7 ms·
AT&T will lower the quality of most video to 480p starting next year
- samfisher83 10y agoCustomers can choose to disable it. Given data caps it might not be a bad thing to have it on. Whether you think they are good or bad tmobile has had a massive impact on the cellphone industry. They were the first to remove subsidies which all the carriers copied. Now the carriers are copying their throttling model.
- shostack 10y agoYes, it is good at helping with data caps that carriers imposed. So you pay them extra for more bandwidth at a ridiculous rate or pay them for the "privilege" of getting higher quality video like T-Mobile. They win through higher fees both ways and consumers are once again screwed through artificial constraints and lack of competition.
- gorbachev 10y agoIf AT&T wished to be consumer friendly, they'd implement this in an opt-in manner.
- errantspark 10y agoThis seems like something that's really easy to get mad about; but given it's optional nature and the fact that you're watching these videos on a tiny phone screen actually seems like almost universally a good thing.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shostack 10y agoIt is optional for now while they get things in place to follow T-Mobile and introduce a plan where this is the default and you have to pay more to unlock higher quality video. Then you remove plan with the free unlock option or just increase its price to make sure to instead ARPU to the desired level. Classic boiling of the frog and T-Mobile is a glimpse into the future of where at&t is going with this.
- shmerl 10y agoIt should be illegal. Same as unnecessary data caps.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- darkhorn 10y agoThis is another reason to use HTTPS.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoHTTPS doesn't mask the source IP block of the content. Pretty easy to throttle Youtube, Netflix, etc based on their CDN blocks.
- mdorazio 10y agoYup, this is more a reason to use a VPN.
- teaneedz 10y agothis.
- helthanatos 10y agoVPNs cost money. Until it is forced, there isn't much of a point in using a VPN (besides AT&T's wonderful spying track record). VPNs are great but until more are free, it's better to deal with switching a setting.
- mschuster91 10y ago> Until it is forced, there isn't much of a point in using a VPN Well, America just elected Trump to office, and here in Europe the situation doesn't look much better (crisis law in France, calls for more and more surveillance state across Europe, and right-wing populists/extremists gaining power in country by country). I'd say there has never been a better argument for VPN/Tor usage than right now.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoMs Clinton did not communicate any intentions of shutting down the NSA domestic surveillance apparatus, part of Obama's legacy (which she campaigned on).
- mikeash 10y agoThe HN title is missing two key words: "by default." You can turn it off. I'm not particularly happy with what they're doing, but there's a fairly big difference between forcing it on everyone and allowing people to opt-out.
- gcr 10y agoT-Mobile started the slippery slope and legitimazed the idea of limited video with their "Binge On" program. If you turn on "Binge On", you only get down-sampled, bandwidth-limited video. The trade-off was that they agreed not to charge you for watching downsampled video. They also let you turn this feature on or off, so there's an upside. But. There's a trick. T-mobile now offers a single plan, "T-Mobile ONE." All videos are downsampled by default and you can't disable that without paying extra. The customers' wallets have spoken.
- izacus 10y ago> The customers' wallets have spoken. Customer wallets are very silent in cases of natural monopoly like telecommunication services.
- woah 10y agoWhy are telecommunication services a natural monopoly?
- hiou 10y agoOwnership of the frequency bands. Maybe I was down voted because my comment was too brief. In the U.S. companies bid on and purchase wireless spectrum which they then own in perpetuity.
- jjoonathan 10y agoThe same reason as any other utility (gas, power, water). It's expensive to run so many redundant lines to your house (or cell towers, etc) as to make collusion between providers prohibitively difficult. Installed infrastructure serves as a moat; the minimum viable competing product requires a massive investment that can't be done one piece at a time, since your competitor will just undercut you wherever you start to roll out. On top of this you would have to deal with standard anticompetitive market forces like economies of scale and relative bargaining power. If you can't get a half decent price from your provider (on account of being small or on account of pressure exerted on the backbone provider by your competitor), you start at a disadvantage that might be impossible to make up. Investors can give you a jump start, but then you've got the problem of providing them a better return than the incumbent, which itself is pretty efficient at funneling money to its shareholders. Even if you don't trust the theoretical hand-waving, the fact that the market is the way it is should provide all the proof you need (see: Google Fiber). The "problem" with utility markets is so thoroughly established by precedent that Adam Smith himself used them in Wealth of Nations as an example of an economic sector where markets don't automagically "do the right thing." There are a number of policy approaches to solving the problem, some of which are more "hands on" than others, but it's not a problem that goes away on its own. It's still vulnerable to technological disruption though! Microwave/mm-wave internet service, which has tiny infrastructure requirements by comparison, might be our salvation if it can be made good enough. That's a difficult problem, but maybe not so difficult as trying to get ISPs regulated as utilities. Google is right to focus their efforts on it.
- ams6110 10y ago480p is as good as the best pre-HD analog TV, or standard DVDs, and better than VHS which everyone was happy to use back in the day. And certainly fine for most things on a screen as small as a mobile device. I don't really see what there is to complain about, especially as it's optional. I'd gladly trade higher bandwidth costs, pixelation, freezing and skipping HD video for smooth 480p for most things.
- fegu 10y agoI agree there are benefits as well. But regarding the quality, I have a 4K mobile screen (Sony Xperia Z5 Premium). For others, full HD is practically the norm for higher end phones now. 480p is noticeably worse in some applications, e.g. screencasting.
- tinus_hn 10y agoIt is not the job of the communications provider to decide what the users get to transmit. And they most certainly shouldn't be in the business of manipulating the users' communication which is what they are doing to change the video resolution. Anyway this whole discussion will soon be moot as everything moves to SSL and AT&T can only decide wether to transmit it completely or not at all. As they should.
- chipperyman573 10y agoOne typical solution to this is just to limit ALL bandwith to youtube.com, nflxvideo.net (Netflix's CDN), etc. Then, you rely on the app to intelligantly downgrade video quality for you. SSL won't solve this issue, only a VPN will.
- op00to 10y agoI can't wait for this feature. I know unlimited (reliable) mobile data is pretty much done for in the US, so anything that lets me economise is awesome. You can turn it off. This is a positive thing for me.
- chipperyman573 10y agoThis move seems pretty pro-consumer (even if ATT did it for their own benefit). Data caps on wireless transmission (not fiber to your house) are a technical requirement. There's only so much bandwith space, and it's being demanded more than ever before. So, carriers create incentives to use less data, including data caps/limits. If grandma wants to watch House of Cards on her phone, she might not realize that, for whatever reason (poor reception, the power cable fell out of the router, etc), her phone switched over to 4G. This will protect users like her from using up ALL her data at once.