6 ms·
Regardless of the reason, deliberate targetting, accidental "drive by DDoS" or bad configuration, the question that remains is "Why is the heating dependent on
by mrweasel 10y ago
Regardless of the reason, deliberate targetting, accidental "drive by DDoS" or bad configuration, the question that remains is "Why is the heating dependent on being online?"
It is completely reasonable if the heat system every so often "phones home", so report on usage, but it shouldn't actually stop working, if the network connection isn't available.
You can blame, DDoS, hackers, network outages, the Russians, I don't care, it doesn't cover up the fact that your system has a stupid design.
- ComteDeLaFere 10y agoNot sure why this is controversial. Boilers have an on/off switch, and when your company manages a large number of buildings, you automate and centralize on/off for efficiency's sake, no?
- ohyes 10y agoNo, you generally have a a control device on site. You probably also have some backup/safeguards in place in case the controller fails. In essential systems you have to build for robustness over efficiency.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mrweasel 10y agoThat fair enough, but in this case the heating system is directly attached to the internet. The correct way of designing something like this is having the heating system as one system and the management system as another. The management system can then receive information and MAYBE control some aspects of the heating system. If you remove or crash the management system, the heating system just reverts back to being a "dumb" heating system. My question is: Why in the name of all that is holy does the heating system stop working just because the remote management interface decides to reboot? This has to be design by the same idiots that believe that an in car infotainment system should be hooked up to the drive computer in a Jeep.
- digi_owl 10y agoa combo of cost cutting and safety requirements?
- robryk 10y agoWhat kind of incident could safety regulations be trying to prevent by forbidding a furnace from operating when remote control is unreachable?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lisivka 10y agoBlow of tank, fire.
- robryk 10y agoThere are other methods to prevent such occurrences: furnaces have "flame out of bounds" sensors and/or chimney flow sensors: this is very good at preventing the furnace from starting a fire of its own. If there's already a fire present, whether furnace decides to stop operating or not is usually irrelevant (you can get a gas leak from a damaged furnace even if it's off). I do not see why _remote_ control should be able to prevent a fire from starting: whatever is remotely controlling this furnace doesn't have more data than the furnace itself.
- lisivka 10y agoSo, circumvent your furnace control logic to burn at max rate when it receives no commands from it remote controller, then go somewhere for a week. Engineers are stupid people, you know.
- robryk 10y agoMy family has a furnace for heating water and the house. The furnace has a control unit that controls the burner and pumps. There is also a "manual operation" switch, to be used if the control unit fails, that simply switches everything on: pumps and the burner. The burner has a thermostatic control (that is set to a very high temperature and is essentially used to prevent it from boiling the water). So, in this case, "burn at max rate" _is_ the safe setting to be used when the controller dies. The only unsafe situation that it will cause is that the hot utility water will be scaldingly hot, but there will be no increased danger of fire nor of CO poisoning.
- EugeneOZ 10y ago1. Why russians? We actually neighbors (40 minutes from my home to Finland), we like them and we prefer to be friends with them. 2. Everybody can be smart after the case :) I'm sure now the'll design something more safe.
- Pxtl 10y agoRussian hackers are a meme right now because of their meddling in the US Election. They hacked the Clinton campaign's email system. There's also the recent spate of DDOS attacks traced to Russia, iirc.
- EugeneOZ 10y agoAfter Trump election you can forget about them.
- ComteDeLaFere 10y agoYeah, that's kind of the problem.
- ivan_gammel 10y agoA day after election 5 of Top 10 Russian banks were DDOSed by some IoT botnet. "Coincidence? I don't think so".
- EugeneOZ 10y agoYou don't understand difference between local hackers and government-paid hackers.
- ivan_gammel 10y agoI do understand it, of course. Regarding "coincidence", it was a kind of joke - a quote from top Russian propagandist Kiselev. ;)
- saucetenuto 10y ago
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agothis exact same thing happened to me in america. i had just bought a house and had a kid. the air conditioner was hooked up to a radio network device that was opt-in, and allowed the electric utility to remotely turn off certain blocks of users under heavy load. anyone who opted in got a % off their energy bill. well, in early may, i have a baptism and it turns out to be over 100 degrees and we have 50 people over. they had recently upgraded the radio system, and hadn't even turned it on for the year yet. i was told i had to pay them to swap it out because they refused to support it. i told them to fuck off. after a few more calls, and thankfully a state attorney general prosecutor who happened to be at the party, suddenly someone at the electric company found the old transmitter and turned it on, and had it send my air conditioner the ok to turn on. i haven't had a problem since. american infrastructure is a joke. you're all idiots.
- walshemj 10y agoGrossly incompetent not just stupid people could have died.
- bsder 10y ago> the question that remains is "Why is the heating dependent on being online?" 1) So they can bill you. 2) Bad design Billing is almost always the reason if the design is sane. And it's always a PITA. Bad design is self-explanatory. Most programmers think in terms of features rather than function. I have this discussion every day with people creating battery operated IoT devices. Me: "What is your most important function?" Them: "Well, we need to do <feature X>" Me: "<sighing> No. Your most important function is to protect your battery. If the device is dead, nothing else matters. Nobody should be able to make you drain your battery without your permission. After that consideration, you can do something useful."
- Freestyler_3 10y agoMostly bad design, it saves lots of money when developing and rolling out. They didn't even have a firewall.