11 ms·
Apple selling a $79 MacBook Pro power adapter without a USB-C cable goes too far
- pedalpete 10y agoIs there a reason why the power adapter wouldn't include a USB-C cable? Can it be used without it? Does the power adapter work with older Macs using a different cable? I'm not trying to forgive apple, I'm trying to understand why/how a decision like this could be made.
- askvictor 10y agoMy only guess is they figure you can take the cable with you. Assuming the wall wart is easy to access to plug and unplug.
- jakobegger 10y agoIf you bother wrapping up your cable to stuff it in your bag, you might as well put the brick in too.
- chrisl99 10y agoThe only reason I can think of, is you can use a USB-C-to-Lightning cable and use it as a fast charger for iPad Pro.
- dogma1138 10y agoEh? They can put the intended cable in the box, any other use you want to get out of it - bring your own cable. This is selling a device that is not fit for purpose especially since apple says to use their chargers and cables only.
- nicky0 10y agoThat's like saying they shouldn't sell cables on their own because they don't come with anything to plug them into.
- twiceaday 10y agoPerhaps most people who buy an adapter do it to replace an old one, so you can use the old cable. I prefer things modular like this. It lets me re-use / buy the right length cable for the use-case. The only problem I see is the price here.
- rincebrain 10y agoThe prior generation of MBP didn't use USB-C for laptop charging, though, so nobody except Macbook Air users would be doing this. (I don't know if all USB-C cables were required to be able to carry 87W, so I'd be slightly wary of reusing cables for that at the moment, too...) edit: someone downthread pointed out that the laptop itself comes with the USB-C cable you'd use for this, so this makes more sense now.
- x0x0 10y agoMy suggestion is there's 19 reasons times the number of people who buy a second or third charger...
- jsz0 10y agoThe best reasons I can think of are: 1. Combating e-waste. Pack-in cables are convenient but not always needed. 2. It encourages people to buy and use the appropriate length cable for their needs. With USB-C it's a lot harder to include a 'good for most people' length because the cable connected to the laptop for charging doesn't have to connect directly to the DC adapter.
- huangc10 10y agoThe Macbook (2016) itself does come with a USB-C cable for the power adapter right...? Does it?
- chrisl99 10y agoYes.
- NickHolt 10y agoYes - a fact that most people seem to be forgetting. People will be less apt to complain when they realize they don't have to replace their entire adapter when they wear down the cable as is the case now.
- dingaling 10y agoAlthough there was no technical reason that the old chargers had to have a moulded-on DC cable. In fact it may have been better from a usability and durability perspective if the DC cable had had a Magsafe connector at each end, one for the PSU and one for the laptop. And with that design they wouldn't have needed to introduce a new charger at all..
- quink 10y agoTwo complete power supplies for a MacBook Pro cost more than the ThinkPad my dad is running Creative Cloud and Visual Studio and whatever else on. With huge financial jump in the barrier of entry with these MacBook Pros, and with my Mac Mini no longer being supported with this release of mac OS why would I (and I suppose many others) still want to touch the Mac ecosystem with even a ten-foot pole? I think Apple is purposely squeezing the line dry for what they can still wring out before they'll jump ship to what can only be called iOS "Pro".
- nicky0 10y agoMacs sure are pricy.
- eridius 10y agoI'm pretty sure ThinkPads cost more than $160.
- quink 10y agoA$266 for two complete power supplies. I just hopped on eBay and surprisingly lightly used T- or X-series ThinkPads i5 and some i7 for under that price, shipped. Sure, they hold no candle to the MacBook's display. But when you could buy literally ten ThinkPads for a MacBook with effectively the same non-screen specs there's a bit of a gap there. And I've had way more problems with Apple build quality over the years than ThinkPads.
- eridius 10y agoTwo power supplies is $160. The extension cable isn't necessary, and the USB-C cable is just a generic USB-C cable that you can get from anywhere (and in fact you don't even need to get one if you just keep your existing cable with your laptop) And you're also comparing brand new top-of-the-line Apple equipment with used computers.
- quink 10y agoAlright, I guess I can only buy six or eight lightly used Core i7, 256GB SSD, 8GB upgradeable RAM ThinkPads for the cost of a MacBook Pro instead of 10. And you're calling a laptop with a Core i5 with integrated graphics "top-of-the-line". I guess top-of-the-line is a distorted concept when the absolute top of the line for the company hasn't been touched in 3 years and that I could outclass by a factor of three in every way for a third of the price. My point isn't that you can't afford it, good on you. My point is that the barrier of entry for your BRIC or even EU consumer or developer is going to be unreasonable. And sure, they're going to get their USB-C cables elsewhere. But that guy in Rio is meant to be paying... $4100 for the cheapest device with an official mac OS touch bar for the time being.
