6 ms·
I propose a fundamental principle that should be obvious, but apparently isn't.
Public policy should aim to improve average quality of life in the short, mediu
I propose a fundamental principle that should be obvious, but apparently isn't.
Public policy should aim to improve average quality of life in the short, medium, and long terms.
We live in low-population-density areas because we get more, higher quality housing for less money, shorter lines, less crowded public places. We drive instead of taking transit because we get where we're going faster and more comfortably, sitting down, with our personal space bubbles intact.
Everything is tradeoffs. You can already make these tradeoffs for yourself by moving to SF or Manhattan, which is generally ill-advised unless you make so much that the astronomical housing costs don't hurt too badly. Why should the rest of us be required to make these tradeoffs? What are we getting in return? 'Cause it sure isn't better commutes or better homes.
If your argument is long-term sustainability, we have electric cars now and we've had nuclear power for quite some time, and a public policy kick in that direction is, I'd argue, critical to long-term quality of life.
Part of the purpose of a public place is for people to be around other people. Considering that, isn't it counterproductive to actively work to make them less crowded?
Many of the benefits you listed are good examples of how people are actually pretty bad at predicting what will make them happier. We have a lot of data on the subject.
- People think that living in a larger home will make them happier than a shorter commute. Cohort studies show the opposite is true. We adapt most quickly to things (good/bad) that stay the same (like the size of your house), and poorly to things that change (like the traffic situation from day to day).
- People think they will be more active if surrounded by parks and greenery, but city dwellers actually walk/bike more. People moving to the city lose weight within a few months (~3 lb. if I remember correctly)
- People think that cities are dangerous, but you are more likely to be killed young in the suburbs. This is because car accidents are far more likely than homicides, and you drive more in the suburbs.
We know people in cities are, on average, happier and healthier.
I think this depends vastly on the city. An unhealthy city won't have these kinds of benefits.
I think, particularly in the climate that I'm in, a /cave of steel/ style city WOULD have those benefits. If instead of streets for cars we had a mesh of (Babylon 5 style) 'zocolo' (sp) markets that had smaller storefronts and a lightly park like median.
It's a funny thing. I don't mind a long commute, of say, 1 hour each way mostly highway. I can use that time to listen to podcasts, audiobooks, or music. Things I rarely find time to in my daily life. But if I have 1 hour commute in heavy traffic, I feel that I'm wasting my time. The former I'm okay with, the latter I avoid at all cost, even if the net result is the same for me.
10y ago
Quality of life is very difficult to measure. Average quality of life is probably worse than median quality of life. What about minimum quality of live? Should we make the life of the very poor worse if it improves the lives of the middle class?
I think the problem is a lot more difficult than what can be addressed with a single sentence.
> You can already make these tradeoffs for yourself by moving to SF or Manhattan, which is generally ill-advised unless you make so much that the astronomical housing costs don't hurt too badly.
The shoe is on the other foot. The reason why rent is so high in these places is because there's a lot of demand to live there - people do find it desirable.
If more cities were built like SF or Manhattan (i.e. there was more supply) then it would be more affordable to more people.
The reason these places should be built is because people clearly like it. That's the advantage.
> The reason why rent is so high in these places is because there's a lot of demand to live there -
No. Mere demand alone does not raise costs. There is a lot of demand for water, but it is still super cheap.
Prices are high when demand is high and supply is low.
The reason that prices in Manhattan and SF are high is because (a) lots of people want to live there, and simultaneously (b) government policies severely limit the ability of developers to generate more housing units there.
You've worded it better, so thank you, but I believe my main point stands.
Exactly, and since high density cities are more common in Europe it is also more affordable there.
I've heard stories about SF's housing problems, but not about Manhattan. I know Manhattan is expensive, but it's also full of some of the tallest buildings in the world, and more are built every day. Are there actually policies restricting housing in Manhattan?
I have recently moved to Miami from the UK. I am not enjoying the low-density lifestyle.
The lack of useful public transit (4 hours for a 20 mile trip because of cross scheduling). It feels like I live inside a ring of steel and rubber - if I want to leave my local area after work it is 2 hours for a 15 mile round trip.
No clustering of shops that generate footfall which builds a sense of community and opportunity for new business - drive to shop, buy thing, drive away. There is no discovery.
