4 ms·
One of the great insights in the Rules of Play[0] (which is a great book but has some frustratingly fundamental issues because it uses a very naive interpretati
by vanderZwan 10y ago
One of the great insights in the Rules of Play[0] (which is a great book but has some frustratingly fundamental issues because it uses a very naive interpretation of semiotics as its first principles), is that games have their own sense "aesthetics" compared to film, photography, or other art-forms before it.
Like film and photography in the last century, we're still figuring those out. But what is clear is that the main aesthetic experience revolves around the interactive loop a player has with a game. This is different from, say, the interaction with a painting.
In short: the aesthetics of games are fundamentally based on the aesthetics of interaction. And therefore much more broadly applicable than just a game-context.
This is why many interaction design studies have a game design course (I gave a few when was an adjunct IxD teacher at Malmo Uni). Other than being a bit of self-indulgence of the professors, that is.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rules_of_Play https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rules_of_Play
- hellbanner 10y agoI love the book and great summary about aeshetics of interaction. I like how they separated mechanics, interface & social context. Curious what fundamental issues you had with the book?
- vanderZwan 10y agoTheir interpretation of meaningful play and how they interpret the whole meaning-from-signs thing, which is a ridiculously banal interpretation of semiotics. I'm not even a philosopher proper but they're really out of their depth there; I suspect that they were trying to prove a point (that game design should be taken seriously) and cherry-picked philosophical interpretations for their needs.