19 ms·
Where Even Nightmares Are Classified: Psychiatric Care at Guantánamo
- kutkloon7 10y agoIt is just plainly hypocritical to have psychiatric care at Guantánamo. The single purpose of that institution is to destroy people on the inside and outside.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoIn that kind of environment, I imagine the psychiatrists could only make things worse.
- pavlov 10y agoReminds me of Peter Gabriel's 1982 song "Wallflower": "Loaded questions From clean white coats Their eyes are all as hidden As their Hippocratic Oaths" The song is painfully truthful still.
- fucking_tragedy 10y agoPsychologists were recruited in order to build the protocol for breaking a person. Not safety protocols or whatnot, but they used their knowledge to permanently render people insane. It isn't a stretch to assume psychotropic drugs were used to torture the prisoners as well. https://www.rt.com/usa/318581-lawsuit-cia-torture-psychologist/ https://www.rt.com/usa/318581-lawsuit-cia-torture-psychologi...
- maxerickson 10y agoThey don't care if you think they are hypocrites, they are believers in their own righteousness. I wonder, do people broadly take away this message from Serenity? Not the slick-talkin space cowboys are cool message, the message about believing. The theme is repeated in the movie, but it's directly delivered by Shepherd Book. He labels the government antagonist as a believer. He literally says to Mal I don't care what you believe in, just believe in it. In the end, the only thing that stops the believer is having his entire world torn down. But yeah, it's pretty hypocritical.
- jsight 10y agoI took a completely different message from Serenity. Shepherd new what Mal believed in and was encouraging him to stand for it. Up until that point in the film, he had behaved as if he were just a leaf on the wind. I'm not sure that Shepherd's advice would have been the same had Mal believed differently.
- maxerickson 10y agoThat is kind of what I mean with believer, someone who is driven by their beliefs (rather than drifting or whatever).
- bitJericho 10y agoThe staff and all involved are traitors to the human race. I hope they're charged as war criminals some day.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoUnfortunately, it might be a decade before that would even be possible again.
- bitJericho 10y agoWe can only hope that he'll be impeached for his raping/sexual assaulting.
- moyta 10y agoImpeaching that rapey rapscallion with our House & Senate? Doubtful. I don't foresee either changing, the Democrats are not likely to have better turnout 2 or 6 years from now, so the mid-terms are likely both losers that will give Trump a stronger House & Senate.
- woofyman 10y agoI predict a huge Democratic turnout in 2018. I don't think Trump will run for reelection in 2020.
- jsight 10y agoI predict that Trump will actually be very popular and win 2020 in a landslide. The things that Trump campaigned on aren't necessarily the things that he actually needs to do to be successful.
- moyta 10y agoGood luck with that, I don't see Democrats surging in 2018, or retaking much ground locally in the interim. At the local level, the Democratic party is dead. The party needs to have a few dozen people volunteering in each district, so that we can actually have decent momentum to retake each state house & senate. Without that, the Democrats are sunk.
- hajile 10y agoUltimately, a person cannot control what other people do, but that person can control what decisions they make. After WW2, we decided that "following orders" is no excuse for war crimes (Nuremberg principle IV). To me, the situation seems eerily reminiscent of the doctor in V for Vendetta. Delia Surridge: [Curtains are drawn back, allowing moonlight to come in] It's you, isn't it? You've come to kill me? V: Yes. Delia Surridge: Thank God. Delia Surridge: After what happened. After what they did. I thought about killing myself. I knew that one day you'd come for me. I didn't know what they were going to do. I swear to you. Read my journal. V: What they did was only possible because of you. Delia Surridge: Oppenheimer was able to change more than a course of a war. It changed the entire course of human history. Is it wrong to hold on to that kind of hope? V: I've not come for what you've hoped to do. I've come for what you did. Delia Surridge: It's funny. I was given one of your roses today. I wasn't sure you were the terrorist until I saw it. What a strange coincidence that I should be given one today. V: There are no coincidences, Delia. Only the illusion of coincidences.
- Kenji 10y agoRemember when Obama promised to close the Guantánamo prison? I think that was more than 8 years ago now. Good times. I even believed it. I guess he didn't care that much about human rights after all.
- pavlov 10y agoRead this: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/08/01/why-obama-has-failed-to-close-guantanamo http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/08/01/why-obama-has-f... Yes, it's very long. It turned out to be much harder to close Guantánamo Bay than Obama thought, with powerful forces in the government opposing or stalling. (It's also illustrative of the difficulties Trump may have carrying through any of his promises that are controversial with the Republican orthodoxy.)
- cloakandswagger 10y agoWhether it was feasible for Obama to close it or not, it's hard to deny that there was a fundamental shift in Obama's ideology once he took office (see: extra-judicial assassinations, abandoning Guantanamo closure, etc) I suspect that there are some pretty powerful briefings a new president receives that draw back the veil in such a way that targeted killings and torture seem like the only effective response.
- xorxornop 10y agoThat or the surveillance apparatus was used in a way so as to ensure that he toed the line...