I haven't owned a car in the UK for 10 years, now I need one to buy groceries.
I do appreciate that I could move somewhere else and seek out those things in other communities but I am tied to my geography by work. If I was here long term I would certainly try and move jobs to get better quality of life.
New York, San Francisco, and Washington D.C. have significantly higher commute times (including by public transit) than less dense cities. New York's subway riders have it particularly bad, spending an average of 7.5 hours per week on the trains [0]. This is despite those cities having some of the best transit systems in the country [1].
I'm aware of the finding that lower commute times are associated with happiness, but that makes the opposite of your argument. The lowest commute times are found in small, low-density, car-oriented cities. Even in New York, drivers and taxi-riders have shorter commutes than public transit users.
As you'll see in the report, a very lucky few have short walks, but it is not at all the norm. I surmise that if you can afford to live within walking distance of work in New York, you're likely an order of magnitude too rich to need to work.
Your other points are valid, but I'm highly skeptical that these benefits are worth the extra $2000/mo they bring in housing costs (when collapsing a 3-bedroom house family into a 1-bedroom apartment), particularly when we are talking about people who do not have $2000/mo.
I say this as a relatively new Berkeley to SF public transit commuter. I love my job, but I'd rather stab my eyes out than spend 80 minutes on overstuffed, lurching BART trains every day for the rest of my life. Fortunately, the gruesome death vs. BART tradeoff is available in the form of motorcycling, which I'm trying next.
[0] http://origin-states.politico.com.s3-website-us-east-1.amazonaws.com/files/Embargoed%20Hardest%20Working%20Cities%20Study.pdf http://origin-states.politico.com.s3-website-us-east-1.amazo...
[1] http://ao.umn.edu/research/america/transit/2014/index.html http://ao.umn.edu/research/america/transit/2014/index.html
The one thing that definitely won't make people happy is someone else telling them they don't know how to make themselves happy. People want choice, even if that means making a few incorrect choices.
>We know people in cities are, on average, happier and healthier.
Some people really dislike cities. I need woods. I need open spaces. I need to see the stars at night. I need a place for my dog to run without some stranger screaming about leash rules. But I also need to work. Personal transport, my own vehicle to carry myself and my dog, allows me to both work and enjoy the open spaces. So I'm all for parking spots.
And yes, weather permitting, my dog does come to costco with me. She would much rather sit in the car than sit at home. If she wants we'll hit any number of dog parks on the way home. If I took the bus, or Uber, she would have to sit at home ... alone all afternoon rather than being with me. That's what having parking spots at Costco means for us.
And I don't have a problem with this, but I do have a problem with minimum numbers of parking spots, or giant parking lots that are unutilized during the night or while you're not at work.
Parking spots at place should like Costco are notoriously bad for the planet and aren't some of the least efficient things possible. At some point, the things you value (such as your parks and woods and scenery) are going to brush up against this suburban sprawl and you're going to be upset.
If you value green spaces, you should be encouraging the disuse of cars and mass parking lots.
America is extremely large, our economy is shrinking not growing, and our native population is not growing either.
Note that the above situation is fractal similar at different scales ranging from my state to the entire world. Similar but not identical.
> People want choice, even if that means making a few incorrect choices.
I don't agree. I often feel liberated when someone takes away a meaningless choice from me. If (and only if) the choices that are left are acceptable to me, of course.
For example, I was going to shop for a new kitchen, and I hated the idea of it. Having to comb through dozens of wood and handle options, arguing all day about the layout, it sounded really dreadful. Then my brother moved into a new house that had a kitchen, so I just bought his old one and had it installed at my home. That was absolutely awesome. I didn't have to think about anything.
> takes away a meaningless choice from me
What is meaningless is completely subjective to every person, so there is no way to remove options without affecting someone.
Also, how do you buy a "kitchen"?
> We know people in cities are, on average, happier and healthier.
I've lived in both and had a happy, healthy life in both.
When I was young, the city was definitely where I wanted to be. I loved the energy and the density. I was close to my friends and because of easy transportation, could get to them anytime I want.
Almost thirty years later, I'm now living in the 'burbs and I never want to leave. It's quiet and I have space to work on my motorcycle, I have a garden, I like my neighbors and I like that they aren't right on top of me. It's fantastic for dog walking and my office is a very scenic 7 mile bike ride from my home.
