3 ms·
If you look just at the shield of deterrence that the U.S. has held over western Europe, it has allowed the growth of both social democracy and of the common ma
by snowwrestler 10y ago
If you look just at the shield of deterrence that the U.S. has held over western Europe, it has allowed the growth of both social democracy and of the common market there. European nations all spend a much lower percentage of their budgets on defense than the U.S. does. While their citizens take that as a sign of cultural superiority, their leaders know that it is made possible by NATO and the outsized role that the U.S. has played in it for decades. Every one of those nations is looking at Russia right now and wondering "what happens next."
Same thing on the other side of the planet: both Japan and South Korea have very little military might; they depend on the deterrence the U.S. provides. They are looking at China and wondering what happens next.
If the U.S. reduces or removes these relationships, it will dramatically change these nations. Japan and China hate each other. If the U.S. draws back, Japan will complete its transition away from pacifism and will have nuclear weapons of its own in less than a decade. Same with South Korea.
Even if you think that the U.S. is not a leading light of democracy, these are real relationships and altering them has real consequences: more weapons and more tension among more nations in the world.
- greedo 10y agoCompletely inaccurate in terms of South Korean military power. S. Korea has a large, well trained and well equipped military with almost 7000 armored vehicles, thousands of artillery systems, a robust air force, and a navy perfectly suited for their requirements. It's even arguable that they could adequately defend themselves against North Korea without US help, as long as China doesn't intervene.
- tormeh 10y agoYeah, S Korea is the Israel of SEA.
- AcerbicZero 10y agoI believe the point made above was in regards to China. SK's ~1500ish MBT's and ~200ish Gen4 aircraft isn't so "well equipped" or "robust" when put up against the PLA and PLAAF.
- greedo 10y agoChina roughly outmatches SK by 4:1 across the board, but China has to worry about more than just SK. They have to be concerned about India, Vietnam, Russia, Japan, SK, and of course the US. China has been on an incredible spending spree and upgraded a lot of their equipment, but there not as well trained as other modern militaries. This is changing, but not something that can be done overnight.
- snowwrestler 10y agoIf the U.S. withdraws into itself, that will dramatically accelerate all of this. China knows it can't beat the U.S. in a shooting war, but it also knows the U.S.'s #1 interest in the region is "no shooting wars." The U.S. wants peaceful stability. China knows that we don't have territorial ambitions in Asia. Lots of other countries do though.
- woobar 10y agoNorth Korea could destroy Seoul without even crossing the border. And they are better prepared for defense. And who will stop China from intervening if US is out of the picture?
- greedo 10y agoNK is starving, equipped with ancient hardware, and without adequate fuel for training. The one thing they have is artillery, which can do an incredible amount of damage to SK. So you think the current token US force in SK can stop China if it decides to intervene? That force just acts as a nuclear tripwire; it doesn't need to be larger to act in that fashion.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoJust to be clear, I don't disagree with anything you've said here, and as such I prefaced my comment with "Rightly or wrongly". And it seems likely to me that as Trump continues to receive intelligence briefings, economic and military advice, we will see a whole lot not change. That's my prediction. Probably.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]