4 ms·

I am guessing that HN will have a lower percentage than reddit. New comments get a bit of time at the top and have a chance to gain votes if they are worthy.

ethanbond 10y ago
That's how Reddit comments work too...
- no_protocol 10y ago
  Sorry, I am not familiar with Reddit, I just took the author's word for it: Anecdotally, that doesn’t be the case with Reddit’s modern algorithm; comments made late in the thread appear at the bottom, where they likely will not receive any upvotes In my experience with Hacker News, late comments are given some space right at the very top, even if they are a day late. I thought this was a distinction worth commenting on, but maybe I misunderstood the quoted passage.
  - ethanbond 10y ago
    So this is kind of bizarre wording on the author's part. He describes that in fact Reddit does use time decay for exactly the reason you mentioned literally two sentences before what you quoted. It seems weird to state something as a fact then dispute it based on an anecdote without addressing the obvious tension between those things... > Reddit’s ranking algorithm attempts to rectify this by determining comment ranking using both time and community voting; comments in a thread, by default, are ordered based on the points score (upvotes - downvotes) the comment receives, subject to a rank decay based on the age of the comment. > In theory, this system should allow comments that posted later in the thread’s lifetime to rank much higher temporarily, then Redditors can vote on the new comment; if the new comment is good, it can now rise to the top and therefore the content which would otherwise be buried is now surfaced. And then it continues on to the section you quoted. I'm not sure what to believe!
  - minimaxir 10y ago
    I commented about the HN behavior in another thread. (I did not comment about the HN behavior in the article because I have no statistical evidence of HN behavior.)

ethanbond 10y ago

That's how Reddit comments work too...

no_protocol 10y ago
Sorry, I am not familiar with Reddit, I just took the author's word for it: Anecdotally, that doesn’t be the case with Reddit’s modern algorithm; comments made late in the thread appear at the bottom, where they likely will not receive any upvotes In my experience with Hacker News, late comments are given some space right at the very top, even if they are a day late. I thought this was a distinction worth commenting on, but maybe I misunderstood the quoted passage.
- ethanbond 10y ago
  So this is kind of bizarre wording on the author's part. He describes that in fact Reddit does use time decay for exactly the reason you mentioned literally two sentences before what you quoted. It seems weird to state something as a fact then dispute it based on an anecdote without addressing the obvious tension between those things... > Reddit’s ranking algorithm attempts to rectify this by determining comment ranking using both time and community voting; comments in a thread, by default, are ordered based on the points score (upvotes - downvotes) the comment receives, subject to a rank decay based on the age of the comment. > In theory, this system should allow comments that posted later in the thread’s lifetime to rank much higher temporarily, then Redditors can vote on the new comment; if the new comment is good, it can now rise to the top and therefore the content which would otherwise be buried is now surfaced. And then it continues on to the section you quoted. I'm not sure what to believe!
- minimaxir 10y ago
  I commented about the HN behavior in another thread. (I did not comment about the HN behavior in the article because I have no statistical evidence of HN behavior.)