With self-driving cars on the horizon, I think the suburbs might go through some type of re-birth.
And I think everyone is OK with your choice, they just don't want to subsidize it.
> With self-driving cars on the horizon, I think the suburbs might go through some type of re-birth.
Suburban sprawl. I have several concerns with that. In places like San Francisco, there is no space to sprawl. It’s healthier for kids to use physical activity to move around. Only 7 miles from the office? When everybody goes to the suburbs, typical commuting distances are measured in the dozens of, or even over 100, miles.
But I haven’t seen an answer to the concern about economic sustainability. The tax revenues from the properties have not been high enough to maintain the infrastructure, and likely cannot be high enough with middle-class people living there. I can imagine Donald Trump, how would he solve it? Hire contractors to rebuild the infrastructure and then threaten to sue them when they present the bill? That’s how he built his own properties. I don’t think it will work for the rest of the nation.
http://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme/ http://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme/
Even in mildly dense areas like San Francisco, revenues do not cover maintenance. The BART district just passed bonds to rebuild the tracks, but we haven’t finished paying off the bonds to construct the tracks. This entire region needs to become dramatically more dense, preferably gradually over the last 50 years, but now we might finally have the political will to do it; just so we can afford to maintain the infrastructure.
Hugely. It's possible to build extremely tall buildings in certain specific areas of Manhattan (and New York in general, like in Downtown Brooklyn), but most of the city is "maxed out" to its zoning - that is, the tallest building that can be legally built is already there. Indeed, in many places, the existing buildings are taller than the zoning code allows - so if you demolished an old building, you'd have to build a shorter one in its place!
"people do find it desirable"
Americans are culturally completely blind to narrowcasting, in this case narrowcasted beliefs about lifestyle.
For example, millions of people are rabid extreme fans of the TV show "Survivor". Its economically important. Its culturally and socially relevant (well, to its super fans who insist on seeing life thru a "Survivor" lens). Enormous sums of money change hands over this one TV show, from its production to its marketing to small time betting. Large amounts of social signalling happen about this TV show. There's nothing wrong with this little hobby of theirs, and they should be left alone. And there's a lot of them.
Yet... yet 29 in 30 people won't watch that TV show for free. Regardless of its economic activity or price or value to an extremely small minority of the population, its value to 97% of the population is zero to negative. For 29 out of 30 people doing anything else is preferable to watching that free TV show.
Someone not blind to narrowcasting can hold both interpretations in their head at the same time.
I would theorize the numbers are not all that different with an analogy of urban living. You can slap any price you'd want on a NYC, SF, SV condo or house, and maybe even get it from another urbanite, but for 29 out of 30 people the value of that property would be zero to negative regardless of the price. That's kinda why almost no one lives there now. There's nothing "wrong" with living there although statistically roughly no one wants to.
I think that philosophical outlook mixes well with that 1984 style authoritarian streak that Americans have, "everything that is permissible must be compulsory" Because we're not going to disassemble and resettle the cities Pol Pot style, we must permit them, and if we permit something it must be compulsory for all, therefore all humans must be moved into cities for their own good regardless of their own opinions on the topic and any deviation from the party line that its a universal good with no downsides is double plus badthink not to be tolerated.
There is likely a lot of "crab pot" thinking where people suffering will do anything to stop others from ending their suffering. Every broken into car, every mugging, every raping, every shooting, all are proof we must stick together to keep everyone else in the city or else I'll have to run for it too. How dare he think himself better than us, we better drag him back down into this crab pot of a city.
I did not advocate for everyone living in cities. I advocated for more city housing, as currently it is unaffordable to many who do want to live in them due to demand outstripping supply. If you want to see my view as Pol Pot style authoritanrianism, well, I'm not even sure where to start.
We need more city housing because there's plenty of demand. I understand plenty of people want to live in rural areas, and I wish them well.
Decreasing the viability of suburban life will create more pressure for urban apartments as suburbanites get tired of crowded trains and move to the city center. If your more housing comes with an effective requirement for everyone who works in the city to live in that housing, we should expect the price to go up.
deleted 10y ago
[deleted]