10 ms·
The macabre fate of ‘beating heart corpses’
- cowpewter 10y agoMy mom was an ICU nurse for a good twenty or more years. In her words, people in the ICU either just got out of surgery, or they are there to die, and the ones that just got out of surgery don't stay there long. She also told me that after a while, you could tell when a person was dead, and their body just a piece of meat kept alive by machines. She said she wasn't sure if there really is a "soul" but whatever it was that made the difference between a human and a pile of meat was gone. She hated the families that kept the meat alive, while feeling sorry for them at the same time. She eventually burned out from so many years in the ICU and switched to a different type of nursing.
- kpil 10y agoI watched my dad die and it was obvious. In that case the bloodflow to the brain collapsed due to swelling so it was rather abrupt. Before the body reacted to pain in ways I recognised and even the breathing was somehow 'his' even if he could not breathe on his how. The higher functions of the brain was hopefully gone at this point. Afterwards, it was nothing left. Just a mechanical thing.
- robbiep 10y agoFood for thought for people reading the above: if a pregnant woman has a cardiac arrest, you have 3 minutes to decide if you are going to perform an emergency Caesarean section to save the child's life, or else you kill it too.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zaroth 10y agoI would say, ...or else the fetus dies with her.
- robbiep 10y agoApologies for the dark angle... doctors have gallows humour.
- joncp 10y agoI would say, ...or you've let the child die with her.
- crazypyro 10y agoThis isn't a healthy mindset for anyone in the healthcare industry.
- komali2 10y agoFailing to resuscitate someone is not the equivalent of killing them in my mind.
- wahern 10y agoA trolley is out of control, barreling toward 6 unaware adult strangers, including 2 parents with children at home. The only person who recognizes the impeding tragedy is you. Fortunately, the lever for a switch is within reach. Scenario #1: If you pull the lever, you'll divert the trolley toward a 6-month-old infant in a carriage, killing it instantly. Do you hesitate such that you risk missing the opportunity to save the 6 people? Scenario #2: If you pull the lever, you'll divert the trolley to a 9-week-old, 1-inch long fetus in a petri dish (being transported and kept viable outside the womb due to new science). Do you hesitate such that you risk missing the opportunity to save the 6 people? If you answered yes to #2, you're either delusional or a morally troubled person. The modern anti-abortion movement requires adopting a disgusting equivocation. Sane, honest people can value fetal life without equivocating it to an actual child. Granted, the trolley problem has many flaws. There are many ways to legitimately weasel out of answering the question, but I think it fairly exhibits the senseless equivocation people make in the debate.
- user5994461 10y ago
- AndreiC92 10y agoI hope I never get to use this information.
- 13of40 10y agoIf you ever have to apply that knowledge, you'd better hope the autopsy can prove she died of a heart attack.
- pavlov 10y agoHow many people could perform an emergency C-section out of the blue, without harming the child as well? I hope nobody actually thinks this is worth considering if your pregnant wife has a heart attack.
- bbcbasic 10y ago"You kill it too" is a loaded way to put it and isn't how the law would see it. Although if you stick a kitchen knife in her they may see that a bit differently! I'd probably call emergency services like most sane people. I'm sure even an OB would to the same even though technically they have the skills to do a C section. Even if they were already at the hospital. Finally heart attacks are not necessarily or even usually fatal.
- robbiep 10y agoA heart attack is different to a cardiac arrest, the later of which implies that circulation has stopped. There are many causes of arrest and it would be unusual for a woman of child bearing age to have an arrest as a result of a heart attack. The training for emergency room doctors is for us to have the c section kit ready to go on arrival of the woman and be prepared to open the abdomen after the first cycle or compressions/resus - otherwise we have left it too long and the fetus is suffering. My point in illustrating this was only to show that It is interesting to consider how quickly you need to make an enormous decision.
- adrianN 10y agoI for one would be completely fine with doctors harvesting my organs after my brain is sufficiently damaged that I won't experience conscious thought again, even if my lizard brain is still alive and supports all bodily functions.
- tgb 10y agoProbably the way to make this happen is to let your close family know and to put it in writing in your will.
