12 ms·
There was a study a while back that showed that the USA has eight times as many parking spaces as it has cars. At first that seems crazy, but it makes sense if
by jedberg 10y ago
There was a study a while back that showed that the USA has eight times as many parking spaces as it has cars.
At first that seems crazy, but it makes sense if you think about the fact that all the places you go in a day need to have enough parking to meet their peak demand all year, so places like malls have huge empty lots most of the year until Christmas rolls around. And then there is the spot your car is in at work that's empty at night and the spot you park in at home that's empty during the day.
Another nice benefit of self driving cars that are shared is the major reduction in the need to all this excess parking.
- makecheck 10y agoThere is also the concept of “ground cover” in some places. I have seen office buildings create gigantic parking lots just to “occupy” all their land so that the land cannot be taken away later. If land is completely undeveloped then it can be reclaimed in some situations, e.g. someone decides they want to build a railway.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoBuilding a parking lot will in no way save you from the imminent domain powers of people who want to build roads and railroads. This strikes me as some kind of urban legend. Every place I've lived has mandated some ratio of parking to floor space in new office buildings, which is why office buildings are surrounded by parking.
- vadskye 10y agoPedantic correction: The term is "eminent domain". In fairness, if someone exercises the power of eminent domain, the domain will imminently be theirs, but that's neither here nor there.
- enraged_camel 10y agoThat said, under eminent domain the government is required to pay you the fair market price of the land it is taking from you. That's why it's in companies' best interest to not let their land sit undeveloped.
- makecheck 10y agoMaybe a railway isn’t a realistic example. A nature preserve might be a better one; they can’t decide to cordon off an area for wildlife if you’ve already destroyed all the trees, whereas untouched land might fall into that category. The examples I can think of were in Texas and I’m sure the rules vary by region.
- briandear 10y agoI highly doubt people in Texas are building parking lots to protect against a nature preserve. It's generally because of parking requirements established by building codes.
- djsumdog 10y agoI think we wouldn't see things as being nearly this bad if all American cities didn't rip out their tram networks. Every city I've lived in, even small ones with ~100k people, use to have Streetcars. Today, cities like Cincinnati struggle to get a tiny segment put in. Trams carry a ton more people than buses. People are more likely to ride them too. If American cities hadn't given in to GM and Ford and kept streetcars instead of replacing them with buses (that have lower capacity, use up more fuel, etc.) I think parking in the US, and car ownership in general, would be very different.
- erentz 10y agoNot only that but the suburbs built up around these streetcar networks are typically the preferred places to live in cities these days, due to their walkable neighborhoods.
- flukus 10y agoShopping centers are rare because business is typically spread out along the length of the line.
- bsznjyewgd 10y agoI don't really get why trams are better than buses. Do they really carry a ton more people than buses? Why are people more likely to ride them? Buses come in short/long/articulated/double-decker sizes and don't need to be on rails or require overhead electrical lines. The only argument I can think of is that you get a smoother ride and no need to burn fuel with a tram. (I've only ridden the trams in one city, and they were pretty much slower buses on rails that happened to make a lot of dinging noises. Worked fine in the central district, I guess.)
- oh_sigh 10y agoOne benefit is trams aren't subject to traffic, but theoretically you could have a dedicated bus lane to achieve that same result.
- 10y ago
- yason 10y agoAlso roads are built for the peak consumption. Outside the peak, there's generally excess capacity quietly eating away space from pedestrians and human beings.
- mjevans 10y agoThis is VERY MUCH a falsehood. Have you ever commuted during the very ironically named 'rush hour'. (Everyone would much rather go fast, and it usually takes much longer than an hour)
- TulliusCicero 10y agoJust because it was originally built for peak demand doesn't mean peak demand won't eventually exceed that as the population grows.
- malyk 10y agoIt's called "Induced Demand". That combined with "drive until you qualify" lead to over congestion on roads that were built to "peak" demand.
- briandear 10y agoRoads are built for average consumption. If they were built for peak consumption there'd be no such thing as rush hour or traffic jams. You could make the same argument about sidewalks -- at 4am, sidewalks have excess capacity eating away space that could be instead planted with foliage and serve as a habitat for animals. Unless there's 24/7 equal use of everything, there's always going to be excess capacity at some point. Your bathroom is unused probably 90% of the day, so why not open it up for neighbors to share? That would be far more efficient than having every house with their own bathroom.