- dman 10y agoThis video explains the rationale from apples point of view - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XSC_UG5_kU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XSC_UG5_kU
- merb 10y agoI laughed my ass off :D
- gumby 10y agoIt's just a USB Type C brick. I have several (from various vendors including Apple) and use them with different (non-Apple) cables, including those with Type C on one end and micro A on the other. No big deal. Those adaptors should outlast your device and are hopefully relatively future proof.
- nicky0 10y agoThe gripe seems to be more with the price rather than the lack of a cable per se. Since they sell the cables too.
- tedunangst 10y agoI suspect one purpose of the gripe is to embed lots of amazon links.
- jakobegger 10y agoIt seems obvious that Apple is trying to reach iPhone-like levels of gross margin in the Mac lineup. Prices of the new Macbook Pros are getting ridiculous. I'm pretty sure that's why they are getting out of the display business; they wouldn't be able to sustain their ridiculous margins, so they leave that part to someone else.
- johansch 10y agoI think you nailed it. Their 40% gross profit margin is quite infuriating. Particularly since they're just milking the franchise by now, rather than actually innovating.
- oldmanjay 10y agoI'm ever curious about this topic - what do you define as innovation?
- johansch 10y agoInnovation means doing something new, doesn't it? The last Apple-ish innovation I saw out of Apple was that "magic" touch-pad that just feels like you're pressing it down, even though you are not. What they have done recently with the new Macbook Pro and iPhone 7 does not really qualify as "innovation" - they have reduced functionality (CPU power/battery and headphone jack, respectively) - and in turn made the goods thinner and prettier. Some people might say that OLED display they installed on top of the keyboard instead of old-school function keys might be an innovation. I disagree - it's not functional (it changes over time, non-newbies don't look at the keyboard, it kills muscle-memory), but it's so, so, pretty. Hence it's another step towards a piece of jewelry rather than something that just works.
- oldmanjay 10y agoThey did add an OLED touch bar that no other laptop has, to my knowledge. Does that not count? Why not?
- dcgoss 10y agoAccording to around 1:50 of https://youtu.be/zkOKtwiceVw https://youtu.be/zkOKtwiceVw, Apple hid the extension cable inside the box underneath everything else.
- simplexion 10y agoThis is a joke. There is definitely no extension cable. https://9to5mac.com/community/does-the-late-2016-macbook-pro-come-with-a-hidden-extension-cable/ https://9to5mac.com/community/does-the-late-2016-macbook-pro...
- smpetrey 10y agoWhoa whoa whoa that's awful packaging design
- nicky0 10y agoNot sure if that was a joke...
- jonah 10y agoThe actual product page says a cable is not included. http://www.apple.com/shop/product/MNF82LL/A/87w-usb-c-power-adapter http://www.apple.com/shop/product/MNF82LL/A/87w-usb-c-power-...
- desdiv 10y agoFYI if you right click in youtube you have the "Copy video URL at current time" option. Here's the video at 1:50: https://youtu.be/zkOKtwiceVw?t=110 https://youtu.be/zkOKtwiceVw?t=110
- eridius 10y agoWrong cable. That video is showing where the extension cable is, not the USB-C cable. And that's talking about the MacBook Pro itself, not buying the power adaptor as a stand-alone product.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tdkl 10y agoThey should just rebrand to Apple Accessories co. at this point, because the level of greed is unprecedented.
- micaksica 10y agoToo far? Apple is a luxury good. You are buying the Prada, the Audi/BMW/Benz/etc of laptops - they position themselves at the high end market and will extract as much margin as they can from that market. These price increases follow suit with their aspirational positioning. There is no "too far", just what their target market with a lot of discretionary income will still purchase.
- johansch 10y agoThere is a "too far". When it slides from being an expensive good tool to a very expensive luxury item mostly used for show. It's a lot easier to be pretty than to solve (new) problems. Of course, their watch foreshadowed all of this. They are not interested in solving problems; they want to turn into a Prada/Chanel/Hermes/LV style super luxury brand.