- komali2 10y agoWills aren't accessed until well into the process of handling a person's death. It would still be a sort of chicken and egg scenario - does their will apply, as they're not technically deceased by this State's laws? You can get medical bracelets for certain things, maybe something along those lines?
- ChrisClark 10y agoI believe that's what a living will is for. Should make sure you have one of those as well.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoNot your will. You need a advance medical directive also known as a living will. Wills are for after death.
- agumonkey 10y agoThis is my "favorite" way to think about this. If your soul is gone the sentence is here.
- necessity 10y agoThe article leads one to think that there is significant room for error in determining if you in fact have just a lizard brain left.
- 10y ago
- SeanDav 10y agoJust recently there was a report in a national newspaper of a patient going from officially "Brain dead" to recovering and going on to live fairly normally. I will try find the link to this. EDIT: Not the specific link I was thinking about, but here are 2 of many others: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-2134346/Steven-Thorpe-Teenager-declared-brain-dead-FOUR-doctors-makes-miracle-recovery.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-2134346/Steven-Tho... http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3081882/It-hand-God-work-Meet-brave-teenage-girl-suffered-irreversible-brain-injury-pulled-life-support-awoke-coma-recovery.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3081882/It-hand-God-...
- 13of40 10y agoSomething like 90,000 people die every year from simple medical mistakes in US hospitals, so at some point you have to decide where to throw your money. Do you spend $200K per patient keeping dead people on ventilators just in case one occasionally comes back to life, or would that money be better spent on something else, like teaching nurses to follow sterilization checklists?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 10y agoNote that it is key to go further than training the nurses. You have to change the culture so that it is expected by everyone involved for a nurse to tell a doctor to stop what they are doing and wash their hands.
- DasIch 10y agoThe problem here isn't a lack of training or culture. Properly "washing your hands" takes a surprisingly large amount of time. In practice people don't do it not because they don't know how or don't want to but because they can't. They simply don't have the time either in general or sometimes in a specific situation. If you want to make a significant impact here, you would need to hire more staff.
- logronoide 10y agoBelieve me, you read this kind of articles from a complete different perspective when the "beating heart corpse" is your mother and the decision to disconnect her is on you. I hope nobody has to do it in her lifetime.
- kalleboo 10y agoAbsolutely. And on the other end of the spectrum, you have people in suffering with consciousness who wish to be euthanized. There's may be no "one size fits all" morality to be found here.
- cbennett 10y agoI know. I had to endure the same with my sister. She was only 24- tragic bike accident. We gave her one day that way after all the tests- apnea, ear flush, even an additional EEG which we requested and was sparse as the night sky- came back negative. We looked at the weekly costs and made an informed decision as well as choosing some organ donation options. Watching her wheeled out of that hospital room heart still beating was certainly the hardest moment of my life so far. We never saw the actual 'plug' pulled and i actually prefer(red) it that way. I deeply empathize that the decision was all on you. doing it collectively was a hair easier. hope your emotional/personal recovery has been as swift as possible.
- walshemj 10y agohugs a terrible position to be in - I am on the other side waiting for the call for a new kidney.
- itbeho 10y agoThoughts and prayers for you both and everyone else in the same or similar situations.
- oaktowner 10y agoThanks for sharing that cbennett, and good luck to you walshemj. I lost one of my closest friends a few years ago to an accident but was heartened to know that his organs went on to help others.
- wyldfire 10y ago> “It goes back and forth as to what people call them but I think patient is the correct term,” says Eelco Wijdicks, a neurologist from Rochester, Minnesota. I can't tell if this is an error, as if it should have been "[...] patient is the correct term" or if the neurologist is trying to be funny, or make a point. IMO the writer/editor should've omitted this quote or clarified its context and overall meaning to the article.
- greenshackle2 10y agoWhy do you think there's an error? It's not 100% clear why the author included the quote there, but the sentence itself makes sense to me, and doesn't sound funny or non-serious.
- forrestbrazeal 10y agoFor a lot more on this topic than you ever wanted to know, I highly recommend Dick Teresi's "Brain Dead". It's a scary and fascinating look at the so-called "death determination" industry that addresses one of our society's least-asked questions: in an era of unprecedented medical skill and technology, who draws the line between life and death, why do they draw it there, and how much are they getting paid? https://www.amazon.com/Undead-Harvesting-Ice-Water-Beating-Heart-Cadavers-How/dp/1400096111 https://www.amazon.com/Undead-Harvesting-Ice-Water-Beating-H...
