5 ms·
This is just nonsense. Trump never provided his tax returns for scrutiny so unlike Hillary we don't know who exactly he is beholden to. What we know from his s
by threeseed 10y ago
This is just nonsense.
Trump never provided his tax returns for scrutiny so unlike Hillary we don't know who exactly he is beholden to. What we know from his son, sources and leaks is that Russian ogligarchs with ties to Putin do hold significant amounts of his company's debt. It is this type of "pay to play" that is far, far beyond anything that has ever been seen before.
- Tycho 10y agoWhy would we learn anything new about that from his tax return? Doesn't the financial disclosure filing cover that?
- threeseed 10y agoTax returns provide additional information. For example they describe in detail the tax mix e.g. income versus capital gains, as well as the nature of liquid assets, deduction types etc.
- Tycho 10y agoBut why would that be relevant to him being beholden to Russian investors? What sort of connection/conclusion would it forseeably allow us to make?
- edblarney 10y agoI guess if Russians were giving him very sweet terms on financing, he might be inclined to 'repay' them by loosening some foreign investment policy. Also - the US currently has a gang of Russians under severe financial control, i.e. they are not able to move a dollar out of Russia. If those guys are connected with 'Russian investors' they might try to lobby to get out of 'money jail'.
- Tycho 10y agoBut why would his tax return shed new light on this, that his previous financial disclosure did not? Are you saying that the tax return would include detail on things like financing rates that were not mentioned in the financial disclosure? I thought it would just tell us what deductions he was taking / loopholes he was exploiting with respect to his taxes.
- edblarney 10y agoYes, his tax returns may very well indicate who he is doing business with and roughly on what terms.
- baybal2 10y ago>gang of Russians under severe financial control Lol, what does it mean: under control until the guy opens an account under a fake id
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- edblarney 10y agoWe wouldn't learn anything salient. But we would probably learn something like: a) he's not nearly as rich as he claims b) he's made maybe $50M this year and paid $0 in taxes due to write-offs in earlier years. That would not go down well publicly. Romney paid an effective rate of 14% on his $500K income (I think all capital gains) and that was destructive for his campaign. It just looks pretty out of touch - 99% of Americans earn less than $500K and pay far more than 14% in taxes. So it would have been a publicity disaster, enough to hurt him badly. Maybe some other skeletons in there. But I don't think anything illegal.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe rate was 14%, the income was a bit higher. Mitt Romney and his wife, Ann, paid $1.94 million in federal taxes on last year's income of $13.7 million, for an effective tax rate of 14.1 percent, his campaign said Friday. http://www2.ljworld.com/news/2012/sep/21/romneys-paid-194-million-fed-taxes-2011/ http://www2.ljworld.com/news/2012/sep/21/romneys-paid-194-mi... He also gave $4 million to charities.
- smsm42 10y ago> He also gave $4 million to charities. Somehow everybody always forgets this part - when you donate to charity, this is deduced from the taxable income, usually, but is not accounted for in tax rate calculation. Which means, if I earned tons of money and donated it all to charity - I'd pay 0% taxes, so people would say "why this fatcat doesn't pay any taxes even though we are paying a lot, he must be doing some shady things!".
- finiter 10y agoHelp me figure this out. Romney earned $13.7 million and paid $1.94 million in taxes. That's 14% (1.94/13.7), but you're saying doesn't account for the charitable donations. So then the formula would be 1.94/(13.7-4), right? A 20% rate?
- 10y ago
- edblarney 10y agoPersonal finances are another issue altogether. He is audited every single year, and there is very deep scrutiny of his personal finances. There are many in the IRS who would love to find something wrong. It's the political favours and support that mattes. I will say this: the laws concerning 'conflict of interest' are very weak in the US for the office of the Pres. It's possible that a Malaysian leader could buy favour by offering him a future sweet deal on land for a Casino in Manila type thing. Again - I don't like Trump, and don't think he's evil and probably won't be looking for that kind of deal ... but I also bet he just might not be able to resist! Anyhow - as of today, he owes almost nothing politically. That's what's weird about it: he's the least civic minded pres in modern history - who also is the most unencumbered! Crazy.
- threeseed 10y agoThe IRS is obligated to not reveal ANY personal information regarding a person or company's tax situation. So for all we know he has done something wrong, every year. You seem to think that being audited somehow ensures transparency. It doesn't. And you keep making these statements about being unencumbered when it is well known that Russian ogligarchs own significant amounts of his company's debt. That is the very definition of being encumbered.
- tsomctl 10y ago> Anyhow - as of today, he owes almost nothing politically. Really? The German bank that has lent Trump millions of dollars has a $14 billion fine to the justice department. https://theintercept.com/2016/11/10/trump-presidency-could-be-worth-14-billion-to-his-troubled-lender/ https://theintercept.com/2016/11/10/trump-presidency-could-b...
- edblarney 10y ago" The German bank that has lent Trump millions of dollars has a $14 billion fine to the justice department. " That's not a conflict of interest, it's just regular business. If you are 'in business' - you 'do business' with banks. There are not that many big ones. A loan is just a financial product like any other.