4 ms·
Nobody on the ground believes that, it looks smells and sounds like horseshit. This plays out in every collective bargaining deal. The company says "here's the
by Spooky23 10y ago
Nobody on the ground believes that, it looks smells and sounds like horseshit.
This plays out in every collective bargaining deal. The company says "here's the offer, if you don't like it, we'll close the place and go to [Alabama|Mexico|China]".
The automation thing is a statistics trick. You look at total value of the finished output which skews the numbers to things like car assembly where many tasks are automated, but ingnore the downstream parts manufacturing, much of which is offshore or in Mexico.
Have you ever seen a textile factory? There isn't a ton of automation for many phases of the work. Just a race to the bottom to places like Bangladesh where it's easy to abuse the workforce.
The economic outputs may be bigger, the cream is only rising to the top.
- Analemma_ 10y agoSome evidence in favor of this argument is that automation is taking jobs even when it's impossible for those jobs to be outsourced: e.g. in coal mines.
- snowwrestler 10y agoThis conversation is the election in a nutshell. Obama and Hillary stuck with a whole-economy, stats-based approach to talking about the recovery, meanwhile Trump addressed the anger and despair of middle class working folks who see their jobs going away or getting worse.
- twblalock 10y ago> Nobody on the ground believes that, it looks smells and sounds like horseshit. If you don't like an evidence-based argument, you should respond with a different evidence-based argument rather than dismissing it as "horseshit" and "tricks."
- BipolarElsa 10y agoMost people buy the fat capitalist factory-owner alibis hook, line and sinker. So don't be surprised he if he calls it horseshit. That's exactly what it is.
- birken 10y agoAnd what do you think happens if you force those factory jobs back into the US with tariffs and then force companies to pay workers a living wage with benefits? The companies instead pay big companies and already highly paid engineers to build machines to automate the work. Companies will always do whatever is most efficient, they don't care if they are using humans in Bangladesh or machines in the US.
- Spooky23 10y agoWe elected republicans, so they give no shits about living wages. If we made my t-shirts here, they'd cost $6 instead of $4.50, but the line workers would be making and spending money here instead of collecting disability and doing nothing. Supporting businesses doing equipment sales and repair would reappear. Wholesalers would open warehouses, etc. The losers would be the middlemen brokering the skimming. I remember buying a pair of shoes in the 90s from a company that closed its factory in Maine. The next year the same shoe, made in some guangdong factory cost 20% more. I'd rather make a living for my neighbor than a fortune for some middleman.