16 ms·
This article criticizes Facebook for firing the human editors that had been keeping things sane. However they were pushed to that by accusations of bias in the
by btilly 10y ago
This article criticizes Facebook for firing the human editors that had been keeping things sane. However they were pushed to that by accusations of bias in the right-wing media. Accusations that looked likely to lead to a Congressional investigation.
See, for example, http://thehill.com/policy/technology/279361-top-republican-demands-answers-over-alleged-facebook-political-bias http://thehill.com/policy/technology/279361-top-republican-d....
Now they are in a situation where they are damned if they do, damned if they don't. And people immersed in echo chambers will accuse them of bias no matter what.
But the entire system is fundamentally broken. Pay per ad incentives lead to rewarding viral content. And content that induces outrage is far more likely to go viral than pretty much anything else. Plus it goes viral before people do pesky things like fact checks. And the more of this that you have been exposed to, the more reasonable you find outrageous claims. Even if you know that the ones that you have seen were all wrong.
For an in depth treatment of the underlying issues, I highly recommend Trust Me, I'm Lying.
- rhizome 10y agoNow they are in a situation where they are damned if they do, damned if they don't On the topic of "don't," an unspoken option is that Facebook simply not try to do news. But the entire system is fundamentally broken... Why would they persist in the face of this? Hamartia?
- btilly 10y agoWhy would they persist in the face of this? Hamartia? "If you're not a part of the solution, there's good money to be made in prolonging the problem." See https://despair.com/products/consulting https://despair.com/products/consulting for the poster that I stole that from.
- ethbro 10y agoFacebook consumes too many eyeball hours not to do news.
- agildehaus 10y agoI think the solution to "damned if you do, damned if you don't" here is to just remove the stupid news sidebar.
- remarkEon 10y agoI imagine the news sidebar drives a lot of traffic. (I agree, though.)
- Bud 10y agoNo. The solution is to continue to provide news, to curate it, to shut down professional liars, and to tell the critics that if they don't like it, they are free to encourage their followers to use other social media.
- Terribledactyl 10y agoI just don't know where the cutoff is for professional or habitual liars. There are many ways to mislead, cherry picking data, methodological errors, straight up confusion and overwhelming technical data. Do we need to model the frequency of offense or severity? I'm not really going for the whole slippery slope aspect, more I feel like I'm miscategorizing the problem. Maybe the metadata on misinformation looks different from the real deal. How quickly does it spread, and through which people? No need to actually judge the content.
- Natsu 10y ago> shut down professional liars Would they really boot CNN? CNN told us this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_X16_KzX1vE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_X16_KzX1vE They were laughably wrong: https://popehat.com/2016/10/17/no-it-is-not-illegal-to-read-wikileaks/ https://popehat.com/2016/10/17/no-it-is-not-illegal-to-read-... Maybe one can claim it wasn't an intentional lie, but this guy is someone who really should have known better. So if it wasn't an intentional lie, they were negligent. Not sure where that leaves us.
- jerf 10y agoYes, trying to solve this problem by creating a definition of "misinformation" sufficiently precise to act on it for all possible articles, then trying to remove it somehow is probably an AI-complete problem. If it's not AI-complete it's probably just plain an ill-formed question. That's before we ask questions about the biases that get embedded into the misinformation detector. This can't be fixed at Facebook scales by building a platform that so highly incentivizes low-quality content of all kinds, then trying to stop the content so late in the cycle. The entire incentive structure has to be rethought. Unfortunately, that's probably a problem that Facebook is literally incapable of solving without going out of business, because Facebook the corporate entity is that incentive structure. To fix Facebook requires Facebook to become not-Facebook.
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoYes. We're talking about a platform that at it's best is birthday wishes, vacation and cat pictures. It's running on a paid content model, with advertisers selling through viral videos and click-bait. It's good not to expect too much out of it.
- Bud 10y agoWe're actually not; that's simply false. No, Facebook is not "at it's best" [sic] when it sticks to birthday wishes and cat pictures. It's actually at its best when it is truly social, in all senses of the word. When it facilitates real communication on real issues across a broad spectrum of people. When it spreads information, not misinformation.
