5 ms·
> "The librarian wants free content, and the copyright office is there to protect creators of content. They are diametrically opposed ideologies" Well, that's
by shakna 10y ago
> "The librarian wants free content, and the copyright office is there to protect creators of content. They are diametrically opposed ideologies"
Well, that's an insane viewpoint.
Creative Commons and free culture licenses exist to maintain both!
> "You don't make any money from recording music anymore," he said. "The streaming services have wiped out that revenue stream."
Ah. So your company has failed to keep pace with what your audience wants, and so is falling apart. Your answer is to use copyright like a sledgehammer, rather than trying to understand the current market.
- tzs 10y ago> Ah. So your company has failed to keep pace with what your audience wants, and so is falling apart. Your answer is to use copyright like a sledgehammer, rather than trying to understand the current market. "All we want is brand new, big-budget entertainment in our homes for nothing. Why doesn't Hollywood get that?" --Carl Carlson
- oxide 10y agoI can't remember the last time I bought a physical album. I think it was about 10 years ago, when Metallica's Death Magnetic came out. Everyone I know uses a streaming service to get music. No one I know buys or owns physical CD's, vinyl, etc. Because the music industry has failed to rise to the occasion, there are several services that have ascended to pop culture status while the traditional music industry is hemorrhaging. The suits who sign the checks need to change the business model, but since they either can't or won't, they'll probably just die off on the vine, eventually. music piracy is a direct result of the failure of the music industry to change with the times. if you offer a service that can compete with piracy, people stop pirating. that's what turned me from game pirate to Steam paying customer with over 300+ titles in my library. that's what turned me from TV pirate to Netflix subscriber. p.s. I don't think anyone ever made money from recording music, even when album sales were good. record labels have always taken the lions share of profits. this has nothing to do with artists making money IMO.
- ethbro 10y ago> record labels have always taken the lion's share of profits This is the problem I have with most of the whining about rates. Artist-driven equity, that I can get behind. But don't pitch me on a solution where we're avoiding the fact that modern technology can replace traditional promotion/distribution channels far more efficiently.
- walterbell 10y agoFlattr and Patreon have taken steps to separating payment from distribution. Someone will eventually build a distribution channel that allows "second screens" to be used for payment. This is not unlike attribution for advertising that leads to a sale. Instead of attributing advertising, we can attribute the actual content being used to lead to a payment. Why would someone "pay" for something they already "have"? Because payment is not for the last song, it's for the next song, to support what will be created by the artist. Sound strange? No, it's how Netflix and others fund content creation. Why can't fans do the same for their favored artist?
- snowwrestler 10y ago> if you offer a service that can compete with piracy, people stop pirating. But it doesn't solve the problem, because the #1 feature of pirated music is that it doesn't cost anything. A free streaming service doesn't cost anything either--but just like piracy, it also doesn't pay the artist anything. > p.s. I don't think anyone ever made money from recording music, even when album sales were good. record labels have always taken the lions share of profits. this has nothing to do with artists making money IMO. You are wrong. Source: my brother has been a recording artist for 20 years.
- shakna 10y agoSteam and Netflix do cost, but have verifiable impact in their industries. And they do pay their respective artists. The streaming service doesn't have to be free. But it does have to have a decent user experience.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 10y ago> Creative Commons and free culture licenses exist to maintain both! If a content creator has licensed her content under a free culture license, the job of the copyright office is to help her enforce that. > So your company has failed to keep pace with what your audience wants, and so is falling apart. Your answer is to use copyright like a sledgehammer, rather than trying to understand the current market. That would be a reasonable argument if the market set the price for streaming services. But to a significant extent it does not. For example, Pandora-style streaming is subject to mandatory licensing at prices set by the government.[1] Imagine that the government sets the price for wheat (as it has several times in our history). If the government sets the price of wheat too low, due to pressure by say cereal manufacturers who use wheat as an input to their profit-making activities, should we condemn the farmer for complaining about it? [1] http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/opinion/commentary/ct-jay-z-pandora-songwriters-compensation-copyright-justice-perspec-0402-20150403-story.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/opinion/commentary/ct-jay...
- jessaustin 10y agoWe'll probably condemn the government when no wheat gets grown. That has happened before, in many different countries. The problem the would-be professional musician has, is that amateur musicians never have to fuel up the tractor.
- ethbro 10y ago> That would be a reasonable argument if the market set the price for streaming services. But to a significant extent it does not. It's been a minute, but didn't CDs and records usually get sold at the same price point? Also, the article you linked is about songwriters, not performers (and happens to be co-written by one of its case studies for "I got paid far less than I think I should have" afaict). I was under the impression that Spotify allocated revenue according to total listens on individual tracks, which seems fair enough.
- chc 10y agoCDs and records were not sold on a basis that's comparable to Pandora. You had to buy a CD or a record — you didn't pay a fee and get unlimited pieces of CDs and records for the rest of the month.