5 ms·
Lots of problems with IRV: * Realities Mar Instant Runoff Voting 18 Flaws and 4 Benefits, http://electionmathematics.org/ucvAnalysis/US/RCV-IRV/InstantRunoffVo
by naasking 10y ago
Lots of problems with IRV:
* Realities Mar Instant Runoff Voting
18 Flaws and 4 Benefits, http://electionmathematics.org/ucvAnalysis/US/RCV-IRV/InstantRunoffVotingFlaws.pdf http://electionmathematics.org/ucvAnalysis/US/RCV-IRV/Instan...
* Instant Runoff Voting: A Cure That is Likely Worse Than the Disease, https://www.uvm.edu/~dguber/POLS125/articles/langan.htm https://www.uvm.edu/~dguber/POLS125/articles/langan.htm
* Instant Runoff Voting: Looks Good--But Look Again, http://www1.cs.columbia.edu/~unger/articles/irv.html http://www1.cs.columbia.edu/~unger/articles/irv.html
- dilap 10y agohow likely are these situations to arise in practice?
- naasking 10y agoWhat situations specifically? The first link I provided describes a number of issues, like increased susceptibility to fraud. Another link describes how IRV is probably illegal in the US.
- dilap 10y agoah, sorry, I was referring to the second link, where it describes a scenario where even though more people would have preferred B over C, C won.
- unethical_ban 10y agoLots of problems with FPTP as well. I'll look at your links, but I'm skeptical of one's motives when you just this out links. We needed to eliminate the two party oligarchy.
- naasking 10y ago> I'll look at your links, but I'm skeptical of one's motives when you just this out links. Are you similarly skeptical of the motives of every poster who posts a story on HN? They're just links too after all. That just seems like a bizarre statement. Either my links contain valid criticisms by recognized authority figures, or they do not. I don't see how adding more verbiage of my own makes the information I presented more or less trustworthy.
- unethical_ban 10y agoI thought about this after I posted, but since I was using a mobile app I couldn't edit at the time. It was unfair to make character accusations for such a minor thing. I'm so suspicious of "shills" ala reddit posters that I didn't take the time to look at your comment history or consider that you may be a real person and not a paid account. Non-sarcastically, I'm trying to get better at that.
- jerednel 10y agoThe first article talks about logistics of doing it in practice, which as other countries and Maine will see, can be done. Another article pushes Ranged voting which is in the same family as IRV. Overall IRV > current process.
- naasking 10y ago> The first article talks about logistics of doing it in practice, which as other countries and Maine will see, can be done. The flaws consist of more than simple logistical problems, such as: * The requirement to count votes centrally to handle ranked choice makes it more susceptible to fraud (flaw #2 and #16). * Makes exit polls virtually useless as third-party verification vote data, which just compounds the flaws of the above (flaw #7) -- this all ties into auditing difficulties (flaw #9). * They cite data that IRV actually entrenches the two-party system wherever it's been tried, so it doesn't actually solve some of the problems it's supposed to solve (flaw #11). * Counter-intuitive results, such as ranking your first choice last could cause them to win, while ranking them first could cause them to lose (flaw #12). * They cite data suggesting that IRV favours extremist candidates, or candidates that are worse for everyone except special interests (flaw #13, similar to flaw #12). * Not all votes are treated equally, so some votes count more than others (flaw #14) None of these are logistical problems. The other links I provided suggested that IRV may actually be illegal in the US for various reasons. So I'm not convinced that IRV is better than the current process.
- rtkwe 10y agoIf you're going to link to ~50 pages of content the least you could do is summarize or pull out some interesting bits. Some of these are real logistical issues but are certainly solvable. There's no real reason that we have to know the results immediately other than a desire to know. And a couple examples like ex 4 in your third link are really unlikely to happen because to make them work you have to have a lot of information about the ranked choices of other voters.
- naasking 10y agoWhy is that my job? Why would you even believe my summary? If you want to be informed on a topic, at least read the abstracts of my links.
- bradbeattie 10y agoAn example of IRV's misbehaviour: * 8 people vote: A, C, B * 5 people vote: B, C, A * 4 people vote: C, B, A IRV eliminates C and elects B, but the majority of voters prefer C over B (12 to 5). The order of elimination dropped 8 ballots' information that they prefer C over B. To put that generally, IRV ignores the secondary preferences of large demographics. Perhaps another example of why I think single winner voting systems should take all preferences into account (as Condorcet methods do): * 100 people vote CentristX * 101 people vote PolarizedCandidateA > CentristX * 101 people vote PolarizedCandidateB > CentristX * 101 people vote PolarizedCandidateC > CentristX * 101 people vote PolarizedCandidateD > CentristX The example is a bit contrived, but it highlights how disregarding secondary preferences (IRV's main feature) isn't a good idea. 403 people prefer CentristX over every other polarized candidate, yet CentristX is dropped in IRV's first round. Disclaimer: I run modernballots, a voting website that makes use of the Schulze-family of voting systems: https://modernballots.com/elections/zombies/vote/ https://modernballots.com/elections/zombies/vote/
- mjhoy 10y agoHow often is this sort of thing actually a problem? Are there examples of elections that turned out this way?
- rce 10y agoWould you prefer some alternative like approval voting or range voting?
- naasking 10y agoI don't know enough about alternatives to say, I just remember reading about fundamental problems with IRV and dug up some links that confirmed what I remembered.