional, systemic propaganda machine. Some may argue that I'm likely just naïve. By the way, I'm trying to reach some shared understanding. I'm not arguing for the sake of argument or just trying to argue against whatever you happen to say. I hope that's clear :) I don't think we're actually all that far off in opinion, if at all. Perhaps we're just prioritizing different parts of the equation. Thanks for sticking with this by the way, and remaining civil. I'm sure you've noticed as well how off the rails a lot of these discussions can go.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Keep in mind many of the people who voted in Trump also voted in Obama. Evidence that this meets any reasonable definition of many voters? Even in the states that flipped, the numbers aren't such that mathematically many (or even any) voters need to have switched that direction. There's probably some, but I haven't seen any indictation in any source that suggests substantial numbers.
- ThomPete 10y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/politics/2016-election/obama-trump-counties/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/politics/2016-electi...
- dragonwriter 10y agoNothing in that article makes the case (there's a subhead which assumes it, but all the details talk about counties, not people.) With new voters coming of age, old voters dying, far less than 100% turnout so even of the people who could vote in both elections those who actually do might not be the same, counties can switch without people switching. So, yeah, I'm sure there are some Obama/Trump voters, but I haven't seen a coherent case that there are a lot, just generous application of the fallacy of division.
- ThomPete 10y agoUnless you have evidence that somehow those areas changed voters then I don't see what exactly you are questioning. 1/3 of Mexicans voted on Trump, Hillary only got 10% more female voters. Nothing indicates that the voters changed completely from one election to another.