3 ms·
We have seen many such interfaces in recent years, but as I understand these techniques they all suffer the same problem. The body eventually coats the electro
by sandworm101 10y ago
We have seen many such interfaces in recent years, but as I understand these techniques they all suffer the same problem. The body eventually coats the electrodes in a non-conductive layer, essentially scar tissue, and the whole thing grinds to a halt in a matter of weeks. Until that practical limitation is surmounted, it seems very wrong to treat animals in such a manner. Watching the paralyzed monkey (also the rat) struggle in obvious agony as the commentators cheered was not fun. This was not the sort of thing I had expected to see on a program clearly aimed at a general audience. This was the very dark side of animal testing.
I saw this story on a canadian news show a couple days ago, a show that regularly does spots on human exploration of Mars. The stories are similar. The headline feel-good story is about the shiny new mars habitat or spacesuit someone is testing, but they haven;t figured out how to actually get it to mars. The result is the false impression that the dreamed future, colonizing Mars and curing paralysis, is closer than is true.
- Balgair 10y agoGliosis is a big problem for sure, and the central nervous system's scarring is not well understood at this time. Typically with recording electrodes you can either 'jiggle' them to shake off the scarring cells or pass a small amount of current between the combined electrodes to kill off the cells. These recording electrodes are typically only a few microns apart, so long range damage is a non-issue if the subject is not connected to ground in another way. You can go for ~6 months like this before the gliosis really builds up, and honestly, by that time the recording electrode has probably broken anyway or the subject has bonked the implant and it broke that way too, or as is typically the case with monkey subjects, it tore out the implant and ate it, stabbed another monkey with it, or tried to have sex with it. Monkey studies are rare and hard, not just because of ethical issues, but because monkeys are clever little assholes.
- sandworm101 10y agoThe process of refreshing an electrode sounds tortuous for the subject. And your information re monkeys clawing out devices Jurassic Park-style is equally disturbing. This points to the conclusion that the efforts spent internalizing the system has less to do with benefit and more to do with preventing the animal from ending the agony. But speaking of the electrodes, how long do they last in human subjects? Docs have been implanting various electrodes in human nerves/brains for decades and I assume a paralyzed person in a research study isn't going to rip them out. With enough current can the gliosis be overcome perpetually? (lol, spellcheck went with 'parallelized' and 'gigolos'. That might say something about my normal writing subjects.)
- Balgair 10y agoWell, there are no pain neurons inside of the central nervous system, so they literally cannot feel anything when you record or 'clean' the tips of the electrodes. Besides, since electricity takes the least impediant path, the current can only flow locally, i.e. over the non-sensing scarring cells. There is not harm to the subject, only to the scar tissue. Human electrodes can last a lifetime if they are properly done. Look at a pace-maker. They last decades. Granted they are not for individual neuron recordings, but they work great. The first deep brain stimulation patients are about 5 years old now and they seem to be doing fine as a whole, the Parkinson's disease symptoms are significantly lessened and their quality of life is very improved. It'll take more time and effort, but yeah, I think we can overcome the gliosis, though it is probably gong to be a drug interaction with the mechanical/electrical that will do it, not just electrical alone.
- biofox 10y agoSee the paper in my other reply to the parent. Admittedly, it only solves the technical problems (and only in mice so far), but it's a big step forward.
- biofox 10y agoA huge amount of progress has been made in this area. The most promising report I've seen was in Nat Methods a few weeks ago: "we demonstrated stable multiplexed local field potentials and single-unit recordings in mouse brains for at least 8 months without probe repositioning" http://www.nature.com/nmeth/journal/v13/n10/full/nmeth.3969.html http://www.nature.com/nmeth/journal/v13/n10/full/nmeth.3969....