8 ms·
Pascal GPUs on All Fronts Push Nvidia to New Highs
- nl 10y agoYep. And AMD just doesn't care - literally: "For the most part, because—in the case of Nvidia—they don't appear to care that much about VR. And in the case of the dollars spent on R&D, they seem to be very happy doing stuff in the car industry, and long may that continue—good luck to them. We're spending our dollars in the areas we're focused on."[1] Everytime someone complains about how little OpenCL is used, I just think of that quote. I'm happy to use products from a company that cares about what I do. (And yes, good OpenCL implementations would be great too. But the world won't wait for AMD on this). [1] http://arstechnica.co.uk/gadgets/2016/04/amd-focusing-on-vr-mid-range-polaris/ http://arstechnica.co.uk/gadgets/2016/04/amd-focusing-on-vr-...
- shmerl 10y agoAMD cares to contribute to Mesa. Nvidia? Not really.
- lmm 10y agoNVidia have their own high-quality OpenGL implementation. Isn't that better?
- robert_foss 10y agoNo. It is strictly worse. NVidia not only has no interest in having a Mesa driver, but would prefer if they didn't have to compete with Mesa at all.
- cosarara97 10y agoBetter for whom? The nvidia driver doesn't have proper wayland support, can't work with gallium nine, can't be included in the kernel, and has issues with v-sync.
- shmerl 10y agoIndeed. While radeonsi continues to march forward, Nvidia doesn't rush to address the above. My next card is going to be Vega.
- emp_zealoth 10y agoYet AMD cards under linux are complete misery Driver support going away after a few years, random issues, etc Every single nVidia card I used under linux just worked TM (ofc I'm not "pure" because I really couldn't care less about open vs closed drivers)
- erichocean 10y ago> good OpenCL implementations would be great too Now that Vulkan is out, that's far less important than it used to be.
- shrewduser 10y agoi wasn't even aware vulkan obviated openCL...
- wlesieutre 10y agoI don't know a ton about the subject, but there's some coverage of it in this overview: https://www.khronos.org/assets/uploads/developers/library/overview/2015_vulkan_v1_Overview.pdf https://www.khronos.org/assets/uploads/developers/library/ov...
- shmerl 10y agoThey overlap to some degree. Vulkan allows access to compute queues of the GPU (in addition to graphics ones).
- pjmlp 10y agoOpenGL already does that via compute shaders and it hasn't helped.
- shmerl 10y agoHasn't helped what exactly? OpenGL can't provide proper parallelized access to all the queues, so having compute shaders there isn't that useful.
- pjmlp 10y agoTo gain adoption. NVidia doesn't care about OpenCL. Google doesn't care, and pushes Renderscript instead. Apple doesn't care, it created OpenCL, but since Khronos doesn't dance their music, they rather push Metal Compute Shaders. Microsoft has C++AMP and DX Compute. Additionally CUDA was designed to be targeted by multiple languages, while OpenCL had to wait for OpenCL 2.0 for it to happen. Also the graphical debuggers for OpenCL could get some love. I know which GPU makers I will keep giving my money to.
- rasz_pl 10y agoAMD management is dysfunctional (think late Commodore). They are perfectly ready to throw away $300m on a shot in the dark (seamicro) but are unwilling to hire actual developers to support their current hardware (gpu drivers still single threaded).
- whazor 10y agoThey invest into efficiency. So they will be second in VR. But provide more battery and therefore more game time.
- EugeneOZ 10y agoAnd you can use their VR device as a warm winter hat.
- peller 10y agoI won't argue with you over some of the things AMD has decided to prioritize, but for what it's worth, they are at least working on supporting CUDA compilation for their GPUs. http://www.anandtech.com/show/9792/amd-sc15-boltzmann-initiative-announced-c-and-cuda-compilers-for-amd-gpus http://www.anandtech.com/show/9792/amd-sc15-boltzmann-initia...
- bryanlarsen 10y agoAnd today AMD announced public availability of CUDA: http://www.anandtech.com/show/10831/amd-sc16-rocm-13-released-boltzmann-realized http://www.anandtech.com/show/10831/amd-sc16-rocm-13-release...
- Notre1 10y agoIt seems like their focus is more on the mainstream (~$200) cards than the high-end. They did get their chips in both the major consoles, so maybe that focus on squeezing costs out if the mid-range is working out.
- dogma1138 10y agoIf AMD cared about VR it would have implemented viewport multi casting which NVIDIA has supported since Kepler. VR performance on AMD card is abysmal, GTX 1060 beats a fury x once you count time warped and reprojected frames.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoIt's silly for AMD to say that nVidia doesn't care about VR. By the same token AMD obviously cares about HPC, even when they say they're "all in" on VR in some press release. They're both big companies that put lots of effort & money into many things simultaneously. Not to mention that today is the day that AMD announced public availability of CUDA for their platform. http://www.anandtech.com/show/10831/amd-sc16-rocm-13-released-boltzmann-realized http://www.anandtech.com/show/10831/amd-sc16-rocm-13-release...
- gcr 10y agoHPC? NVidia is completely destroying AMD on the deep learning front. The most popular deep learning frameworks use CUDA and do not have stable OpenCL support out of the box.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoAnd today AMD announced support for CUDA and hinted that they were deprecating OpenCL (by releasing OpenCL 1.2+ rather than concentrating on 2.0).
