4 ms·
There was a very good link submitted to an NPR article that simply took Trump's published list of things he says he is going to do in the first 100 days, and an
by tzs 10y ago
There was a very good link submitted to an NPR article that simply took Trump's published list of things he says he is going to do in the first 100 days, and annotated the items with a short look at what it would take to accomplish them.
It did not advocate for or against the various items. It just looked objectively at whether they could be accomplished. There was nothing partisan or inflammatory in the article.
It was [flagged] and [dead] within minutes.
If a simple, nonpartisan, neutral analysis like that cannot make it here, no way is anything even remotely near political activism going to fly.
- grzm 10y agoA lot of people on the site are tired of the political discussion on the site, especially given what such discussions have looked like recently, and that political discussions are not generally in line with the site guidelines. I suspect a lot of submissions are getting flagged as a result, sometimes regardless of the tone of the article.
- detaro 10y agoA discussion of that article would have been quite likely mostly a duplicate of the discussion on the 100 day plan itself, because it only supplies additional arguments for the existing discussion. So it might be better to just quote it in comments.
- tptacek 10y agoCareful. It's not the stories themselves that are or aren't suitable for HN. It's the topic and (to a lesser extent) the mode of inquiry†. Political stories are flagged from HN not because they don't admit to intellectual inquiry (such as it is around here), but because this community won't react to them in that spirit. Good political stories, bad political stories: all of them generate unbelievably noxious threads. You're right of course. But, since this is a nerd message board, I feel entitled to point out at tedious length that you're right for the wrong reason. :) † In very rare cases, you can see academic studies of politics get some traction here.