6 ms·
> or rather facilitating illegal actions. This is a very disingenuous statement, because it is illegal only because it's made illegal to kill the service model
by smsm42 10y ago
> or rather facilitating illegal actions.
This is a very disingenuous statement, because it is illegal only because it's made illegal to kill the service model they are using. It's like GM sponsoring a law banning Toyotas and then saying - well, look at those criminals - they are making illegal stuff! How shameful of them! No, it's shameful to use the law as a club to bash competition and prevent innovation instead of what it was meant to - to protect people from harm.
> Losing crazy amounts of VC cash to compete against traditional companies that must be cashflow positive.
So borrowing money from investors to compete with somebody is now a despicable thing, maybe even a crime?
> It's not a level playing field.
Sure it is. Level playing field does not mean everybody has the same sum of money.
> Uber is devaluing the medallions they've invested in.
The value of medallions was created by artificially choking the market until what was supposed to be simple permit issue to open a business now is a million-dollar investment way out of the reach of a common person. On the way creating a severe shortage in services and severe price distortions, since drivers now have to cover the costs of there million-dollar medallions.
> Is this really how we want the world to see us?
As people trying new things instead of just doing what always been done and letting incumbent interests tell us they are there for our own good and don't dare to question them? Sure thing!
- haldean 10y agoUnlike in your metaphor, though, both Uber and AirBnB were breaking the law at the time they were founded; those laws were not written in response to them, but to prevent things like them from cropping up.
- smsm42 10y agoIt doesn't matter. If GM sponsored a law that won't specifically target Toyota but all cars competing with GM cars, not naming Toyota by name - the argument "it's illegal" would be as disingenuous. It's subverting the meaning of the word to make it serve special interest. We think illegal things are bad, because we assume there are just laws that ban bad things from happening. So if we make a law banning somebody from competing with us, they'd be "illegal" and thus bad. But it's easy to see through this - sometimes "illegal" means just "bad law" and not "bad thing". US has a history of many extremely bad laws, I won't list them because I am sure you can name them by yourself, and even more laws that aren't as bad as those but merely self-serving and protecting some special interest. Laws against Uber and Airbnb usually are of this kind.
- thrownblown 10y agoThe usa already have a 500% tarrif on Chinese steel. I dont think were gonna get rid of that in the next 4 years.
- ethbro 10y ago> So if we make a law banning somebody from competing with us, they'd be "illegal" and thus bad. You're still missing (or strawmanning) the order of the events parent is referring to. An analogy would be closer to the US deciding headlights were a required safety feature. Then at some point after that Chrysler realizes they can duct tape glow sticks to the bonnet and cut costs. Doing so is illegal, they knew it would be illegal, and they still chose to make it their business model. Whether the laws being broken serve a societal purpose is another question, but one that can't be hand waived away by saying "Some laws are bad. AirBnB has legal troubles. Therefore the laws AirBnB is breaking are bad."
- marssaxman 10y agoIn this case Chrysler is using shiny new high-tech glowsticks of a sort that nobody had imagined when the laws were written, and they actually do a better job than the legally-mandated electric headlights. Forcing the law to change and catch up with the times can therefore be seen as an important public service.
- ethbro 10y agoIt's possible that glowsticks are a better solution to the problem and that the laws should change. After all, glowsticks weren't a technological possibility when it was written. I think the exasperation I (and others) seem to have with AirBnB/Uber/their supporters' sometimes-arguments are that they skip right over the "changing the law" piece. That's a pain in the ass and a lot of drudgery to be sure. But personally, I prefer to live in a society with a moderate amount of respect for the rule of all laws. Because the alternative of getting into a front-on collision at night with an unlit car sucks.
- soufron 10y ago
- nilved 10y agoYeah, those are the laws that shouldn't exist.
- newjersey 10y ago> Yeah, those are the laws that shouldn't exist. I absolutely agree. I'm no fan of Uber or Airbnb but I still side with them on a lot of issues (except Uber or airbnb requiring you to accept any and every customer in the name of anti discrimination). I reject the idea that traditional taxis are safer than Uber. I reject the idea that Airbnb makes our communities less secure. My understanding of Airbnb is bringing someone to share my house where they have their own room but I'm still in the building. YMMV when it comes to most Airbnb use cases where the host is in a different state and uses Airbnb full time. The reason I support these companies even though I don't like them is that I feel helpless against the regulatory capture. Taxi service doesn't exist to promote employment of taxi drivers. I think the medallion holders should ask TLC for their money back they paid for their medallions. Screw this whole charade about employment. If the only way to fight against regulatory capture is big companies breaking laws, I fully support big companies breaking those stupid laws. If I were in a jury about any such case, I'd likely vote to acquit.
