3 ms·
These are the questions that would need to be answered by a hyperloop proponent, not me. The burden of proof is on the person making the claim. The only claim
by lisper 10y ago
These are the questions that would need to be answered by a hyperloop proponent, not me. The burden of proof is on the person making the claim. The only claim I'm making is that no one has proposed a solution. The two sentences that the Hyperloop white paper devotes to this issue is not a solution.
But what the hell, I need to get my mind off politics, let's do the math.
The fatigue limit stress for steel is about 200MPa. You'd want a 50% safety margin, so let's limit it to 100MPa (which also make the math a little easier). The maximum stress is in the middle of the run, where you are pushing or pulling against N/2 pylons on both sides. Pylons are spaced every 30m. LA to SF is ~450 km. Let's call it 300 to make the math easier. So that's 30k pylons.
There are two different tube designs: passenger only, and passenger plus vehicle. Let's just do passenger only. The tube diameter is 2.23m with a wall thickness of 20-23mm, so the cross-sectional area of the steel is 0.14-0.16 m^2. Let's call it 0.15. So the maximum tensile load we can tolerate is 15 mega-newtons, or about a kilonewton of differential stress per pylon.
The mass of the tube segment borne by each pylon is 0.15 x 30m x 8000kg/m^3 (density of steel) = 36 tons. The weight of this segment is about 350 kilonewtons. So you'd need a coefficient of friction no greater than 1/350. Interestingly, that seems to be just about what you can get out of an industrial roller bearing, so there is no way that you can get anywhere close to that from a sliding bearing.
I wasn't able to find cost figures for roller bearing capable of handling a 36 ton load. I'm sure they exist. I'm equally sure that they're pretty frickin' expensive and require a lot of maintenance.
- ash 10y agoWow, your calculations are totally awesome (and seem correct)! It looks like our estimation of "Hyperloop thermal expansion problem solution" feasibility now comes down to your last sentence: > I wasn't able to find cost figures for roller bearing capable of handling a 36 ton load. I don't know, railroad car steel wheel? Max load per axle for train cars: 26 - 40 ton. Searching on alibaba.com for "train car wheelset" and "train car bogie" never comes up with more than $2500 per piece. Maintenance seems doable, if we look at millions of train car running around the planet. > These are the questions that would need to be answered by a hyperloop proponent, not me. The burden of proof is on the person making the claim. The only claim I'm making is that no one has proposed a solution. The two sentences that the Hyperloop white paper devotes to this issue is not a solution. Yeah, I agree with that sentiment. Luckily, we are not the people making an actual practical decision on Hyperloop. Like you said, we are just trying to get our minds off politics.