6 ms·
Dan Savage declares May 20th "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day"
- tome 17y agoRelated to this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1284420 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1284420 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1284466 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1284466
- Tichy 17y agoIsn't that a bit like handing out free tickets to paradise? Right now, a fanatic has a choice of a few cartoonists to kill, many of whom might be under police protection. After May 20th, all a fanatic has to do is google for one of thousands or even millions cartoonists, choose one to kill, instant paradise. It might not be a DDoS on the fanatics, it is a DDoS on the police. In any case it seems very unlikely that fanatics would be deterred by such an action. One could perhaps hope for confusing them (can't decide whom to kill). Or an individual might feel safer in drawing a cartoon, because the random chance of being the selected victim among thousands has become smaller.
- maxharris 17y agoI do not want to live in a world where I have to "watch what I say" under the constant threat of death. The recognition of the inalienable right to speak your mind, using property that you own (and that includes your mind and body!), is fundamental to any legitimate government. Patrick Henry said it best: "Give me liberty or give me death."
- Tichy 17y agoBut how do you remove the threat? That is, how do you eliminate the crazies? Granted, I don't know how many crazies there are. Suppose it would go down as in my worst case scenario, with crazies killing cartoonists left and right. Assuming most crazies would be caught after the deed, after a while all crazies might be used up. The cost would be quite high, though (lots of dead cartoonists).
- maxharris 17y agoIt is a crime threaten people with violence. When someone holds up a sign that says "Death to so-and so!", and they're in America, arrest and prosecute them. And this doesn't go just for Islamic terrorists: anyone that threatens a particular person with violence, incites or instructs people to violate the rights of another particular person or exactly delimited set of persons (such that their rights could be violated independently of government action), they have committed a crime and should be prosecuted. The point is that you shouldn't have to wait until someone is dead to put a stop to violence, and you don't. The laws we already have do this.
- J3L2404 17y agoAnd on the other side... WARNING SARDONIC "Give me Christ or give me Hiroshima" Leonard Cohen
- adelevie 17y agoAbsolutely wrong. These guys thrive on the fear they can stir up. You let them win this relatively small battle, then the larger ones follow. Every single American lost an amount of freedom when Viacom caved to thuggish threats. I am no longer able to choose to watch South Park. Someone else chooses what I can and cannot watch based on their non-pluralistic religious sensibilities.
- Tichy 17y ago"These guys thrive on the fear they can stir up." Maybe, I don't know - maybe they are just crazy. Anyway, just playing devils advocate here. I am certainly not in favor of censorship.
- adelevie 17y agoMasses of people showing solidarity for Stone and Parker will not cause more terrorism. Letting these fanatics know that their tactics of petty intimidation actually work will create more terrorism.
- lionhearted 17y agoAgree. Caving to threats generates more threats. It's like when you've got a rabid dog snarling at you - you don't get it to go away by throwing meat at it.
- tzs 17y ago"Absolutely wrong. These guys thrive on the fear they can stir up" They may thrive on it, but I'd guess many of them are primarily motivated by trying to stop what they see as blasphemy. If they can stir up fear while doing so, they'll be happier, because that fear might stop future blasphemy. However, I don't think its safe to assume that if they aren't causing fear, they'll let the blasphemy slide.
- hackermom 17y agoRight. Let's just be silent instead, afraid of voicing our opinions... Gee, I wonder what kind of message that will send.
- zacharypinter 17y agoNot sure how plausible that scenario is, but it's a very interesting angle.
- tome 17y agoIf that happened there's no way muslims could continue to use the line "Islam is a religion of peace".
- isleyaardvark 17y agoI don't think that's exactly right. The religious doctrine that supports "Behead those that insult Islam/Muhammed" is based on sha'ria - Islamic law. The murder would just be an enforcement of the law, and not a ticket to paradise. (I believe you are thinking of jihad, as best I can remember the only ticket to paradise is not fighting in jihad, but dying in jihad.) Bit of a quibble, but there's a bit of a difference between a ticket to paradise and simply enforcing religious law on people who do not live under sha'ria or follow that religion.
- Tichy 17y agoI don't know much about it, to be honest. But what incentives do the fanatics have to enforce islamic law? Maybe in some cases some spiritual leaders make extra promises? Like for the famous british author who has been living in hiding for years now? (Somehow I am braindead today, can't recall his name).