- DonaldFisk 10y agoAnother book of interest is Buried Alive by Jan Bondeson (https://www.amazon.com/Buried-Alive-Terrifying-History-Primal/dp/039332222X/ https://www.amazon.com/Buried-Alive-Terrifying-History-Prima...), which covers the steps that were taken to prevent premature interment, including the ways death was diagnosed.
- googletazer 10y agoJust the comments on amazon show how polarizing the contents are, but I'm really happy someone is asking questions. The stakes are as high as can be - for the potential donor and recipient. I really hope smart people are working on artificial organs or growing organs in pigs, instead of the focus being on devising tests when a person is really dead or not with the intention to harvest theirs.
- rwmj 10y ago"Stiff" by Mary Roach is also a good read on the many things that happen to dead bodies. https://www.amazon.co.uk/Stiff-Curious-Lives-Human-Cadavers/dp/0141007451 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Stiff-Curious-Lives-Human-Cadavers/...
- forrestbrazeal 10y agoEdit to the above: Somehow I cited the name of the book wrong. It is, of course, "The Undead", not "Brain Dead." And +1 to the Mary Roach book recommendation. You might need a strong stomach to get through that one, though - it's pretty grisly.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- random_upvoter 10y agoThe brain cells love to believe that the brain cells are all that matter. The cells of your heart, your liver, your gut would disagree, but they're not designed to do the talking.
- diggernet 10y agoIs there a medical person here who can help me out with this? Take these excerpts from the article: "He suggested using the newly invented stethoscope to listen for a heartbeat – if the doctor didn’t hear anything for two minutes, they could be safely buried." "An electrical engineer from Brooklyn, New York, had been investigating why people die after they’ve been electrocuted – and wondered if the right voltage might also jolt them back to life." "Starting in the 1950s, doctors across the globe began discovering that some of their patients, who they had previously considered only comatose, in fact had no brain activity at all." "They had discovered the ‘beating-heart cadavers’, people whose bodies were alive though their brains were dead." "In some cases, their hearts kept beating and their organs kept functioning for a further 14 years – for one cadaver, this strange afterlife lasted two decades." Now... If the brain were dead (by my understanding of a 'dead' organ - its cells have died), wouldn't the brain start either decomposing or being absorbed by the body? If that happens, it's a pretty clear indication that the brain is truly dead. But if it doesn't happen, doesn't that mean the brain cells are still alive (just not communicating for some reason)? And in that case (living cells with a blank EEG), couldn't there be a way to jump-start their communication, as was previously discovered with hearts? I'm sure that I'm completely ignorant of some critical factor, and look forward to your thorough discussion of it...
- mordocai 10y agoI am a layperson as well but as I understand it the brain cells have not died in a brain dead patient, rather there is no sign of communication as you said. As far as any thoughts of restarting communication, I have no idea.
- comboy 10y agoArticle suggests that the cells get destroyed: > If their efforts are stalled by a lack of oxygen, neurons are rapidly inundated with ions which build to toxic levels, causing irreversible damage. I mean, we may get into a discussion when does the brain cell die, like what if it still is a living cell, but can't act as a neuron anymore.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoAs medicine gets better and we develop a better understanding of how our bodies work this question will only get more difficult. At some point it will be possible to program your cells to repair any damage to your body including regenerating limbs or organs. And when you can do that, taking someone who is "dead", hooking them up to the "autodoc"[1] and having it repair the damage and restart them, then the only question might be how many short term memories did you lose? And if you can download those some how then even a partly decomposed body could be the source material for reconstructing the original, not a clone per se because parts of the original are re-used but certainly a full retrofit. Then a lot of built in human assumptions get really challenged. [1] This is a name used in science fiction stories to describe the machine that mechanically repairs tissue damage.
- seanp2k2 10y agoWth the current rate of stem cell research, I doubt I'll see that for at least 60 years.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoAs a mental exercise, look up the medical state of the art from 60 years ago (1956), look at what was known and unknown, and compare it to the current state of the art. The only thing slowing down this development timeline is the FDA approval process, and that doesn't slow down research much at all. Given that, I would be surprised if it took 60 years. It may not be 6 but I would put it more around 12 - 15 when we start human trials of organ or limb re-generation.