- VLM 10y agoI sleep less than 12 hours per day... I only type on my keyboard maybe half the day, so I could share a keyboard at work to save huge amounts of capital on a world wide basis. The dystopian world of the future looks like life on board a nuclear attack submarine, where no one owns a car, everyone works at home, two people have to share a bed (involuntarily, mostly), no one is allowed to cook their own food, only a tiny percentage of the population have the intelligence and social skills to survive it but everyone is united that everyone should be forced at the point of a gun to live exactly this way, all your time and your entire life is planned out by big brother with little to no care about your own personal concerns, living density is extremely high, no one can have kids, the whole lifestyle is financed by hand waving and ridiculous unsustainable and unscalable financial scams, constant uncontrollable interruptions, energy all comes from green (ish) sources which are ecologically harmless unless some pipe springs a leak and then an entire village dies horribly, apparently people do nothing when off duty and have no personal hobbies other than getting drunk in cheap dive bars as often as possible, your life depends on a minimum of 500 CPUs all programmed by the lowest bidder with a literal army of people trying to crack security which would result fairly inevitably in your rapid and painful death. But other than that, its pretty awesome.
- forgettableuser 10y agoInteresting. Now you got me thinking more about what things might change with self-driving cars. Will cars offer an "orbiting" mode where they keep driving in a circle until you are ready to be picked up. Will stores offer a driving ring where cars can drive around in circles off the main street in the case where no parking slots are available? Will cars be able to drop you off, and park themselves when a space becomes available? Will the cars notify you where they parked, or will they always come to your location? (And what if you are standing in an area that is impossible to drive to...where does the car go?) I can't wait for self-driving cars. This will be a lot of fun to see how the world changes in both the large and small.
- michaelmrose 10y agoDriving in a circle still isn't free it either costs gas or electricity. When you park your car you are constrained to park it relatively nearby. Logically your car lacking a parking spot at your location will seek one nearby until it has traveled far enough that it is logical for it to turn around and drive back to you. In some cases perhaps it will rejoin the pool of available cars and you will picked up by a different car. Perhaps retailers will be yet more likely to offer to ship selected large or awkward items directly to your home after you have picked them out.
- jessaustin 10y agoPerhaps retailers... Yes they'll be happy to pay a premium for delivery trucks that require no drivers. Time-of-day flexibility will enable serving more customers with the same size fleet. Many customers will be more willing to use delivery when they can plan around working hours and don't have to worry about tipping. Service levels won't be subject to mistakes in shift planning.
- erentz 10y agoCars moving take up more space that stationary parked cars. What you've stumbled on is actually a concern for transit planners - more traffic because self driving cars are circling without any passengers.
- Zach_the_Lizard 10y agoEven at peak demand many spots are empty. The reason for so much parking is that it is legally required. Nothing more, nothing less. Many of the businesses will never make full use of their parking. Places without parking requirement laws develop very differently, and if parking is provided at all, it's usually in far smaller quantities and it's not free. Compare, say, third tier Japanese cities that lack subway systems to American equivalents. Parking exists, but it's not universally free, and there's less of it. You should read up on parking minimum laws.
- loeg 10y agoThat might apply in cities, but I don't believe parking spaces at suburban malls are typically regulated.
- ianferrel 10y agoYou are probably incorrect. Suburbs generally have parking requirements in their zoning laws as well.
- loeg 10y agoI'm talking only about malls.
- Zach_the_Lizard 10y agoYou are actually not correct; suburban areas have more intense and all encompassing parking minimum laws. Manhattan, for instance, has either none or none below 125th Street IIRC. Suburbs look like they do not because of preference but because it is not legal for them to look otherwise. The idea in the 50s was: A) Require cars to live and you will not have to live next to poor people or minorities since cars and maintenance of them are expensive, how great; Jim Crow without the legal challenges and we can co-opt non racist people B) Cars are the future and no one needs to walk, except maybe in parks C) Since this glorious future has yet to arrive naturally despite decades of mass produced automobiles, we'll need to legislate it into existence and massively fund highways D) Cities are the source of all ills Other than the racist motivations, it's really just poor planning that is copy and pasted from one place to another. A lot of cities are realizing it's stupid and removing or relaxing these laws.
- hibikir 10y agoI'd be very surprised if shared self driving cars lead to a major reduction in excess parking, or lower the number of traffic jams. People want to do the same things at more or less the same time: Having time off while your social circle is at work is not as fun. Many jobs require customers, and others require entire groups of people to be there together. This means the minimum capacity needed to handle peaks is not going to be very far off from where we are right now. Think of your typical morning traffic: One side of the highway is in gridlock, while the other is doing well. In the evenings, the directions reverse. A lot of people want to be at the office at 8:00, so you need capacity for that. And what do the cars do now that it's 8:05 and they are downtown? Probably nothing, as there is no demand for that much capacity for most of the day. Same thing with a sporting event: People will get to the stadium to watch the 49ers, but Santa Clara doesn't have any use for 40K+ cars for 3 hours on sunday morning. The most you can do is have the cars do some otherwise useless miles to park in a cheaper area further away from the stadium. I'd love to be wrong on this, but this phenomenon would make it surprising if we got a double digit decrease in traffic with shared self driving cars.
