2 ms·
> a possible problem is when the software gets better then humans ... And you get many people who all can be identified by the vitness, witch one do you prosecu
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> a possible problem is when the software gets better then humans ... And you get many people who all can be identified by the vitness, witch one do you prosecute ?
The non-rhetorical answer, according to how the system is supposed to work, is none of them. It's not possible for four independent actors to each have a 95% chance of being the perpetrator. If one has a 95% probability then the combined probability of all the others has to be <5%. And if the probability of the "most likely suspect" to have done it is e.g. 40%, that clearly isn't "beyond a reasonable doubt."
But this was all true even before computers. The system doesn't care about the math. A crime is committed, someone is to be punished, they put the most likely suspect in front of a jury and most of the time the jury will convict regardless.
In reality most of the time the accused will plead guilty to take a six month sentence over the 90+% chance of getting five years from a jury who doesn't understand (and is not given an opportunity to understand) how the probabilities actually work. And that incentive to plead guilty for a shorter sentence and lower legal bills is the same whether you're guilty or innocent.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoEffectively, taking away your right to a trial by a jury of your peers. Plea bargains are one of the many elements of our legal system that is completely antithetical to actual justice and the Bill of Rights.