3 ms·
You’re right that “There is no difference between Time and any of the three dimensions of Space [...]” is kind of misleading, but it’s only half wrong. The spe
by jacobolus 10y ago
You’re right that “There is no difference between Time and any of the three dimensions of Space [...]” is kind of misleading, but it’s only half wrong.
The special relativity story is more nuanced. There’s no single “time direction”. Which direction in spacetime looks like “time” vs. a mix of “space” and “time” movements vs. “space” depends on your reference frame.
Every “faster-than-light velocity vector” can be considered the direction of “time” for some observer, just as every “slower-than-light velocity vector” can be considered a direction in “space” for some observer. A vector like “the vector difference between the position of the earth now and the moon half a second in the future” (by our measurement) is, for some other reference frame, a pure movement in time. In just the same way, “the vector difference between the position of the earth now and the moon two seconds in the future” is a pure distance in space indicating simultaneous-in-time events, for some other reference frame.
Or perhaps we should even say that the “reference frames” and a split between space and time dimensions are an abstract concept that we impose on top of the 4-dimensional spacetime. We can work out all of our physics in a 4-dimensional context without explicitly splitting “space” from “time”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spacetime_algebra#Spacetime_split https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spacetime_algebra#Spacetime_sp...
In just the same way, if you have a two-dimensional Euclidean plane with no externally imposed markers on it, there’s no inherent notion of “up” or “left” – those depend entirely on what kind of reference you pick. Imposing some specific coordinates is sometimes useful for understanding the geometry and solving particular problems, but itÍ’s in some ways arbitrary.
- charlieflowers 10y agoReminds me of the final book in the Hitchhiker's Guide "trilogy". The advanced version of the Guide is calibrating itself so it can perform "reverse temporal engineering" on behalf of Ford. It asks a series of questions, one of which makes no sense, and then says something like, "Oh, time travels in that direction for you."