- jedberg 10y agoThe traffic reduction will come from two sources -- fewer cars and the fact that the cars can drive at optimal speed, reducing unnecessary slowdowns. That being said, while some cars would need to be stationary, there are plenty of people moving around all day long.
- greggman 10y agoDo we know there will be fewer cars? Self Driving cars allow all non-drivers to use a car.
- FatalLogic 10y agoYes, that's so, although I think it's fair to assume that many non-drivers don't use a car because of the cost, not because they're unwilling to drive or incapable of driving. On the other hand, the cost of car ownership could be reduced with self driving cars.
- dclowd9901 10y agoIt floors me that businesses are allowed to keep their parking lots off limits during non business hours. That alone would go a long way to freeing up spaces.
- cardiffspaceman 10y agoA property owner that allows the public onto their property needs to have insurance against claims that members of the public were injured by the property owner. Such claims can arise out of accidents that happen in the normal course of walking. The claim process itself is expensive to use for settling claims, regardless of the outcome, therefore the insurance premiums are significant. It is cheaper therefore, to only admit into the parking lot the cars that belong to the customers of the property owner, because there will be less people who could press claims against the owner. When the owner's business is closed, it behooves the owner to enclose the parking lot to keep out people who aren't customers. I suggest that non-free parking that belongs to a parking company would be preferable, on the above reasoning. Plus fewer spaces would be needed since the company would have no reason to make you move your car if you wanted to patronize a second business. I patronize a bar where I have to find on-street parking most nights. It is across the street from a supermarket that has a mostly-empty parking lot. I understand why the bar patrons are not permitted to use the supermarket parking lot, and I believe it were best that that parking lot was instead a paid lot open to all drivers. I think about this as I walk to my car.
- jedberg 10y agoI've seen places where this situation exists, and the supermarket will charge some amount of money to park in the lot, but make it free if you shop in the market. Seems like a reasonable solution. The paid parking covers the extra insurance and maintenance. Maybe you should suggest it to the market across from your bar. :)
- dclowd9901 10y ago>I suggest that non-free parking that belongs to a parking company would be preferable I'd be totally fine with this. As is, the space just sits empty and wasteful.
- coldtea 10y ago>At first that seems crazy, but it makes sense if you think about the fact that all the places you go in a day need to have enough parking to meet their peak demand all year "Need to", because, god forbid if people: (a) take the public transit (or build a decent public transit in the first place), (b) park a little further down (e.g. half a mile or so), and walk to the place you want to go.
- mikecke 10y agoGod forbid that these are suburban areas where public transit effectively makes no sense for the loosely-packed population- you might as well be blowing away $ building parking spaces half a mile away. Places which (b) happen already have (a) and vice-versa.
- coldtea 10y ago>God forbid that these are suburban areas where public transit effectively makes no sense for the loosely-packed population God forbid people didn't create environmentally disastrous and socially ho-hum suburban sprawls...
- hackuser 10y ago> Another nice benefit of self driving cars that are shared is the major reduction in the need to all this excess parking. I would think that applied to any shared cars, including taxis and ride-hailing services. Why would the self-driving feature reduce parking demand beyond that?
- TheSmiddy 10y agoIt does, however self driving taxis can be operated far cheaper than human driver taxis. So if the cost of running your car is say $5000 a year and you can get an subscription robocar service for $100 a week then a large number of people will switch. At the moment it's only cheaper to go car free if it's possible for you to walk/ride/catch public transport to work Mon-Fri and catch the occasional taxi when needed.
- mantas 10y agoRobocar for $100 a week would be $5600 a year. So individual car would be still cheaper in such case... :) Unless you start factoring in time that you were away for vacation and didn't pay for that week etc. But that'd be some Adobe-level subscription madness...
- fulafel 10y agoAverage owned car cost is $725/month according to the AAA[1]. [1] http://exchange.aaa.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Your-Driving-Costs-2015.pdf http://exchange.aaa.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Your-Driv...
- mantas 10y agoJust pointed out a math flaw in parent post. It's obvious where both numbers were pulled from...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- return0 10y agoWe don't even need self-driving cars, we need connected cars