- __jal 10y agoNot trying to speak for the original poster, but what I took away from the argument is that when FB is "truly social", involving real issues, the potential rewards are sufficiently high that misinformation becomes valuable, thus dangerous. When it sticks to birthdays and cat pictures, there's no incentive to go hostile. Think of it as being somewhat similar to the arguments about the Flash Crash regarding HFT and liquidity: that HFT is great for liquidity until you need it, at which point it goes away[1]. I agree with others that detecting misinformation in the general case likely requires a theory of mind, and so something approaching "real" AI. I also agree that FB has a serious problem on their hands. And I'm so very glad I don't use it. [1] I advance no comment here about the correctness of that; just a comparison to illustrate what seems like an overlooked point.
- txru 10y agoI think a lot of the problem arose because they kept the content editors close to home. A lot could be solved by just adding people to that department, located across the country in states where they already have offices anyway, or hire editors to work from home. That way, the editorial content wouldn't have to be so biased by region.
- tropo 10y agoThat would help. Another problem is the type of people who would take this job. They must be literate, but not able to find a better job. This will be people with degrees in English, journalism, and similar -- giving a pretty obvious political bias. You won't be getting mechanical engineers, coal miners, patent lawyers, and stock traders.
- vehementi 10y agoIt's a sign of the times that we shit on facebook's AI for not quite being smart enough
- guelo 10y ago> lead to a Congressional investigation. That really seems like "abridging the freedom of speech" to me. Constitutional conservatives sure love pushing the limits of the constitution when it inconveniences them. But, you know, the election is over so now that the right has total control we must all put aside our differences and work together.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoIt is kind of Orwellian to claim an investigation of suppression of speech is "abridging the freedom of speech." Nonetheless, it isn't the government's business, what Facebook does with its feed, and constitutional conservatives should recognize that. http://thehill.com/policy/technology/279498-some-conservatives-uneasy-about-facebook-inquiry-from-congress http://thehill.com/policy/technology/279498-some-conservativ...
- r00fus 10y agoThe original "bias squad" was not a first amendment issue. Facebook isn't the government (despite their incredible reach).
- weberc2 10y agoI think if they control 60% of the news pipeline (and climbing), they're categorically different. The U.S. government regularly investigates similarly large entities.
- caseysoftware 10y agoFacebook, et al, campaigned to have internet access be considered a utility instead of a luxury. The UN is pushing it as a human right. If you follow that line of reasoning, the companies who run the pipes and control the flow of information aren't just companies playing favorites. They're potentially influencing - if not outright regulating - human rights worldwide.. which means they should have a much higher level of scrutiny. And they walked right into that one.
- Bud 10y agoThere's a proper response to "accusations of bias" from alt-right white-nationalist thug media. Never mind whether the accusations "looked likely to lead to a Congressional investigation". The response is to tell them to fuck off, and that the professional editors in your private company will continue to do their job however they see fit. Period, paragraph.
- mozumder 10y agoCorrect. I don't know why editorial bias was a problem in the first place. Right now they have false-equivalency bias that drives fake stories.
- zeveb 10y ago> I don't know why editorial bias was a problem in the first place. Because, like it or not, Facebook has become a trusted news source. Because of that, they have a duty to accurately report the news. Their human editors fell down by vanishing stories they found politically uncomfortable. Their algorithmic editor fell down by promoting stories that were false.
- ssalazar 10y ago> Because, like it or not, Facebook has become a trusted news source. Because of that, they have a duty to accurately report the news. What other trusted news source has this "duty?" What other trusted news source does not have biased editors?
- zeveb 10y ago> What other trusted news source has this "duty?" All of them. > What other trusted news source does not have biased editors? None of them, of course. Man is a fallible creature. But other news sources try, most of the time, to be objective and accurate.
- dasil003 10y agoTelling people who aren't aligned to with the liberal intelligentsia to fuck off is exactly what got us in the current mess. Most people are reasonable, but when the reasonable and rational media ignores their issues, we leave the door open to demagogues and dictators. How else could a silver spoon like Donald Trump ever claim to represent the everyman?
- z_mollusk 10y ago"they were pushed to that by accusations of bias in the right-wing media." Accusations of bias? I think you mean to say that actual Facebook employees stated this as a fact. And the story was covered by ALL news outlets, starting with Gizmodo.
