3 ms·
> They aren't forcing subsidized parking. They're forcing the construction of parking lots and structures. The part where they're required to build these lots
by TulliusCicero 10y ago
> They aren't forcing subsidized parking. They're forcing the construction of parking lots and structures.
The part where they're required to build these lots virtually always results in subsidized parking. Yes, technically you could charge for spots, and then they wouldn't be subsidized, but in practice that's so much effort that it's much easier to just let the spots be free. For most businesses, running a paid parking scheme involves too much overhead to be worth it.
> This causes congestion (cars circling trying to find parking) and makes going to these areas less pleasant.
Then the city can charge; since they'd be doing it in many areas (and many cities already charge for this anyway in a section of their core), it's much less of a burden for them to do it than for individual businesses.
> How do these other countries deal with the lack of parking?
In Tokyo, you can't buy/register a car unless you can prove you have an off-street space.
> I think simply suggesting better public transportation and redesigned cities does not solve problems that people are having right now.
Well yeah, actually implementing those things is what's important.
- overcyn 10y agoLike you say, for most businesses running a paid parking scheme is too much overhead to be worth it. But you would remove requirements for minimum amounts of parking. So wouldn't you expect in areas with limited parking the issue to be exacerbated, since business would have less incentive to build parking? You say that the city can then charge for parking, but also that they already do it, so not much would change there... Re-planning cities takes a long time. Do you suggest people just take taxis/uber for a decade until public transportation catches up? Might not be the worst idea.
- TulliusCicero 10y ago> So wouldn't you expect in areas with limited parking the issue to be exacerbated, since business would have less incentive to build parking? Yes. This is actually the natural outcome one would expect from the market; it takes a lot of resources to provide storage for cars, and those costs will result in things like, say, less parking. > You say that the city can then charge for parking, but also that they already do it, so not much would change there... Many (most?) cities do it in a small part of their urban core. I'm suggesting they could expand those areas. They can also adjust the price of parking as the supply:demand ratio changes. Additionally, past a certain point, it becomes worthwhile for developers to create parking garages as a standalone business. > Re-planning cities takes a long time. Do you suggest people just take taxis/uber for a decade until public transportation catches up? Might not be the worst idea. Of course not. Removing parking requirements wouldn't result in massive change overnight. There would be plenty of time to improve transit (and walking and biking) as the number of parking spaces gradually declined.