3 ms·
> And rather than embrace it, rural and white working-class Americans are twisting and turning, fighting it every step of the way. We will never return to the d
by flukus 10y ago
> And rather than embrace it, rural and white working-class Americans are twisting and turning, fighting it every step of the way. We will never return to the days where a white man could barely graduate high school and walk onto a factory floor at 18 and get a well-paying job for life. That hasn’t set in for much of the Midwest.
There's the problem and the bubble people are talking about. White men (or any sex and color really) that can barely finish high school aren't going away anytime soon and they still need jobs. Not everyone is capable of more academic work.
- cheriot 10y agoThey need job skills and few high schools teach them. One of the high schools I went to had a small program with the community college next door for people to learn marketable skills instead of the usual electives. The other had nothing like it. tl;dr Study beyond high school is not just liberal arts.
- flukus 10y agoMy high school was similar but that's all gone now. But this was 15 years ago and not finishing high school was still common. In fact I didn't and later learned programming through a trade school. I'm pretty sure there are next to no opportunities for anyone following my path today though.
- serge2k 10y agoThey have job skills, the jobs disappeared. It's not their fault. If outsourcing suddenly produced high quality issue free software for cheap tomorrow then we'd all be just as screwed despite having such great skills.
- dx034 10y agoMost job losses were due to automation, not necessarily outsourcing. And if they have job skills for jobs that don't exist anymore it's as if they don't have job skills at all. But it's certainly not their fault, it's the education system that has to teach job skills, you can't learn that by yourself.
- ubertaco 10y ago> if they have job skills for jobs that don't exist anymore it's as if they don't have job skills at all. Exactly this. At the risk of reductio ad absurdum, would anyone consider the ability to write (not compositional writing, just literally the ability to put a pen down on paper and form letters) a "marketable job skill" any more? Not likely, since that skill can be replaced by a $60 printer what doesn't need a salary.
- cheriot 10y agoWhat are those skills? My high schools taught regular academic subjects and electives. What job does that qualify a person to do? They can't fix a car, drive a big truck, or operate specialized machinery. Yes, the unskilled jobs moved. That's why high schools need to teach actual skills now.