7 ms·
I feel like people are getting mad at the FBI for not pulling the trolley car lever in the right way, which is a valid thing to be mad about, but I believe the
by klodolph 10y ago
I feel like people are getting mad at the FBI for not pulling the trolley car lever in the right way, which is a valid thing to be mad about, but I believe the FBI made the right choice.
First, let's not rely too heavily the analogies with drugs or prostitution. The differences between CP and drugs / prostitution are too large to ignore anyway.
CP consumers are often producers as well. That's a fact—you want CP, so you make some yourself and swap it with others to get more. This isn't universal but it's common enough that you should know about it. So the visitors to the CP web site are not all just consumers of CP but many of them are producers as well. This is relevant because you have to weigh the damage of distributing CP against the benefit of catching people who produce CP. People have stated that distribution revictimizes the children, but I would weigh that against the ability to catch people who were either producing their own or at least supporting other producers of CP.
So the FBI discovers this server, operates it for less than 30 days with a Tor exploit, and catches 200 people using the site. Yes, the FBI was complicit in the distribution of CP, but rephrased as a trolley car problem, this is basically like not pulling the lever, allowing the distribution to continue for a short time, and using that to catch 200 consumers—and how many of them are producers? You can pull the lever now and stop the distribution of CP, or you can let the trolley barrel down the tracks for a short time and save all these people somewhere else.
(People are saying that the exploit may have done damage to other police investigations from other countries—I don't see any evidence that the exploit damaged the computer, merely that it leaked information about the computer.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- voxic11 10y agoI think maybe your argument about consumers also being producers made more sense in the pre internet age when distribution of the content was very hard. I would be rather surprised if they was still true today. After all I presume the FBI didn't create their own content...
- openasocket 10y agoLook at the affidavit: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/3216737-Freedom-Hosting-NIT-Affidavit.html#document/p91/a327945 https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/3216737-Freedom-Host... I only skimmed, but at least 1 of the Websites required users to upload their own CP, to be approved by the admins, before they could download any.
- arthulia 10y agoYou don't think they just found it elsewhere on the internet?
- Cyph0n 10y agoUploading != producing
- dogma1138 10y agoBut if the upload requires it to be new or at least unique to the site it usually does means production either directly or a contracted one. If not everyone would upload the same content pretty much.
- Cyph0n 10y agoMy assumption is that production is concentrated to a small inner "scene", just like the warez scene. If you have enough connections and perhaps money, you could get the material from the source, and then use that to gain access to other sites that require contributions, which is analogous to how elite private torrent trackers work. So again, uploading does not imply production capability, at least the way I see it.
- lightedman 10y ago"but I believe the FBI made the right choice." To further encourage the victimization of children for their own personal gain? FUCK THAT and KILL ALL FBI AGENTS NOW. Disclaimer: I'm a victim of child rape. 12 years old, forced to suck dick at gunpoint. Police and FBI did NOTHING.
- mSparks 10y agowell. from the op they actually quite likely did do something.... They filmed it and stuck it on their website. Expect to see much more of this now a child rapist is president of the united states (again).
- TaylorAlexander 10y agoIt makes sense to me that, while some number of people would want to consume CP, only a very small fraction of them would be willing and able to secure a child to photograph. I imagine much less than 1% of the people who are involved with CP do more than consume it online. Do you have a source for your information regarding the prevalence of production?
- dogma1138 10y agoIn the west maybe, but they can always travel to South America or Asia and get it there. Eastern Europe and Russia also used to be a hot spot for these productions but they cracked pretty hard on that. He is correct that most CP these days is traded, large scale productions are too risky since even 3rd world countries have been stepping up Anti-CP enforcement. If you are a middle aged men traveling to Thailand a lot for no apparent reason don't be surprised if they flag you at the airport and search you.
- ussain 10y agoMaybe we should start jailing people for watching films with guns in them. It's hard to acquire guns for abuse in the west maybe, but they can always go to the Middle East and get it there.
- dogma1138 10y agoIf every gun shot in a movie resulted in a casualty then yes we might have to reconsider our stance on guns in movies. You do realize that every child in a CP movie is being raped right? This isn't regular porn, these aren't consenting adults who are compensated for their participation.
- RIMR 10y agoIIRC, a lot of these site require that you share a unique photo or video (something they don't have in their library already) as a condition of membership. This ensures that only the most serious users even get a chance to view the forums. These communities would have a lot more producers in them than your run-of-the-mill CP imageboards, as they have to fulfill a barrier to entry that only a seasoned CP consumer or producer would be able to meet. So, once the FBI have control of the site, they can sort out all the lurkers who are consuming but not actively participating (probably uncommon, given that these sites also require you to remain active to keep your membership) and get damning information about people who are mass-distributing/selling and/or producing child pornography.
- jobigoud 10y agoWould you be OK if they filmed new material of one of the existing victim? I think the entire debate relies on the re-victimization aspect. If we accept it, and they do, then it's decidely not a trolley car lever conundrum.
- clifanatic 10y agoInteresting point... it seems to me that they ought to at least find the victims and secure their blessing to be used this way.
- Pica_soO 10y agoWould it be okay, to upload the security camera footage of the beating up of a minor in a sweat shop that produces cheap shoes or phones? Would buying those shoes, then make you a co-producer?
- bobwaycott 10y ago> and how many of them are producers? Your argument really hinges on this point. So, what's the answer? Out of the 200, how many are proven producers?
- lomnakkus 10y agoHow much of this is backed up by evidence? (Being a little facetious, I suspect very little.) EDIT: Not to mention; the logic behind possession of CP being illegal is completely defeated by this enforcement strategy. (That's not to say I'll actually defend possession of CP, but I think it's very troubling that law enforcement and the judiciary are this out of sync.)
- jshevek 10y agoFacetious? Being flippant about a serious subject?
- drvdevd 10y agoNo one seems to remember rule 41 in this thread. Did it get tossed out already? We can all look at this and assume the FBI made a good choice here, even if they broke the law in the process. But.. what about those of us who use Tor to browse perfectly legal content in order to simply attain added privacy from the prying eyes of our local ISPs? Or to host SSH via a hidden service? Etc. You may not know it yet, but you need tor or you will need it sooner or later. Or you will need something else like it.
- drvdevd 10y agoLet me add to that: the FBI themselves and various Police forces will also need Tor, or something like it, as well.
- SN76477 10y agoI think that this is the morale hairs that have to be split. I would disagree, and that they are being in violation of the law to uphold the law. Which I think is much more dangerous for everyone. This isnt to say that CP isnt dangerous, or take away its magnitude. I am saying that there should never be a situation where those that uphold the law should be allowed to break the law.