- tn13 10y agoAnd Zuckerberg meeting right wing leaders shows that there was great element of truth in it.
- unethical_ban 10y agoIt could also mean he was simply running damage control on a bullshit accusation he had no way of denying. If sites are spreading factually provable lies through Facebook as fact, and people are acting on it, should Facebook have any say in telling people "Hey, this is garbage"? It's an open question.
- dhimes 10y agoIt's also partly a constitutional question. I want my friends and I to be able to share articles we find in whatever press on FB. I'll filter by friend. (Mea Culpa: I haven't read TFA yet, so I may be missing some context.)
- gohrt 10y ago> ALL news outlets, starting with Gizmodo. That's like saying "the truth of this information is at least 0"
- denzil_correa 10y ago> Now they are in a situation where they are damned if they do, damned if they don't. And people immersed in echo chambers will accuse them of bias no matter what. You are making an assumption that algorithms can not be biased. Earlier, humans were biased. Now, algorithms are biased.
- wyager 10y agoProvided the data isn't wrong, we can typically put tight statistical error bounds on the output of various ML algorithms. Most people's understanding of how algorithms can be "biased" is completely wrong. There was a whole furor a while back about algorithms discriminating due to language differerences in the data for people of different races. Guess what; if you give race as a parameter to any half-decent algorithms trained on that data, the algorithm will learn that the written data contains those biases. Decent algorithms trained on true data are pretty much guaranteed to have results within a very very small margin of reality.
- denzil_correa 10y ago> Guess what; if you give race as a parameter to any half-decent algorithms trained on that data, the algorithm will learn that the written data contains those biases. You know what? Even if you do not give race as a parameter; an algorithm could be biased. It can easily learn race from secondary or tertiary parameters.
- wyager 10y agoI don't think you understood my post; giving race as a parameter allows ML algorithms to detect and counteract human racism. If an ML algorithm notices a disparity along e.g. racial lines, it's because it's actually there, not because a human imagined it.
- whybroke 10y ago> damned if they do, damned if they don't The level of damnation differs significantly. Having a human team being accused of bias (possible falsely) and pressured by politicians to change puts them in the same category as the NYT, the Wall Street Journal and every serious print and broadcast service on earth. Algorithmically spreading exciting and blatantly false claims puts them in the category of the National Enquirer, and 'The Protocols of the Elders of Zion' One category is significantly less damned than the other.
- strictnein 10y agoIt's amazing how much Trust Me, I'm Lying explains 90% of what you see shared on social networks these days. A great book, and still really relevant.
- grzm 10y agoNot only in social media. The trend of the news in what were once subscription-only papers is disturbing as well now that they're online and supported in part by online advertising and eyeballs. I agree. Great book, written by someone who's been there.
- razakel 10y agoJust a reminder that anyone in the UK or with an interest in UK politics should subscribe to Private Eye. Ian Hislop likely has the distinction of being the most-sued person in English legal history - almost entirely by people seeking libel writs in attempts to bury the truth. There is a podcast and selected content online. Funnily enough, it's the only periodical in the UK that has seen a rise in readership.
- DenverR 10y agoIt's seems pretty obvious to me that they replaced the human curated news section with a far (and intentionally) inferior product. They knew people would eventually begin complaining about the new system and ask for the old system back.
- tn13 10y agoHuman editors can separate sane from insane ? I dont think so. The recent presidential poll fiasco is prime example. All the large media houses like CNN, ABC, WaPo, NYT complete failed to detect and acknowledge the silent righ-wing voters claiming Clinton would win hands down. This is not just about political bias of the media but more importantly their complete failure to judge the pulse of the nation. In my opinion the main stream media was just insane here. On the contrary the media engaged in an active social bullying of conservative voters by calling them bigots,racists,misogynist and what not. Had this media been lot more sensitive and sane in understanding both liberal and conservative voters, had they focused on what issues really mattered to conservative voter-base instead of ridicule and bullying I am pretty sure it would have changed things. I blame the social bullying by main stream media as the prime reason why country seems divided.