- pavlov 10y agoThere was an interesting article in the Washington Post today about these covert-op and nuclear briefings for the president-elect: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/president-elect-donald-trump-is-about-to-learn-the-nations-deep-secrets/2016/11/12/8bf9bc40-a847-11e6-8fc0-7be8f848c492_story.html?hpid=hp_hp-top-table-main_trumpsecret-430pm%3Ahomepage%2Fstory https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/presi... Some quotes that kind of confirm what you inferred about Obama: After one of the briefings in 2008, Obama told a close adviser that it was perhaps one of the most sobering experiences of his life. He said, “I’m inheriting a world that could blow up any minute in half a dozen ways, and I will have some powerful but limited and perhaps even dubious tools to keep it from happening.” “Events are messy out there,” he said. “At any given moment of the day, there are explosive, tragic, heinous, hazardous things taking place.” He acknowledged that as president it was his responsibility to deal with all these problems. “People are saying, ‘You’re the most powerful person in the world. Why aren’t you doing something about it?’ ” The following made my hair raise a bit: Trump will receive a book of options benignly called the “Presidential Decision Handbook.” This top secret/code-word book, known as the “Black Book,” of about 75 pages has separate contingency plans for using nuclear weapons against potential adversaries such as Russia and China. ... Two officials said that the “Black Book” also includes estimates on the number of casualties for each of the main options that run into the millions, and in some cases over 100 million. A man who habitually gets into 3am Twitter fights will command choices that can result in the near-instant death of 100+ million people. That's way more than Hitler, Stalin and Mao managed to kill all together. It's a strange world.
- wruza 10y ago>Even interviewing prisoners to assess their mental health set off recriminations and claims that she was torturing them. “What would your Jesus think?” they demanded. Oh, so you didn't expect symmetric suffering, right?
- UhUhUhUh 10y agoThe "we didn't know" bit is eerily familiar and I will not expand. The other thing that came to mind was the 1971 Stanford Experiment (Zimbardo). It is ironical that this experiment would not be able to take place today, out of "ethical" considerations but that its real-life version is publicly funded and tacitly approved. All this is extremely frightening...
- maxerickson 10y agoI think people still don't really know. Forced sterilization was routine in parts of the US up until the 1970s (and widespread prior to WWII). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_sterilization#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_sterilization#Unite...
- dom0 10y agoInterestingly the story of A. Turing usually ends with WWII, and doesn't go on to tell that the state he did so much for forcedly sterilized him, driving him into suicide.
- rz2k 10y agoI get the vague impression that there was some sort of unspoken deal not to prosecute the people who ordered torture and the people who followed those unlawful orders for the sake of reconciliation between sides of culture wars. How could we have prosecuted the torturers but not the people giving the orders? Or, how could we prosecute the former vice president, but not the former commander in chief? Even though we are part of treaties that promise we will not torture, practical politics seems to be more powerful than the rule of law, and there would have had to be a much more overwhelming mandate. Instead, it seems like we have forgiven people for commandeering the power we gave them for unlawful uses from one perspective[1], but the other perspective is that they did not do something wrong. Based on the rhetoric of this campaign it seems like timidity, instead of leading to some sort of reconciliation, has lead to the normalization of torture. Now even low caliber network television shows such as 24 and Madame Secretary have protagonists casually carrying out or ordering torture without the implicit condemnation that would have been written into the plot 20 years ago. [1] Forgiving the breach of trust for misusing power you gave someone is of course different than the type of forgiveness actual victims could grant.
- pmoriarty 10y agoTrump has said that "torture works", and "I like waterboarding a lot", and that he would "bring back a hell of a lot worse than waterboarding". When asked about former CIA Director Michael Hayden’s recent comments that the military could defy unlawful orders to torture or kill civilians, Trump said, "They won’t refuse. They’re not going to refuse, believe me." Thanks 50% of American voters. You're helping to make the world an even worse shithole than it already is. Trump couldn't have done it without you.
- lambertsimnel 10y agoNo presidential candidate got ≥50% of the vote. Clinton got the most votes, but still less than half. And that's just out of votes cast. Clinton got the backing of barely 27% of eligible voters and Trump got even less.
- Chris2048 10y agoComment said "of American voters". If you don't vote, you lose it, so why mention this?
- lambertsimnel 10y agoTo me "voters" seems as likely to mean "those eligible to vote" as not. I agree that the proportion of votes cast is more relevant.
- benchaney 10y agoEven if you include only votes cast, both Clinton and Trump got < 50% of votes.
- vacri 10y agoOh, then if Trump only got 47% of the vote, the OP's point is irrelevant? Phew.
- jsight 10y ago
- 75j 10y agoOne of the most disturbing stories that I don't hear mentioned is of Sean Baker, who was working undercover for the USAF as part of an attempt to gauge the abuses at Guantanamo. Baker was beaten by the guards so badly that he got a serious brain injury. "In January 2003, Baker was ordered by an officer at Guantanamo to play the role of a prisoner in a training drill. [...] The soldiers in the reaction force were operating under the impression that he was a genuine detainee that had assaulted a sergeant. [...] Although Baker shouted out the safeword ("red") he had been given to stop the exercise and stated that he was a U.S. soldier, the soldier continued beating Baker's head against the floor and choking him. Only after he ripped his prison jumpsuit in the struggle, revealing that he was wearing a battle dress uniform and government-issue boots underneath, did the beating stop." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sean_Baker_(soldier) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sean_Baker_(soldier)
- johnchristopher 10y agoHow were the soldiers of the reaction force supposed to know the safe word? The article doesn't mention anything about working under cover to gauge guantanomo abuses. It says it was a drill exercise for handling uncooperative prisoners.
- 75j 10y agoOi... wrong about that it looks like. I could swear I read something a long time ago about this that said it was at least part of an internal investigation, but maybe not. He was a veteran of the USAF and a military policemen at the time, and one of the higher officers asked him to do the drill apparently.
- proksoup 10y agoSeems pretty cruel to me. Would be nice if we had some sort of standards or guidelines or laws against this sort of treatment of prisoners. Would one need a safe word at all if we did?