4 ms·
Maybe some prisons can fundamentally change to becoming some sort of YMCA-like environment. I imagine a lot of the prisoners are non violent. If so, I wonder if
by Waterluvian 10y ago
Maybe some prisons can fundamentally change to becoming some sort of YMCA-like environment. I imagine a lot of the prisoners are non violent. If so, I wonder if you could co-mingle those who live at the "prison" with those who go for the social activities and whatnot.
- rwmj 10y agoThis sort of exists in the UK. When I was young I volunteered for CSV (now rebranded "Volunteering Matters"), but a good section, possibly 1/3rd of the people there were prisoners on day release or people who had been given (non-voluntary) community service as an alternative to prison. Quite good, you definitely got to meet all types of people. Sadly unlike the Simpsons joke I cannot trade my voluntary work against future crimes.
- gpvos 10y agoThey are doing something like that in Denmark. Seems to work well from what I've heard.
- john_reel 10y agoThat would be interesting. AA and NA meetings have undeniably helped a lot of people break addictions and turn their lives around. If a criminal justice system is to improve people's lives and many of these prisoners are in for drug and alcohol related reasons, it only feels logical to me that at the very least, these meetings should be an option. Come to think of it, if it worked out, I could see non-prisoners that feel they need help or could help others out going. While NA and AA meetings have the appeal of almost always being done in private, inconspicuous locations, I'm sure that at least a few people might still attend meetings held in a hypothetical YMCA-prison. It could help with situations like these where there is a lot of extra room in the prison. This might be best suited to drug rehab facilities, but I think that the idea could work anywhere with a receptive environment. It would probably be hard to give a prison of a good image though. According to comments here, it seems like similar systems already exist in some countries. If this is true, how effective have they been?
- Scarblac 10y agoIn the Netherlands there are also institutions for those who committed crimes but were held less responsible because of mental illness. To protect society and to treat them. Not quite as stict as prison, but they don't have freedom and are often violent. They can sometimes have social contact with the outside world, e.g. by having a football or chess team that plays in the league. Only home matches of course. I played chess against some of these people inside once, you do keep wondering what they did to be there...