3 ms·
This is going to seem personally harsh--that's not my intention. But you're flatly wrong. Fundamentally, collecting observations is an active pursuit. An examp
by snowwrestler 10y ago
This is going to seem personally harsh--that's not my intention. But you're flatly wrong. Fundamentally, collecting observations is an active pursuit.
An example: We didn't start to learn about electricity until we started messing with it. That's because there was very little to observe passively. Touching electric fish, rubbing amber to make static electricity, flying a kite into a thunderstorm--these sorts of actions produced the early observations that started us down the path toward the knowledge we have today.
Your example was observing USB traces. In order to do that, you had to plug a well-understood sensor into a well-understood interface. You did something, and observed the results. You just think of it as passive observation because you're taking for granted the enormous amount of prior knowledge that made it possible.
- Benjamin_Dobell 10y agoI do agree with you here. My point is paralysing the monkey didn't help them collect data about how a monkey walks, quite the opposite. Reasonable observations would consist of using electrodes to monitor left leg movements vs right leg movements. Running vs walking, joint extension etc. Build a waveform generator and compare the generated waveforms vs real waveforms and iterate. (The scientists did actually do this.) Once you've got a fair degree of confidence then you can try apply your work. Paralysing a monkey just to replay captured data when we already know we can interface with the nervous system is totally unnecessary. Edit: It should really go without saying that when it does come time to apply your work you do everything within your power to avoid harming a non-consenting creature. Does applying the work even require paralysing a monkey? Can it be temporary? What about sedation and then interfacing with the nervous system whilst sedated?