- jonknee 10y ago> The recent presidential poll fiasco is prime example. All the large media houses like CNN, ABC, WaPo, NYT complete failed to detect and acknowledge the silent righ-wing voters claiming Clinton would win hands down. The fake news on Facebook is a whole different thing, it's easy to spot and literally news stories made specifically to game Facebook. It's insane that it has gotten this far. https://www.buzzfeed.com/craigsilverman/how-macedonia-became-a-global-hub-for-pro-trump-misinfo https://www.buzzfeed.com/craigsilverman/how-macedonia-became...
- kmtrowbr 10y agoI don't think the "bias" of mainstream media sources is solvable, it's not that problem we need to solve. The problem we need to solve is the sharing of hysterical, blatantly false information, presented as facts, from specific, intentionally propagandistic sites. And I wouldn't hide or disallow it, I would flag it with a warning message.
- brightball 10y agoIt seems like the best thing to do would be penalize a site if it shows verifiably false content until it both updates the original story and issues a retraction. Facebook could prioritize retractions in its algorithm and ensure that people who saw the original story would see the retraction as well. Content providers who abide by journalistic guidelines could be prioritized. Providers who actually have an editor could even associate the editor of each article with the post so that the editor's individual track record could be checked alongside the site itself, which would work better for large organizations who have multiple departments and don't deserve to be globally penalized for a single bad editor.
- caseysoftware 10y agoDo you really want Facebook in this role? I guess it works as long as you agree with their choices, prioritization, and opinions but as we saw this cycle, there was a collusion between "journalists" and the Clinton campaign. Even if you see no problem with that, would you see a problem if the Trump campaign had done it?
- brightball 10y agoNot particularly. Personally, I've always advocated for some type of "internet journalistic credentials" that could be embedded in meta tags to identify content producers, editors, originators and retractions according to a process of journalistic ethics that actually valued real journalism over content spam. Content originators over scraper and ad-farms. I'd honestly envision something closer to the BBB to manage this type of thing and track membership, ratings, disputes and resolution that all browsers and search engines could tap into. The key would be that freelance journalists would need to be able to gain membership in the same way that journalists get officially credentialed to cover different types of events.
- gohrt 10y agoThe BBB is just a way for angry consumer to snipe at vendors. It doesn't to any sort of investigation of issues, nothing close to Politifact or Snopes.
- millermp12 10y agoLet's create a Ministry of Truth. Then we can ban all those sites on homeopath, acupuncture, astrology, stereotype threat and all that other pinko voodoo (the bulk of social "science" papers come to think of it). Where do I sign the petition?
- throwawy64 10y agoThe Filter Bubble Ted talk is what motivated me to dump social media. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=B8ofWFx525s https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=B8ofWFx525s Gone are my Facebook, G+, Reddit accounts. I have a Twitter which I curate manually with numerous feeds from all over. I generally look at content like links first then read the Twitter discussion if any. I treat posting as a personal catharsis anymore, and use throwaway accounts. IMO my online opinions are going to get lost in the crush so why bother curating an identity. One that just creates a signal trail for advertising and snoopers? I talk to the people in my life more instead. These have been conscious decisions on my part and honestly I think I'm mentally happier and less frustrated "at the world" for it. MMS is good enough for sharing pics with grandma and grandpa. Though I've asked them to keep most off social media. It's too creepy having the world ogle my kids. They don't like it but abide. IMO despite being my mom she's old and has less life left than my kids. Nothing to worry about by posting her life on Facebook My kids on the other hand have their whole lives ahead of them. I would rather it not be broadcast without their consent. If they get older and decide to go all Jayden Smith or Paris Hilton on social media so be it. But these services are not what humanity needs to progress. They are today's fascination. And I am not into it. So fuck em
- pinaceae 10y agoFB would need to abandon the algo-driven feed altogether. yes, manual forwarding is bad, but that existed in the email days. nowadays you get all that suggested content which is driven by your past behavior, acting as a giant amplifier. to go back to something idlewords is harping about - all of that is possible because of the persistent storage of user data. kill the deep profiles, kill the tracking, only use what the user directly, willingly entered. in SV speak: utter heresy.
