3 ms·
This is surprising, and it could mean that early commenters have their voice heard more than later commenters. But it could also just mean that topics raised by
by gnicholas 10y ago
This is surprising, and it could mean that early commenters have their voice heard more than later commenters. But it could also just mean that topics raised by early commenters end up being discussed in those threads, and commenters on both sides have their voices heard.
For example, if the first comment is roughly "I read the linked article and disagree because of A, B, and C" then someone with an opposing viewpoint would probably reply to the existing first comment instead of creating a separate comment.
This doesn't mean that the second commenter's voice isn't heard—it just means it all happens under the thread created by the first commenter.
- kemitche 10y agoIf two commenters want to say the same thing, the first arrival will post it, and the second will upvote it (and maybe reply with additional information). So it's not surprising that top comments are weighted towards early arrivals. The question needs to be are there later comments that are objectively better that don't end up sorted higher when sorting by "best". The "best" sort, by the way, does not use time as a factor, but rather generates a confidence score. Newer comments have less votes and thus less confidence (which ends up giving them a slight boost).
- asddddd 10y agoWhat if you consider it as an optimization problem for the late commenter? You have to choose where to insert your comment, most likely there are multiple options. A root-level comment when there are already dozens is unlikely to be noticed; there is significant momentum behind the top comments, usually for good reason - whether jokes, clever insight, or a popular viewpoint. Instead, if you reply near the top in a context where it makes some sense, you skip the root-level graveyard and are almost guaranteed good placement with the downside of "overhead" due to the upwards chain always appearing first. Consider also that the penalty for being the 2nd, 3rd, or worse comment at root-level gradually increases due to the increasingly nested replies to each highly rated comment. If you assume root-level comments express opinions, minority opinions are also more likely to maintain good position in a reply comment such as the one you posited. Lastly, "trickle down karma" could be a factor. A quality reply to a root-level comment could enhance the parent comment's value and result in additional karma for them. Such situations could include biases like assuming comments which merited replies are interesting due to peer validation and thus reading them, and more fundamental added value such as uncited sources being given.
- minimaxir 10y agoThere is a "hijacking the top post" meme that pops up occasionally where an important reply is made to the top-ranking comment, since it would get more exposure. (Rare, since it most cases it would be seen as spam if unrelated to the parent)