4 ms·
Popular and right are orthogonal values. In addition, just like Brexit, I see a lot of people who appear to have completely ignored the concrete results of the
by bsder 10y ago
Popular and right are orthogonal values.
In addition, just like Brexit, I see a lot of people who appear to have completely ignored the concrete results of their actions.
For example, me to Trump voter: "You do realize that you voted to throw your own daughter and my mother off of healthcare? Your daughter couldn't get coverage before Obamacare because she has mild sleep apnea while being middle-aged. My mother couldn't get healthcare before the ACA because she is a breast cancer survivor." Trump voter: "Well, I didn't really want that."
What am I supposed to say at that point?
Please tell me which platform plank of yours is more important than your own daughter receiving healthcare?
Please tell me which platform plank of yours is more important than my mother receiving healthcare?
Really, I want to know this.
And, when you give me your answer about god, guns, gays, mexicans, emails, Benghazi or any other stupid thing that doesn't impact our lives one iota other than to serve as a propaganda vehicle, don't be surprised when I tell you how FUCKING WRONG you are.
Thanks.
- oldmanjay 10y agoLiterally everything in my life is more important to me than any aspect of your mother
- walshemj 10y agoYou need to a hard look at your self for saying that
- ersii 10y agoI've taken a long hard look at myself and I share oldmanjay's sentiments. You have other beliefs and other priorities, that's fine with me.
- arethuza 10y agoOut of interest, how would you summarize your political views? You are perfectly entitled to your views, but they appear to be so completely different to my own that I am genuinely interested to find out what you believe. [NB As a bit of background I'm from the UK, strongly in favour of the socialist NHS we have and happy to pay taxes so that everyone in our country can get pretty decent healthcare "free at the point of delivery"] Edit: I upvoted you because I don't think people should be downvoted just for making that comment.
- jlewallen 10y agoI applaud your efforts to understand this as I'm eager to also. It's a mentality or similar to one I've found myself in deadlock with before. For example, I asked a relative of mine if they would sacrifice themselves to save the lives of N number of people and there was no value of N they considered worth more than their own life. This relative found it uncomfortably easy to ignore and even justify the suffering of strangers. Not to say that the GP feels precisely this way. I'd hate to ascribe this particular belief to anybody that didn't directly espouse it.
- gspetr 10y agoI believe this book will help you to understand: https://archive.org/stream/MightIsRight_966/MightIsRight#page/n0/mode/2up https://archive.org/stream/MightIsRight_966/MightIsRight#pag...
- arethuza 10y agoIn case anyone is wondering what that link is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Might_Is_Right https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Might_Is_Right
- arethuza 10y agoI think that's a completely different argument and one that I'm not sure anyone could come up with a sensible answer unless they were actually put in that position. However, I can definitely understand the argument that being forced to pay taxes to pay for the healthcare of other people is unfair. I just happen to not agree with it but I don't think its unreasonable that other people don't agree with me on that point.
- jlewallen 10y agoAgreed, and sorry, didn't mean to imply they were similar arguments at all.
- oldmanjay 10y agoLet's take that long hard look. What aspects of a woman I never met should be more important to me than things that are in my life, and for bonus virtue signaling, why?
- namecast 10y ago"Eff you, I gots mine" is not the robust survival strategy you might think it is. I don't know you, but I hope your mother is doing ok, and I hope she will do better under a Trump presidency than I think she will. There's actually plenty of parts of my life that I'd consider giving up or changing if I could guarantee a better future for both your mom and mine, now that your post implicitly asks that question.
- oldmanjay 10y agoMy post did not ask the question. I don't care one whit about your feelings for my mother, because you don't know her at all. You don't even know if she's alive or if I even know her. You are simply virtue signaling. For that matter, although I don't particularly care, your uncharitable and incorrect summation of my view is also just virtue signaling. We get it! You have tremendous morals, the best morals.
- namecast 10y agoNo, I actually want to figure out how to live side by side. This shit is terrifying. Please stop talking past me and imagining an enemy that doesn't exist. (Also: I'm aware your post didn't ask the question. It was implicit... which is why I said implicitly. I do have the best vocabulary, tremendous vocab words folks. A lot of people are saying Trump voters have trouble with bigly words. Sad!)
- oldmanjay 10y agoMy point is that you inferred a question that was not asked implicitly or otherwise, not that I needed a definition of implicit. I did not talk past you. I simply deny your arrogant assumption upon which you base your understanding of me. Your terror is no more my responsibility than your putative mother's health. I don't consider you an enemy. In fact, I don't really consider you, because as a human being I have limited capacity for things like love and I save that capacity for the many people I actually know and deal with in my life.
- 10y ago
- sctb 10y agoDid we not ask you repeatedly not to do this? We've banned this account.
- trdrake 10y agoThere was a category of people [not me, fwiw] for which abortion was the singular issue that made them vote for what they considered a deeply flawed candidate. Everything else paled in comparison.
- jpgvm 10y agoAbortion also doesn't affect anyone other than the woman that chooses to exercise the right. Thus also a pretty shit reason to vote for someone.
- filoeleven 10y agoFrom the pro-life point of view, it also affects the unborn child who is murdered. For many of them, abortion is literally the same thing as letting people kill their toddlers because they decided that they don't want them for whatever reason. This is the divide. (I realize that there are other pregnancy complications that don't literally equate to having an inconvenient toddler, and pro-lifers aren't as consistent on how they view those cases, but those are a small minority of abortions.)