3 ms·
This is eating up our data and inconveniencing millions of people using your products. The data issue can be addressed by only having videos play automatically
by onion2k 10y ago
This is eating up our data and inconveniencing millions of people using your products.
The data issue can be addressed by only having videos play automatically when the user is on a wifi connection. This is the default for mobile devices already, so it's arguably already solved for most users.
The "convenience" issue is something that I strongly suspect is actually something that people think one way but act another - lots of users claim to hate auto-playing videos but then they watch them a lot. Facebook's video engagement statistics are hard to argue with - a well designed video that works without sound (eg something from Buzzfeed) gets a tremendous number of shares, likes and click through engagements.
I strongly suspect that turning off auto-playing video, even by default, would actually make the web worse for the majority of people. For those who prefer them not to autoplay, browser vendors do provide that, but the functionality is usually buried in the equivalent of chrome://flags somewhere.
- frankzinger 10y agoThe data issue can be addressed by only having videos play automatically when the user is on a wifi connection. This is the default for mobile devices already, so it's arguably already solved for most users. Not all WiFi connections equate to an infinite amount of data. Due to circumstances I am on a connection for which I pay per GB and it's shared through a WiFi router. I do not want my browser to download videos unless I asked it to.
- egeozcan 10y agoI have a 3G Mobile Wireless Modem/Router (TP-Link M5250[1], heavily recommended btw) and this "if wireless connection present, download all the things" attitude really annoys me. Android is a big offender. Why on earth I don't get a "download updates automatically only on this particular network" setting... Whatsapp, Google Maps and many other apps too make the same false assumption. [1]: http://www.tp-link.com/en/products/details/cat-4692_M5250.html http://www.tp-link.com/en/products/details/cat-4692_M5250.ht...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- metasean 10y agoGoogle Chrome is another auto-update offender. Inevitably it updates while I'm tethered to my phone (which has a small data allowance).
- kpozin 10y agoYou can configure Android to treat any specific WiFi network as metered, so apps that care will treat it the same as a mobile network. Look in Settings > Data usage > Wi-Fi > Network restrictions (might be in an overflow menu).
- onion2k 10y agoThat's why I said most users. There are a small number of people to whom wifi doesn't mean unlimited data. I don't think browsers defaults should be be designed with those people in mind though - the default settings should be to provide the best experience for the maximum number of people. Anyone who is outside the norm for whatever reason should be able to exert control over their browser, so obviously you should have the option to block videos autoplaying, or downloading at all, in the browser settings. Whether that should be in the settings page or a flags page is what browser vendors should be thinking hard about. Arguably this is a behaviour that enough people want to control that it should be in the settings page.
- Tepix 10y agoIt's still an issue if you use a mobile wifi hotspot to go online and have limited bandwidth (like most of Japan for example).
- chunkiestbacon 10y agoI live in Japan, and while mobile hotspots are popular for airbnbs and tourists, I don't think most people have them here. Also, there are mobile hotspots with unlimited data. The rest of the country has unlimited fiber at home, so it's especially those people that want their youtube and facebook videos to autoplay. I see the point tough. It's bad on a limited wifi hotspot
- eru 10y agoA bit off-topic: Japan is weird. We could get data-sims as tourists, but I don't think we would have been able to make calls?
- chunkiestbacon 10y agoFinally somebody reasonable in this thread. Most people might want this behaviour.
- imh 10y agoIf you yell at me, I'll pay attention, but I'd still rather you didn't. The argument that we watch them more is the same thing. Bright, shiny, loud, moving things will draw my attention and increase my engagement, but I'd prefer to avoid things that manipulate my attention in certain ways. Video and audio are where I personally draw the line, and from this thread, it seems that others do too.
- mercer 10y ago> This is the default for mobile devices already, so it's arguably already solved for most users. Unfortunately it's relatively easy to circumvent this. I recently implemented an auto-play background video using a canvas element to which I'd render the frames from a video. Sound can't be played, but you could still end up downloading megabytes worth of video without taking any action.
- gravypod 10y agoWifi connection does not mean a good ISP is backing it. I'd hate to be some poor guy in Australia and end up using some of my precious bandwidth.