- popmystack 10y ago>However they were pushed to that by accusations of bias in the right-wing media. As per my previous comments on this subject. The sources that got "censored" _happened_ to be conservative. They were unreliable sources, and stories that turned out to be not true. But people still moaned about it. The fact that more conservative sources report false information seems like a problem conservatives should want to fix, instead of crying censorship. We have too much false information flying around; it's yellow journalism.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cynusx 10y agoI think that's a genuine concern, the only way I can think of that breaks this paradigm is by users to elect moderators. This would also give a platform to new and grassroot politicians to rise up over time. Right now, grassroot enthousiasm seems to flow towards senators (ron paul, bernie sanders,..) because they didn't vote for something most of the other senators voted for. Meanwhile having access to capital and connections to even become a senator is very constraint and unlikely to come without strings attached. Anyway, having users elect moderators solves the problem of "trusting the moderator" and since I assume they would be a salaried position facebook can apply and enforce fairness guidelines.
- DominikR 10y agoWhy exactly shouldn't it be beneficial if we let the market (the viewer) without any regulation decide which information should spread and which shouldn't? If people prefer seeing outrageous stuff then let them have it. The reason why governments and institutions want to control this is in order to control its people, all the other reasons given are just an attempt to mask this.
- htns 10y agoYou just don't have enough contempt for humanity. The masses are unaccountable and will lie as much as they think they can get away with. It won't help them. They will lose sight of their self-interests as they become more and more detached from the facts of the world.
- JabavuAdams 10y ago> Why exactly shouldn't it be beneficial if we let the market (the viewer) without any regulation decide which information should spread and which shouldn't? 1) It doesn't work. It leads to the lowest common-denominator winning. 2) Humans aren't rational. 3) The world is complicated enough that the median person simply doesn't know much about anything outside of their silo. 4) There are powerful forces conspiring to profit off of people's ignorance, rather than to turn them into less ignorant, more rational, more empathetic people, more curious people. 5) There are many people who simply aren't that curious. Left to their own devices, they will be overly susceptible to trickery and populism. This might be a nice idea in a socially homogeneous group of a small number of like-minded farmers. It fails surely and predictably in a large group trying to make good decisions in a complex and technical world. Read: Why Smart People Make Big Money Mistakes And How To Correct Them: Lessons From The New Science Of Behavioral Economics
- DominikR 10y agoIt doesn't matter if I am rational or not, it is my freedom to consume information from whichever source I prefer just as it doesn't matter if it's justified to spend double the money on an Apple product over something from a competitor. It's also irrelevant how you would like people to be (more rational, empathetic and so on), actually no one on this planet even cares about your opinion on that matter enough to actually change themselves. (and no one ever will, trust me) What matters is that people are free to choose to be whatever kind of person they want to be. Some of them choose to be persons that you don't like, well then don't be around them, issue solved. You seem to believe that we exist to follow some great plan devised by other people who believe they are smarter and know what we should actually be instead of what we choose to be. This is not the case. We've all seen the results of ideology that seeks to reach utopia by changing man into something elevated. (Soviet Union, Nazi Germany, North Korea, Rouge Khmer, Venezuela) It always failed in a catastrophic manner and caused often unimaginable suffering because of the authoritarianism inherent in this ideology.
- baybal2 10y agoYou can't win against clickfarmers and clickbait networks. No machine learning will save you from botters as the lion share of commercial botters live in a country from which most of the math research behind machine learning is coming from. In Russia, few people will start an advertising network startup in their sane mind, commercial scale clickfraud, farming, and botting give an order of magnitude higher returns. The term "Internet marketing business" is used mostly as an euphemerism for all of the aforesaid here.
- smsm42 10y agoThat's what happens when you try to control other's speech. You will be blamed for bias, and the worst thing the accusations would be completely correct, because humans are biased. Humans have opinions, humans have cognitive biases, humans are prone to groupthink and a long list of fallacies. It is extremely hard work to get even close to objectivity, let alone achieve it - professional scientists who are trained and have tons of tools to avoid biases still regularly fail and produce irreproducible results and wishful thinking papers that are then debunked - for somebody involved in politics where there's no such tools it's doubly hard. Hoping Facebook somehow magically solves this problem for us is naive at best.
