4 ms·
I don't think we can assume that just because somebody accepts a job working for the President necessarily means they necessarily condone the tone of his campai
by notahacker 10y ago
I don't think we can assume that just because somebody accepts a job working for the President necessarily means they necessarily condone the tone of his campaign or ever judged him to be a good choice for president. They can of course be judged on how they influence and shape policy proposals, and their participation in the process might well be much better or much worse than a principled boycott.
Peter Thiel is not somebody who has simply refused to rule himself out of serving, however. I do think we can judge people for donating large sums of money to the Trump election campaign and subsequently being appointed to a position of power, both because they signalled strong approval of Trump and his campaign with their wallet and because (like major donors appointed to high office in other administrations) they can readily be accused of paying for positions of power.
- BurningFrog 10y agoYou can definitely judge him for supporting the campaign. But do you judge him even more for pitching in after the election? As an admirer of Thiel and... the opposite of Trump, I find the whole thing confusing, but I'm definitely glad to have a sharp voice outside the Christie/Gingrich/Guiliani-axis involved. Thiel is not some random rich fat cat who buys an ambassadorship. He's an extremely capable and accomplished man, and to me it looks like he's the one doing Trump a favor, not the other way around. I realize reasonable people can differ on that part :)
- zymhan 10y agoNo, but his financial and verbal support for Trump before the election colors his participation in the administration.
- notahacker 10y agoWe judge him for how and why he pitches in, bearing in mind that a Trump presidency is something he wanted to actualise rather than mitigate the effects of. I don't doubt Thiel is capable and accomplished, but I also don't doubt he's ruthless, ambitious and tends to see things in black and white. It remains to be seen which of the ideas he's championed on he chooses to focuses his efforts on, of course, whether that's encouraging the government to support breakthrough research and entrepreneurship, slashing higher education funding and creating new tax shelters for the ultra rich, or just ensuring Palantir is well-positioned for contracts on new surveillance systems. Of course, reasonable people will still probably argue over what his contribution has been after he's made it. :)
- maratd 10y ago> We judge him for how and why he pitches in You have no idea how or why he's pitching in. You have very limited information on that front and judging him based on that is silly. It seems far more likely everything that was said and done was simply to get his foot in the door. You have no idea what his intentions are.
- anigbrowl 10y agoI do.
- notahacker 10y agoWe'll have considerably more information on how and why he's pitched in after he's actually done something with the foot he's got in the door. Which was literally the entire point of the post you're responding to...