- adelevie 17y agoSalman Rushdie
- hackermom 17y agoGood. Let the human filth that thrives on extinguishing others' voices honk their little horns like the clowns they are.
- hackermom 17y agoLots of radical muslims here, huh? :P
- cgranade 17y agoSee also: http://rawstory.com/rs/2010/0424/seattle-cartoonist-promotes-everybody-draw-mohammed-day/ http://rawstory.com/rs/2010/0424/seattle-cartoonist-promotes...
- kevinh 17y agoThis is pretty much what I was thinking when I heard about the Mohammed-South Park debacle. We need enough people to depict Mohammed that threats will be entirely meaningless.
- Kilimanjaro 17y agoReligion, the hand brake of freedom.
- smgy 17y agorelated: http://muslimmatters.org/2010/04/25/salon-misreading-the-quran-to-threaten-the-south-park-guys http://muslimmatters.org/2010/04/25/salon-misreading-the-qur...
- mad44 17y agoI feel sad about this whole ordeal. I feel that this is unwarranted provocation. (Disclosure: I am a muslim. And long time hacker news participant.) Muslims value their prophet a lot, as they also value Jesus, Moses, Abraham, and other prophets. The prophets are human, but they excelled in their lives by the choices they made, they served as great examples and deserve respect. Out of respect to prophet Muhammed, muslims would always follow with a short prayer every time they utter his name. Most muslims will refuse to name their children "Muhammed", because they don't want to call/yell their children with the name of the prophet, so they use variations on the name, such as Ahmed, Mehmed, Mustafa. Dead threats by the fanatics are unfounded and despicable. But, following on this with a provocation like this is equally unfounded and hurtful towards the muslims. As for people who feel like their freedoms are restricted if they were not allowed to draw and make fun of prophet Muhammed, I have hard time understanding them. Muslims are not dictating them to actively respect him. Not at all. They are just asking them not to go over their way to actively insult his memory. Instead of this hurtful and easy shot, why don't they all consider practicing their freedom of speech by wearing t-shirts that has bomb pictures and arabic inscriptions on it to the airports? Or, any other way that is offensive to the government?
- amvp 17y agoI don't think the people behind this look at this as provocation, but as retaliation. For those that haven't see this: Philip Pullman (who wrote a book titled 'The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ' had a comment on free speech and the right not to be shocked that I think was quite beautiful: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HQ3VcbAfd4w&feature=player_embedded# http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HQ3VcbAfd4w&feature=playe...! "It was a shocking thing to say and I knew it was a shocking thing to say. But no one has the right to live without being shocked. No one has the right to spend their life without being offended. Nobody has to read this book. Nobody has to pick it up. Nobody has to open it. And if you open it and read it, you don't have to like it. And if you read it and you dislike it, you don't have to remain silent about it. You can write to me, you can complain about it, you can write to the publisher, you can write to the papers, you can write your own book. You can do all those things, but there your rights stop. No one has the right to stop me writing this book. No one has the right to stop it being published, or bought, or sold or read. That's all I have to say on that subject"
- adelevie 17y agoI subscribe to an ideology in which not drawing pictures of Muhammed is blasphemy. Who am I to say that my ideology trumps your rights?
- smgy 17y agoMuslims' response: http://muslimmatters.org/2010/04/26/south-park-episode-censorship-of-mohammeds-s-depiction-the-script-played-to-perfection/ http://muslimmatters.org/2010/04/26/south-park-episode-censo...
- wr1472 17y agoLets all bully the muslims. I don't think this is a very productive line of action, very agressive and confrontational. This comment does not mean I am defending the actions of an extreme minority who threatened the South Park guys. However, with freedom of expression comes a responsibility to not offend others. What did the South Park guys hope to achieve by portraying the prophet onscreen? It smacks to me of a cheap publicity stunt, hidden behind the banner of freedom of expression. If someone finds something offensive, would you go out of your way to deliberately offend them? Why? At the very least it is bullying, at most it is a very agressive act. The muslims who counter this threats, and acts of violence are just as ignorant, and deserve to not be called Muslim. Look back to Persian (and even Ottoman too, I believe) art, there the prophet is depicted, granted not in a derogatory way. Live and let live everyone, why do we feel we have to go out of our way to offend others (on both sides)? Are we doing it because we want to exercise the fact that we can? Less of the dick waving, be humble and respectful of others, and their beliefs. Its not hard.