4 ms·
New York, San Francisco, and Washington D.C. have significantly higher commute times (including by public transit) than less dense cities. New York's subway rid
by closeparen 10y ago
New York, San Francisco, and Washington D.C. have significantly higher commute times (including by public transit) than less dense cities. New York's subway riders have it particularly bad, spending an average of 7.5 hours per week on the trains [0]. This is despite those cities having some of the best transit systems in the country [1].
I'm aware of the finding that lower commute times are associated with happiness, but that makes the opposite of your argument. The lowest commute times are found in small, low-density, car-oriented cities. Even in New York, drivers and taxi-riders have shorter commutes than public transit users.
As you'll see in the report, a very lucky few have short walks, but it is not at all the norm. I surmise that if you can afford to live within walking distance of work in New York, you're likely an order of magnitude too rich to need to work.
Your other points are valid, but I'm highly skeptical that these benefits are worth the extra $2000/mo they bring in housing costs (when collapsing a 3-bedroom house family into a 1-bedroom apartment), particularly when we are talking about people who do not have $2000/mo.
I say this as a relatively new Berkeley to SF public transit commuter. I love my job, but I'd rather stab my eyes out than spend 80 minutes on overstuffed, lurching BART trains every day for the rest of my life. Fortunately, the gruesome death vs. BART tradeoff is available in the form of motorcycling, which I'm trying next.
[0] http://origin-states.politico.com.s3-website-us-east-1.amazonaws.com/files/Embargoed%20Hardest%20Working%20Cities%20Study.pdf http://origin-states.politico.com.s3-website-us-east-1.amazo...
[1] http://ao.umn.edu/research/america/transit/2014/index.html http://ao.umn.edu/research/america/transit/2014/index.html
- oblio 10y agoBut is driving the same as being in public transport? You can read a book, watch a video, and in general not pay attention to your surroundings (more or less). Meanwhile driving in traffic is half boring, half stressful.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 10y agoGetting a seat is absolutely not the norm during commute hours. Two transit systems I use (BART and CTA) are actually migrating rolling stock to designs with fewer seats to free up more standing room. Unless you board at the beginning of the line and show up well before departure, you're going to be standing. Likely pressed up against strangers, holding the overhead rail, trying to keep balanced while the operator does his best to knock you over with violent throttle and brake inputs. On rare, blissful occasions I'll get some wall to lean on. Usually stuck in the center. I have tried to read this way, but it doesn't work well. It's hard to find a nook where there's enough space in front of me to hold a book. The one handed book grasp is awkward, and I always seem to choose the wrong moment to take my other hand off the rail to turn a page. You can wear headphones, same as you can listen to the the radio while driving. I wish I could not pay attention to my surroundings; that's pretty hard when in a hot stuffy smelly claustrophobic space trying my hardest not to make physical contact with strangers' bodies.
- Eric_WVGG 10y agoHealthier too, as much of that time is spent walking or standing instead of sitting on your ass.
- malyk 10y agoBART is way over capacity and a terrible experience for sure. Have you tried the transbay busses? I ride the F from North Oakland every day and I have a seat every morning and, with a little planning, a seat every night on the way home (get to the stop early). A motorcycle will probably be faster, but a 40 minute "leisurely" commute on the transbay is a pretty nice option. http://www.actransit.org/transbay-lines-in-east-bay-neighborhoods/#Berkeley http://www.actransit.org/transbay-lines-in-east-bay-neighbor...
- closeparen 10y agoThe Transbay buses are all standing room by the time they get to me, and I've been denied boarding several times. BART is somewhat easier to stand on then they are.