- micaksica 10y ago> they want to turn into a Prada/Chanel/Hermes/LV style super luxuary brand. The Watch Edition showed that there's a step too far for them, but it's not the definition you used. Nobody bought the thing. We had to get into the five figures for that to happen, though, and it's because Apple didn't fully understand the luxury watch market isn't entirely driven by how expensive the thing is. That said, Apple has been pushing the luxo market for quite some time, even before the watch. There has almost always been cheaper items than Apple products that fulfill roughly the same niche. iPhones are often a status symbol, and now having the newest one is, now that they are ubiquitous. The fact that they are somehow supremely useful sometimes falls out for the sake of design. Remember the little iPod shuffle that had absolutely no buttons that they marketed like jewelry? What about the headphone-less iPhone 7 or the Thunderbolt 3 / USB-C only new MBP? Going older, what about the 20th Anniversary Mac, the G4 Cube, or the iMac which didn't come with a floppy drive and nearly everyone bought that Bondi Blue SuperDrive thing?
- johansch 10y agoI think you're missing the point. We all looked to Apple for technical, user-focused innovation.. now all we're getting is a good-looking and expensive things that's best sold in a jewelers shop. I really can't see this working out for them in the long run. (In the short term, sure.)
- eridius 10y ago> But I discovered that Apple did have one more hidden extra cost in store for 2016 MacBook Pro buyers This seems like an extremely misguided article. The overwhelming majority of users don't buy extra power adaptors. I'd wager that most power adaptors that are purchased are to replace the old power adaptor (because it was damaged or lost). So no, this is not a hidden cost in store for MBP buyers, this is a "hidden cost" in store for the handful of people who like to buy 2 spare power adaptors to go with their brand new computer.
- j45 10y agoI have one for each of my desk setups at work and home. I don't think I'm the majority in any way but I don't think it's that uncommon either. USB-C cables are cheap enough anyways as long as you find one that can handle the power and amperage
- jackweirdy 10y agoSimilar here. I have one for home, one for traveling with. When the travel one starts to get too worn out, I'll swap them.
- eridius 10y agoEverybody that I've ever worked with (that uses an MBP) has an external monitor at work, and external monitors provide power so you don't need a separate charging brick.
- brazzledazzle 10y agoIsn't that limited to Apple displays?
- eridius 10y agoUSB-C/Thunderbolt 3 displays can do this too.
- j45 10y ago
- bhartzer 10y agoWon't there be third party vendors selling these adapters for much less? If it's just for travel I won't mind using one that's not from Apple.
- doe88 10y agoOne more time, this is greed. More than ever their North Star (to use an expression of T. Cook) seems to be greed. I'm lucky enough to have enough money to be able to buy their products but lately I seem to have reached a threshold where I think there is something really wrong with their behavior, I'm less and less inclined in enabling them by buying their stuff. First time in years I thought about switching back to Linux as my main system.
- reustle 10y agoWell, I'm at least excited that this cable is a separate piece. I'm tired of needing to get a new macbook charger every time the joint of the white thin wire and the brick gets bent out of shape.
- asp_hornet 10y agoThat's not the problem. The problem is there isn't one included with the charger. It doesn't need to be sold only included or only separately.
- reustle 10y agoI understand that problem, I was just pointing out the silver lining :)
- anonbanker 10y agoAuthor should read Thorstein Veblen's seminal work The Theory of The Leisure Class. There is no "too far" when it comes to conspicuous wealth.
- Keverw 10y ago> the $69 (13-inch model) or $79 (15-inch model) power adapter I wonder why they have two separate adapters and couldn't make one for both. Seems to add a bit of fragmentation.
- tylerwhipple 10y agoI do not know if the prices were different in the past, but 13" laptops previously used a 60W power adapter, while the 15" used an 80W
- Keverw 10y agoInteresting. I figured it was the same, like how the iPhone and iPhone Plus is the same... They should make a magic power adaptor. Since using USB C. If plugged in start charging it at like 60W and then once the computer is booted up it could use the data part of USB C to tell the adaptor to change if possible. Then when the cable is unplugged from the laptop or adaptor then go back to 60W... I also wonder if its any bad if people plugged their iPhone's into these power bricks too hmm.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- snowwrestler 10y agoUp to now, any Apple laptop could use any power adapter. I regularly plug my 2012 MacBook Air into the brick for my 2008 MacBook Pro. I will be VERY surprised if that is not the case anymore. Probably the main reason to build different bricks is so that the smaller lighter laptop also has a smaller lighter brick.
- pman2000 10y agoI don't really care that they're no longer bundling the 2 together. What I DO care about is having to pay $79 for a charger then another $20 for the cable. Those prices are just fked...