- sethrin 10y agoI recommend going to Panama City, Panama, and finding out what life is like when those laws don't exist. Traffic is miserable, most taxis are in extremely poor repair, the taxi drivers are making next to nothing, and half the time they will either not pick you up if you want to go across town, and/or overcharge you because you don't sound like a local. One of the bigger reasons for medallions is congestion control. For-hire private transportation provides a financial incentive to have more cars on the road. This system will only begin to self-correct after the point of gridlock (assuming that taxis lose money while in gridlock), or not at all (if they get paid to sit in traffic). If that sounds like a future you want, you can go down to Panama and enjoy it any time. If it's all the same to you though I'd prefer not to import third-world living conditions.
- haldean 10y agoThen convince people that they shouldn't. Laws aren't written in a vacuum, so clearly other members of your community disagree with you; the right way to approach that is to engage with those who disagree and convince them you're right, not to flagrantly violate the rules.
- geofft 10y agoEnsuring that the housing stock of a city serves residents over visitors is protecting people from harm. The analogy in your case would be GM sponsoring a law that says that if you want to build cars, you have to e.g. include seatbelts or not pump carbon monoxide into the air. That is a perfectly good law for GM to be sponsoring, even if it does inhibit competition.
- smsm42 10y agoIt doesn't serve residents. It serves hotel lobby. They don't even hide it too much: http://reason.com/blog/2016/10/31/hotel-workers-union-gave-100k-to-managem http://reason.com/blog/2016/10/31/hotel-workers-union-gave-1... http://reason.com/blog/2016/11/04/hotel-exec-celebrates-new-york-airbnb-re http://reason.com/blog/2016/11/04/hotel-exec-celebrates-new-... It's not about safety or interests of anybody else, it's about who the money goes to.
- geofft 10y agoWhy are these mutually exclusive? (Can we use Airbnb celebrating the other side as evidence that Airbnb's preferred laws don't serve visitors, they serve the VC lobby?)
- smsm42 10y agoIf aribnb reps would say something like "we're glad this law got passed, now we can charge more and not be afraid of competition" then yes. But I don't remember Airbnb sponsoring any exclusionary laws, it's the hotel lobby that does. And they don't even bother to put a transparent screen of saying "great day for safety!", they just plain go out and say "great day for us charging more!".
- chimeracoder 10y ago> This is a very disingenuous statement, because it is illegal only because it's made illegal to kill the service model they are using. On the contrary - Uber likes to say that it's fighting against the unjust laws in London that require drivers to take an obsolete test of all roads in the city. In reality, they would have been exempt from that law as long as they provided fixed price quotes in advance. (Uber provides "estimates", but not fixed quotes). They actively chose to structure their business model this way because providing estimates instead of fixed quotes allows for better customer acquisition, and they'd rather compete against medallion cars because it's an easier market to undercut if you have the VC cash to spend tens of millions in lobbying and lawyer fees just in that one city (as they have).
- jpatokal 10y agoBut why legislate such an absurd distinction? Why not let consumers choose whether they want fixed fares or taxi-style pricing? London minicabs are terrible compared to Uber (unreliable, unavailable, no QA), while black cabs are absurdly overpriced. There's an obvious gap in the middle which is caused by protectionist legislation.
- kinkdr 10y ago> So borrowing money from investors to compete with somebody is now a despicable thing, maybe even a crime? Running at financial loss just to drive prices down so you can kill competition is at least unethical in my book. Also I believe it is illegal, for good reasons, in some countries.
- drieddust 10y agoAgreed and I think this should be handled under anti dumping Law anyways? It's idiotic to allow these unicorns to destroy existing businesses only to screw customers later on. They are not moving the world forward in any manner. It is just a power grab. At best we will end up replacing many small businesses with behemoths with a virtually limitless lobbying powers.
- shimon_e 10y agoFrom the sounds of it a Trump Presidency would be for removing red tape that effects Airbnb but against the dumping practices that Uber does. There are a lot of talk that Trump is going to break up some of the Silicon Valley companies up. Especially the ones who don't care about American jobs.
- drieddust 10y agoYes I actually watched [1] this and seems like Trump's view aren't formed now just to cash on the sentiments. He is talking these ideas for a long time. So let's hope he keep his insane side in check and does something good. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OCabT_O0YSM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OCabT_O0YSM
- smt88 10y agoNo one knows what Trump will do until he does it. Even his long-held beliefs are unreliable, because he is beholden to the mainstream Republicans and religious right that got him elected.
- 10y ago
- amykyta 10y ago>> Losing crazy amounts of VC cash to compete against traditional companies that must be cashflow positive. > So borrowing money from investors to compete with somebody is now a despicable thing, maybe even a crime? That's considered economic dumping and is likely a net negative in the end. They ruin the competition by operating at a loss and then collect rent when they are the only ones left.
- xapata 10y agoDoes that work for airlines? Let Uber give it a try. They are unlikely to gain a monopoly.
- drieddust 10y ago> This is a very disingenuous statement, because it is illegal only because it's made illegal to kill the service model they are using. Business models which are based on undercutting the competition by ignoring the regulation concerned with safety of end user.
