4 ms·
Ummm, what's the legal theory that allows a US state to regulate out of state commerce like this? On the other hand, I wouldn't want to be a web company based
by hga 17y ago
Ummm, what's the legal theory that allows a US state to regulate out of state commerce like this?
On the other hand, I wouldn't want to be a web company based in Massachusetts and this might have more than a small effect on the Boston area's attractiveness to many startups.
- tzs 17y agoThe big thing with regulation of commerce is that a state can't do it in a way that favors in-state merchants over out-of-state merchants. This law appears to treat in-state and out-of-state merchants equally, so might be OK as for as regulation of interstate commerce law is concerned. (And it might not--this is a tricky area of law).
- dangrossman 17y agoIt would be the US Constitution, where it gives all rights that are not explicitly enumerated to the states.
- ggchappell 17y ago"... or to the people." Let's not forget that. (Not that it's terribly relevant to your point.)
- tomjen3 17y agoTrue, but the commerce clause is enumerated in the constitution.
- andrewf 17y ago--article snip-- I could wax eloquently on about the potential battle of states’ rights versus federal oversight and the potential for a Supreme Court challenge based on the Commerce Clause, but, this is an article for geeks, so I won’t go there. Instead, I’ll simply say once again: yikes. --snip-- It seems silly to state legalities are out of scope when you're talking about a law, even if (or, especially if!) you're not writing for lawyers.