- asib 10y agoGoing off on a bit of a tangent, it's interesting to think about how 100 odd years ago if your heart stopped, you were declared dead. Then we got defibrillators and CPR, etc. and suddenly if your heart stopped you could still be resuscitated. Further, nowadays, if you have a heart attack and no one makes an effort to resuscitate you, and there's someone who knows how to nearby, most people would argue that that person has forgone a moral obligation. This is one of the arguments made for cryonics[0], in two ways. If in the future it's possible that we'll be able to revive a cryopreserved body, then you can't really consider someone dead if they're cryopreserved within a certain timeframe after their heart stops (just as today you can't consider someone dead within the ~5 minutes after their heart stops, because of CPR, etc). What's more, the people of the future will have a moral obligation to revive cryopreserved bodies, because not doing so would be the equivalent of not attempting CPR on someone who just had a heart attack. This is the response given when someone asks why anyone in the future would be bothered to go through the hassle of reviving cryopreserved bodies. Food for thought. [0]: https://www.alcor.org/FAQs/faq01.html#dead https://www.alcor.org/FAQs/faq01.html#dead
- astrodust 10y agoCyronics are a waste of money, it's junk and a way to sponge money out of the too-rich-too-vain crowd. The number of animals that can survive being frozen are pretty slim, and those that can survive being frozen for an indefinite period of time are almost zero. What could work is developing some kind of human version of torpor (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torpor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torpor), slowing down biological processes to a crawl, which would not only help with space travel but could buy people enough time for medical treatments to mature to the point of being feasible. It has the advantage of being fairly common in the mammal world, so genetically it's a lot closer than, say, what frogs do to survive being frozen. You can't buy decades, but you can buy five to ten years, and for some people that would be all the difference they need.
- Houshalter 10y agoCryonics could be made pretty cheap if lots more people signed up. It's only expensive because it's an extremely niche market. It's really a tragedy that cryonics isn't the default option. Even if you think it's unlikely to work, even a small chance at saving so many lives is worth it. Cryonics almost certainly works. They use chemicals which prevent the formation of ice crystals. Which is like 90% of the reason most animals can't survive being frozen. They've demonstrated certain organs can be revived from cryopreservation - a rabbit kidney was frozen and then successfully revived. Which is incredible. And even if we don't have the technology to revive everything today, I do believe it will be possible in the future. The point of cryopreservation is that everything is preserved completely. The information in your brain - what makes you you, is preserved.
- jcoffland 10y ago> By loosening up the definition a little further, transplant doctors would have access to a much larger pool of potential donors than they do at the moment and save countless lives. For some cases, we can never loosen this definition enough.
- paxcoder 10y agoI guess it's time again to spend some points. Killing/euthanizing people in any stage of development or condition is murder.
- wtbob 10y agoI'd say that it's homicide. Sometimes homicide is justified, and sometimes it's not. I think that defensive homicide is okay, and I think that's fairly uncontroversial. And there's definitely a difference between directly killing someone and withholding extraordinary measures. What's extraordinary and what's ordinary will, of course, change over time with the progress of technology. I'm not troubled by not tasking medical staffs with regulating hormones &c., as is required to keep brain-dead people alive. I'm rather more troubled by keeping them alive only to remove their organs piece by piece (but I find dead-donor transplantation morally problematic at best, anyway).
- tekklloneer 10y agoVery well. When someone I love is in that situation, I'll be happy to send you the $20k+ a week bill.
- bashinator 10y agoI agree, but I also think that there are circumstances where some humans are not/are no longer people. Encephalitic fetuses, accident victims with zero higher brain function, etc.
- paxcoder 10y agoI think you were thinking of anencephaly. But I disagree. Likewise for the comatose. Ask the guy pronounced brain dead by four doctors.
- x3n0ph3n3 10y agoI guess I'll spend some points and advocate for murder! "Some may question your right to destroy ten billion people. But those who understand know you have no right to let them live."
- whybroke 10y agoSuch caution to avoid misdiagnosing death is probably good. Too bad we put up with a worse than 4% error rate when applying the death penalty.