3 ms·
> if you offer a service that can compete with piracy, people stop pirating. But it doesn't solve the problem, because the #1 feature of pirated music is that
by snowwrestler 10y ago
> if you offer a service that can compete with piracy, people stop pirating.
But it doesn't solve the problem, because the #1 feature of pirated music is that it doesn't cost anything. A free streaming service doesn't cost anything either--but just like piracy, it also doesn't pay the artist anything.
> p.s. I don't think anyone ever made money from recording music, even when album sales were good. record labels have always taken the lions share of profits. this has nothing to do with artists making money IMO.
You are wrong. Source: my brother has been a recording artist for 20 years.
- shakna 10y agoSteam and Netflix do cost, but have verifiable impact in their industries. And they do pay their respective artists. The streaming service doesn't have to be free. But it does have to have a decent user experience.
- snowwrestler 10y agoThe music industry specifically has this problem. The video and gaming industries watched what happened to music and learned a lot of lessons about what not to do. For example, they didn't give up on DRM, and they funded a lot of their own services for online distribution (Steam, Hulu, etc.). They also have been much more aggressive negotiating with 3rd parties. Netflix started developing their own content because it became clear that movie studios and TV producers would soon start pulling out, in favor of their own software platforms. Vertical integration is the name of the game now. The ISPs are all buying content producers, the online stores are all developing original content, and the content producers are all selling out or doing partnership deals. Tidal is an example of musicians trying to do the same thing, but they're so late to the party it might not matter.