- 69mlgsniperdad 10y agoMisinformation? They got caught using humans, to manually sort through the trending stories, and prune stories that were anti-Hillary. The stories they are referring to I'm guessing are wiki-leaks? Not fallacies, but instead, things that the authors didn't originally intend the public to see. There is a big difference. And the reason they had to stop tweaking the trending stories feed, was because they were creating a large mis-trust across their platform. They were literally doing the opposite of what this story claims..... They were censoring free speech, to further their agenda. What they were doing is no different then places like CNN claiming that certain Wikileaks are not based on fact. CNN went as far as to tell their viewers that it was illegal to read the Wikileaks emails. They claimed only employees of the media were permitted to legally read the emails. Facebook is now claiming that they should have censored things like wikileaks, without telling anyone, just delete them. However, CNN is not now claiming they should have told more people it was illegal to read the wikileaks that aren't true.(they were gmail dkim verified). But Facebook however now claiming that they should silently remove more stories which don't further their agenda. This is going to be a nightmare when shareholders start having an issue with stories like these. As soon as people start realizing the truth, people will flee the platform.
- 69mlgsniperdad 10y ago"This article criticizes Facebook for firing the human editors that had been keeping things sane." Read your comment. Let's think. What you mean is, Facebook fired human editors, who they contracted out moderation to. They contracted this job out, and kept it on the down low, because it was a breach of their promise with users of their platform. "keeping things sane." What exactly does this comment mean? What you mean by that, I assume, is 'don't allow anything to trend that might upset the leftist 'social justice warriors.' In other words, keeping things sane, meant don't allow posts to trend, that contradict, or prove false, the beliefs of the people whose primary mechanism of accomplishing agenda, is to 'get triggered' or to freak out, cause a scene, cry foul. The primary class of posts that could have or as Facebook claims 'should have' been censored, were Wikileaks. The Wikileaks were DKIM verified, and of reliable source. They were however not in the best interest of the left. They helped Donald Trump win. They spread the word, that Hillary Clinton was lying about a plethora of different things. These "Social Justice Warriors' believe that the US, themselves, and Hillary herself deserve to be president. Their response to people posting anti-Hillary ads, memes, leaks, or posts, is to flame them. Attack them. So what you are claiming, is that Facebook should have done a better job, of keeping things sane; a better job of limiting contradictory ads, statements, and shares from Hillary's opponent or opposing voters. Facebook was extremely sane during the weeks leading to election. Any insanity before election day I assume, was people have arguments or conversations on each others posts, discussing who to vote for. Are you suggesting that we should have silenced these debates? Are you suggesting we should have blocked Trump ads? I pushed a lot of content on Twitter and Facebook, and the majority of it was generated by users on Reddit. I have a list of 75 top ten trending Hashtags, which were removed from twitter by moderators. They were removed from the trending list. The list of 75 hashtags, are entirely non-violent, non-harrassing, and simply brief descriptions of illegal or unsettling things that Hillary Clinton said or did during her time in office. They are summaries of quotes from Wikileaks emails. Are you telling me that removing those hash tags was simply a peace-keeping measure? Are you saying that this was not blatant censorship to push Twitter's own agenda?
- the8472 10y ago> Now they are in a situation where they are damned if they do, damned if they don't. And people immersed in echo chambers will accuse them of bias no matter what. What if they simply change the algorithm to perform some graph clustering/principal component analysis on the stories that are shared organically among groups and then inject let's say 10% stories that are disproportionally shared by other clusters, but not this one? The granularity could be tweaked to chunk everything into let's say ~5 clusters per nationality and language. The machines do not have to assess facts, they just have to allow people to see beyond their friend-horizon. So call it the bubble-burster.
- shinamee 10y agoQuite sensible. The more options the better
- lerpa 10y agoThe solution is simple, stop being gullible and stupid trusting things you hear or read without something credible to back it up. Facebook has it's own bias, most people do. Some professional reviewers and political commentators try to be as unbiased as humanly possible, but why blindly trust them, even if that's their intention, there is nothing that say they cannot just be factually wrong.
- lalalandland 10y agoMaybe their AI should be trained to fact check stuff posted on Facebook? So if you post something that claim outrageous things, it would be visible right from the start that the claim is false.
- pmarreck 10y agoThere was a quote regarding this which I can't find, but paraphrased it was something like, "Bullshit flies halfway around the world before the truth has even gotten its pants on."