- shados 10y agoWhen someone buys a condo in my building like in many, many (most?) such buildings, they agree to bylaws saying they will only ever rent their units out for a minimum of 6 months at a time. It's meant to avoid overuse of some shared facilities (loading dock, etc), having to reexplain the rules we all agreed on every other day, improve the sense of community, and all around make it nice for everyone to enjoy their apartment and live with each other. If they go out and airbnb their unit out, it's not the hotel industry they're hurting. It's their neighbors, community, and they're breaching rules they specifically agreed to.
- Mz 10y ago> or rather facilitating illegal actions. This is a very disingenuous statement, because it is illegal only because it's made illegal to kill the service model they are using. It's like GM sponsoring a law banning Toyotas and then saying - well, look at those criminals - they are making illegal stuff! How shameful of them! No, it's shameful to use the law as a club to bash competition and prevent innovation instead of what it was meant to - to protect people from harm. Yeah, no. Various jurisdictions may be tightening up laws, and the original intent of AirBnB may not have been anything illegal, but the way it has developed it does promote activities that were never legal to begin with in most jurisdictions. And renting your home out via AirBnB can void your homeowner's insurance because it is commercial use of a residential property. Many people do not realize this and do not notify their insurance company and only find it out if an AirBnB tenant damages something, they try to file a claim and get told "You aren't covered for that and, now, you aren't covered at all." I have not paid real close attention, but my understanding is that this started as more like a paid form of couch surfing or a means to find a short term roommate and then someone eventually asked "Can I just list my entire property for rent, rather than just a portion of it?" and now that format is most of their listings. So, as I understand it, they kind of slippery sloped their way into their current model. But their current model is basically illegal in most jurisdictions and always has been. Some jurisdictions may be tightening up laws to make it easier to combat and perhaps that is the wrong way to handle this because it fosters misconceptions of the type you have. But residential property was never meant to be treated like a hotel and the fact that the internet makes it possible to do so in ways that were never before possible does not change the fact that rules concerning residential property is intentionally different from rules for commercial property and always have been. I generally try to stay out of discussions about AirBnB. I don't think the founders are nefarious people who intentionally tried to do anything bad. I think this very much was a case of slippery slope. Like a lot of slippery slopes, it started out as not necessarily a bad thing but has gradually turned into something seriously problematic. As they say: The devil is in the details. Law is very often all about insidious details. When the people who run AirBnB agreed to something that was not part of their original vision and then that happened to work to rake in the dough, well, they are responsible for what they agreed to without apparently really thinking it through carefully enough. I get the appeal of that, but it doesn't make it right that they were just trying to make money and not intentionally trying to fuck up entire cities. I am totally fine with the existing war on AirBnB. Rather than acting all surprised and like cities are being unreasonable, maybe they should rethink their business model and stop behaving like Theranos and basically demanding that the world rise up and drag them out of there kicking and screaming because the allure of the all important goddamn dollar is too fucking strong for them to care about what their business model does to the fabric of entire cities. "Not their problem -- LA LA LA NOT LISTENING" all the way to the bank.
- soufron 10y agoWell Law is meant to bash competition and prevent innovation when it's dangerous to the community. It's the voice of the People against individuals or companies that will pursue their own interests.
- kafkaesq 10y agoSo borrowing money from investors to compete with somebody is now a despicable thing To compete "in all cases", no. To compete against mom and pops -- that's a different matter altogether. maybe even a crime? That's not what the commenter was saying.
- smsm42 10y agoHotel business is not exactly "mom and pops" - at least not the majority of it. Neither is a taxi one when medallion is valued in hundreds of thousands of dollars. Moms and pops then are no more than hired labor for holder corporations. And deregulating it so they maybe can become owners instead would be great, but that's not happening. Uber is going around it because going directly against the medallion laws is not possible.
- kafkaesq 10y agoI was just attempting to clarify that the situation is more complex than simply "pro-" or "anti-competition". For example, medallion-based taxi services are both, simultaneously, soulless megacorps and franchises of (within a given association) many thousands of de-facto "mom and pops". If you have any doubts about this, ask a medallion holder how they go into the business (which I've done a fair amount of in various cities, in the past couple of years since Uber/Lyft got big). In effect a "medallion" is a lot like a permit to park your food truck in a certain place, or a lease on a corner store. And a lot of these people either invest their life savings (or sometimes the life savings of extended family members), and/or go very seriously into debt in order to purchase one of these "permits". And whose nest eggs Uber et al would very much like to "disrupt", at massive scale (literally in all corners of the globe) in order to validate their Weltanschaung (and of course, get stinking rich). Yes I know these services also bring (significantly) greater efficiency and experience, and perhaps better working conditions and financial security -- for some current medallion holders. But it would be naive to suppose that all of them stand to benefit; most likely there will be many losers as well -- by which I mean: bankrupted, in middle age, with a laughable pension and no savings -- before the dust settles.