- gcp 10y agoWhat? AMD's drivers have had OpenCL 2.0 support for a long time. At least on Windows.
- gcp 10y agoThe most popular deep learning frameworks use CUDA and do not have stable OpenCL support out of the box. It's worse than that. The popular frameworks use cuDNN, which is a hand (assembler) optimized library for common operations. AMD does not have any equivalent. Even if you have OpenCL support you'll get nowhere the performance.
- gcr 10y agoMost libraries have fallbacks for cuDNN-less operation. Torch, for example, requires you to import a CUDNN library if you want to use it. Caffe requires you to uncomment a line in a makefile if you want to use it.
- 7TJx4UN4ro25 10y agoNote that the first graph is misleading - it does not provide the context the release of their previous architecture.
- arcanus 10y agoI like nextplatform and nvidia did just have a great quarter. Tensorflow runs best when accelerated by nvidia GPUs. However, the article vastly oversells nvidia in the HPC space. Intel's MIC platform is targeted at competing with GPUs, and cuda is a closed standard. Nvidia is by no means dominant in HPC, and has parts in only two machines in the top-10, and none that I'm aware of under contruction. Finaly, Exascale architecture is likely to be radically different than present tech. It could absolutely shake up the environment significantly.
- craigyk 10y agoI believe the DOD already has plans to bring online two new computers in the near future that will retake the crown. At least one of them with Nvidia with a big emphasis on P100 and nvlink.
- synacksynack 10y agoSummit and Sierra are two planned DOE machines with hardware developed in collaboration with IBM and Nvidia. They're slated to feature Volta GPU, a generation past P100's Pascal. More details here: https://www.olcf.ornl.gov/summit/ https://www.olcf.ornl.gov/summit/
- craigyk 10y agoOK, that's right, was working from memory. In any case, GPUs are making big inroads into HPC.
- mp3geek 10y agoDoes this show PC Gaming is booming as a result?
- eva1984 10y agoShows deep learning is the new king.
- tener 10y agoTheir graphs are showing a large growth in 2017 which are pure predictions. To makes matters worse they are not marked as such which is misleading.
- Maakuth 10y agoHow can anything concerning future be something else than pure prediction? Do you mean like already agreed orders with delivery dates in 2017?
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoThere are two wrinkles here: - "Fiscal 2017" may not be the calendar year, e.g. it could comprise April-2016 to March-2017. (I don't know the specifics here, but accounting is weird that way.) - There's booking, and "book-to-bill ratio" in the semiconductor industry. I.e. the pre-orders are recorded quite a bit in advance, but actual shipments (and payments) may vary.
- mcbits 10y agoRight, the graph goes up to Q3 of Nvidia's fiscal 2017, which just ended on October 30. So apparently the fiscal year will end sometime in January. http://nvidianews.nvidia.com/news/nvidia-announces-financial-results-for-third-quarter-fiscal-2017 http://nvidianews.nvidia.com/news/nvidia-announces-financial...
- EugeneOZ 10y agoFor me not obvious why they predict small failure in sales in Q1 2017, if 1080ti will be released in Q1 2017 - and by current information it will be awesome card for gaming.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tambourine_man 10y agoI thought we'd be able to write code in Pascal for the new Nvidia GPUs. I have found memories of the language.
- pjmlp 10y agoWell it is just a matter of getting FreePascal to output PTX. :)
- dharma1 10y agoTraining - I have a feeling it's going to be NVidia for a while. AMD just doesn't show interest in joining the party, and NVidia has been optimising CuDNN for a while now, it will take a bit of time to play catch up. I really don't understand what AMD have been doing the past 2 years here. Inference - NVidia will have a much harder time enforcing a monopoly here, because they are not, and cannot be the dominant player on all the hardware where neural networks will run after training. ARM, Qualcomm and others in mobile space will be pushing it hard, as will vendors running neural nets on FPGA/ASIC designs that are now emerging. Will be interesting to see what effect architectures using low precision or binary weights (for both training and inference) will have too on the hardware landscape. SPIR-V - AFAIK Codeplay (https://www.codeplay.com https://www.codeplay.com) are working on SPIR-V support for tensorflow, that should in theory help to use TF on various hardware that supports Vulkan/SPIR-V. But I guess each vendor will still need to tune things like convolution kernels for their specific hardware to squeeze the best perf out
- chronic6l 10y agoYou realize that deep learning is such a small market and will be small in the context of GPUs?
- dharma1 10y agocould have fooled me http://fortune.com/2016/11/10/nvidia-earnings-stock-machine-learning/ http://fortune.com/2016/11/10/nvidia-earnings-stock-machine-...
- muyuu 10y agoIn the article there's a comparison of earnings by usage. It remains comparatively small.
- dharma1 10y agoFor now. It's also hard to say, how much of the rise in their "gaming" earnings - is in fact driven by people buying GPUs for deep learning. Everyone I know who are doing deep learning have been buying Titan X's or GTX 1080's - their "gaming" cards. Not the datacentre or pro viz cards.
- diziet 10y agoIt looks like Nvidia's financial quarters are a couple of quarters ahead of calendar quarters.
- touristtam 10y ago> Just like Intel arguably does not need the Core PC chip business to justify the existence of a very large and profitable Xeon server chip business.